Monk brain study: Ricard, Davidson and the gamma waves

Eight Tibetan Buddhist practitioners, ten students and a 128-electrode cap. What the famous 2004 gamma study found, and what it never claimed.

Matthieu Ricard, the French-born Tibetan Buddhist monk and co-author of the 2004 gamma study, in Paris in May 2009
Photo: Nicolas Richoffer, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The monk brain study that made headlines is Lutz, Greischar, Rawlings, Ricard and Davidson, "Long-term meditators self-induce high-amplitude gamma synchrony during mental practice", published in PNAS in November 2004. It recorded 128-channel EEG from 8 long-term Tibetan Buddhist practitioners (10,000 to 50,000 hours of practice) and 10 student volunteers during a compassion meditation, and found that the practitioners produced far stronger and more widely synchronised gamma activity (25 to 42 Hz), even at rest before they began. It was a striking result from a very small, non-random sample, and the authors themselves said it could not show that meditation caused the difference.

Key takeaways
  • 8 vs 10: long-term Tibetan practitioners against student volunteers, in PNAS, November 2004.
  • 25 to 42 Hz gamma was higher in practitioners even at rest, and rose further during compassion practice.
  • r = 0.79 between estimated lifetime practice hours and baseline gamma, the paper's only significant correlation.
  • Not causal: the authors said pre-existing traits could explain the gap.
  • r = 0.33 in the larger 2017 Rishikesh replication: the effect held in direction but shrank.

The study is often summarised as "monks rewire their brains" or "Matthieu Ricard is the happiest man in the world". Neither line is in the paper. This post rebuilds the story from the paper itself, the history of the Mind and Life dialogues that set it up, and the replications that followed, including one recorded in Rishikesh and one from the Indian Institute of Science in Bengaluru.

How did a monk end up in a neuroscience lab?

The route ran through the Dalai Lama's long interest in science and a series of private meetings called the Mind and Life dialogues. The first was held in October 1987 at his residence in Dharamshala, a week-long conversation with six scientists that included the Chilean neuroscientist Francisco Varela.

The organiser was R. Adam Engle, and in 1991 the group incorporated as the Mind and Life Institute to fund more meetings and, later, research.

The story

In 1992, Richard Davidson, a neuroscience professor at the University of Wisconsin–Madison, stood waiting outside the Dalai Lama's residence-in-exile in Dharamshala. He had been summoned by a faxed letter. By his own account he was a "closet meditator", and while he waited he felt the symptoms of panic rising.

The letter had been blunt in spirit: the Dalai Lama was tired of brain research that studied only fear, anxiety and depression, and wanted scientists to turn the same tools on kindness and compassion. Davidson later said he had no good answer to why they had not. Twelve years later, the compassion meditation in the 2004 gamma paper came out of his lab.

Waisman Center, University of Wisconsin–Madison: The world wide web (2013)

From talk to experiment

The turn from talk to experiment came in 2000. At the dialogue on destructive emotions that year, the Dalai Lama suggested that contemplative practices be studied in the lab rather than only discussed.

Davidson, an affective neuroscientist, was one of the scientists who took up that challenge. His lab began recording long-term practitioners whose training could be counted in tens of thousands of hours.

Why Matthieu Ricard

Matthieu Ricard was the obvious bridge. Born in France in 1946, he finished a PhD in molecular genetics at the Institut Pasteur under the Nobel laureate François Jacob in 1972, then left science to study Tibetan Buddhism in the Himalayas.

He lives at Shechen monastery in Nepal and appears on the 2004 paper as a co-author with a Shechen Monastery affiliation. He could translate between a lab protocol and a meditation instruction, which is exactly what the experiment needed.

Buddhist monks seated in rows performing a fire puja at the Lamayuru meditation centre in Ladakh
Monks at the Lamayuru meditation centre in Ladakh. The 2004 study recruited practitioners from two Tibetan lineages, Nyingma and Kagyu, with training estimated at 10,000 to 50,000 hours.Photo: No machine-readable author provided. Deeptrivia assumed (based on copyright claims)., CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

What exactly did the 2004 PNAS gamma study do?

The design was simple: record brain rhythms from experts and beginners while both groups rested and then meditated. The details matter because they decide what the result can mean.

FeatureLong-term practitionersControls
Number810
Mean age49 (SD 15)21 (SD 1.5)
Training10,000 to 50,000 hours over 15 to 40 years (estimated)One week of instruction, about 1 hour a day
TraditionTibetan Nyingmapa and KagyupaNone; had expressed interest in meditation
Practice recordedObjectless "unconditional loving-kindness and compassion", alternating with neutral rest
Recording128-channel Geodesic Sensor Net, 500 samples per second

The two measures

The team measured two bands. Gamma was defined as 25 to 42 Hz, the fast rhythm associated in earlier work with binding perception and attention. Slow activity was defined as 4 to 13 Hz.

  • Gamma ratio: gamma power divided by slow power, the main measure.
  • Phase synchrony: whether gamma oscillations at distant electrodes rose and fell together.

Because scalp gamma overlaps with the electrical noise of muscles in the face and neck, the authors also measured power at 80 to 120 Hz as a marker of muscle activity and adjusted for it. That step is the reason the paper is still taken seriously, and also the reason it is still argued over.

Which frequencies each study measured 4132542608090110120 Frequency, Hz (cycles per second) Slow 4–13 Hz (2004) Gamma 25–42 Hz (Lutz 2004) Gamma 60–110 Hz (Rishikesh 2017) Muscle marker 80–120 Hz
The 2004 and 2017 studies looked at different parts of the gamma range, and the 2017 band overlaps the region where face and neck muscle noise is strong. That is why "higher gamma" is a family of findings, not one number. Bands from Lutz et al. 2004 and Braboszcz et al. 2017.

What did the monks' brains actually show?

The practitioners had a higher gamma-to-slow ratio than the students before meditation even began, and the gap widened during compassion practice. The baseline difference was strong (t = 4.0, P < 0.001), and it held when the three youngest practitioners were compared with the students (P < 0.05), a check against age as the explanation.

8 vs 10practitioners vs student controls
25–42 Hzgamma band the study measured
30-foldlarger muscle-adjusted gamma rise in practitioners
r = 0.79hours of practice vs baseline gamma
  • During meditation: the gamma ratio rose by more than twice its baseline standard deviation in all eight practitioners and in only two of the ten students.
  • After the muscle adjustment: the authors report a gamma increase more than 30-fold greater in practitioners than in controls.
  • Synchrony: practitioners showed larger long-distance phase synchrony, and it rose more from rest to meditation than in controls. One practitioner showed about a 30% rise in synchrony across the two hemispheres.
  • Dose: estimated lifetime hours (9,855 to 52,925 among the practitioners) correlated with baseline gamma at r = 0.79. Age did not (r = 0.23). It was the only significant correlation the paper reports.

Put plainly, the people with the most practice had the most gamma at rest, and they could raise it on demand. That is why the paper was read as evidence of a trait, a lasting change, and not only a temporary state.

What the 2004 study comparedhighlowBaseline restCompassionNeutralCompassion8 long-term practitioners10 student controlsSchematic only: shape of the reported effect (gamma/slow ratio), not plotted data.
A schematic of the finding in Lutz et al. (2004): practitioners started higher, rose further during compassion blocks and stayed high in neutral blocks. The curve shapes are illustrative, not the paper's data points.

Did the study prove that meditation changes the brain?

No, and the paper says so. The authors wrote that the group differences could reflect traits the practitioners had before they ever meditated, and that only longitudinal and randomised studies could show that training causes the gamma signature. The list of confounds in their own discussion is long:

  • Sample size. Eight practitioners and ten controls is small for any EEG effect, let alone a headline about human potential.
  • Age and culture. The groups differed in age by almost three decades, and also in culture, first language and probably diet and sleep.
  • Estimated dose. Lifetime hours were reconstructed from daily practice and retreat time, not logged.
  • Thin control training. One week of instruction is not a fair comparison for a skill measured in years.
  • Muscle artefact. Scalp gamma can be contaminated by muscle activity. The 80 to 120 Hz adjustment reduces that risk; it does not remove it.
  • Unknown function. The paper notes that the functional consequences of sustained high gamma were unknown.
High gamma is a signature, not a definition of a kinder or happier mind.

There is one more caveat worth stating: high gamma is a signature, not a definition. A brain rhythm that rises during compassion practice does not tell you whether the person is kinder, calmer or happier. Those are separate questions that need behavioural measures.

Where did the "happiest man in the world" label come from?

It came from the press, not from the paper. Ricard took part as a volunteer in Wisconsin research on emotion and scored far above the average of hundreds of volunteers on a measure linked to positive emotion, and newspapers turned that into a title.

Ricard has called the label absurd. The 2004 PNAS paper does not rank anyone's happiness and does not single out an individual as a record holder.

The legend also inflates the sample. Popular accounts speak of "monks" in the plural and imply a large group. The paper had eight practitioners, and the most-cited numbers are group statistics.

An EEG recording cap with many electrodes fitted on a person’s head
An EEG cap. The 2004 study used a 128-channel net; the 2017 Rishikesh study used 64 scalp channels. Gamma recorded at the scalp has to be separated from face and neck muscle noise.Photo: Chris Hope, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Why did neuroscientists protest the Dalai Lama in 2005?

A year after the paper, the Society for Neuroscience invited the Dalai Lama to give the first lecture in a new series on neuroscience and society at its November 2005 meeting in Washington, DC.

Several hundred researchers signed a petition asking the society to withdraw the invitation, arguing that the meditation science was thin and that a religious leader did not belong on the programme. The society kept the lecture and said the talk would not be about religion or politics. Some of the objection was also political, given the Dalai Lama's position on Tibet.

The episode is useful because it shows how early the field was. By 2005 the evidence for trait changes rested on a handful of small studies like Lutz et al. Supporters saw a promising lead; critics saw a lead being sold as a finding. Both were reacting to the same thin evidence.

Has anyone replicated the gamma finding?

Partly. Later studies have repeatedly found higher gamma in experienced meditators than in controls, but in different bands, regions and practices, which makes it a family of findings rather than one clean replication.

Participants in four meditation gamma studies
See the data as a table
Meditators (people)Controls (people)
Lutz 2004 (Madison)810
Braboszcz 2017 (Rishikesh)4816
Lee 2025 (Chan monks)2018
IISc 2026 (Bengaluru)3030

Source: Lutz et al. PNAS 2004; Braboszcz et al. PLOS ONE 2017; Lee et al. Behavioral Sciences 2025; IISc release on Biswas et al. 2026 · Braboszcz: 16 analysed per group across three traditions. Lee: male monks vs male novice lay practitioners.

StudyWherePracticeGamma resultMain limit
Lutz et al., PNAS 2004Madison, USATibetan compassionHigher 25–42 Hz ratio and synchrony; r = 0.79 with hours8 vs 10; age gap; muscle artefact
Braboszcz et al., PLOS ONE 2017Rishikesh, IndiaVipassana, Himalayan Yoga, Isha ShoonyaHigher 60–110 Hz parieto-occipital gamma in all three groups; r = 0.33 with log hoursSelf-selected; single time point; neck muscles not controlled
Lee et al., Behavioral Sciences 2025Hong Kong team (PolyU)Chan Can-Hua-Tou inquiryTrait-like fronto-parietal gamma (30–45 Hz) increase in monksGroup × condition interaction not significant after correction
Biswas et al., Imaging Neuroscience 2026IISc, BengaluruBrahma Kumaris Rajyoga, eyes openStronger stimulus-induced gamma and broadband gammaCross-sectional; matched pairs, not randomised

The Rishikesh study is the strongest of these on artefacts: it used independent component analysis to check that eye and muscle signals did not explain the gamma, while admitting that eye-related components still correlated with gamma power. Its correlation with practice, r = 0.33, is far weaker than the r = 0.79 in the original eight. That shrinkage is what usually happens when a small study's effect is tested in a bigger sample.

What does the gamma story mean for an ordinary meditator?

Very little directly, and that is the honest reading. Every study above compares people with thousands of hours against people with almost none. None tells you what 20 minutes a day for eight weeks will do to your EEG, and none shows that more gamma makes daily life better.

What the work does support is narrower: long-term contemplative practice is associated with measurable, repeatable differences in brain rhythms, and the differences grow with practice in the studies that measured dose. Whether the practice causes them is still open.

Where to look instead

If you want the evidence on beginner-level outcomes such as stress, attention and sleep, the better sources are randomised trials, which I cover in does meditation change the brain? and meditation techniques ranked by evidence. The longer arc, from 1930s yogis in Indian labs to fMRI, is in the history of meditation research.

The Indian thread in this story is worth noticing. Two of the four studies above were recorded in India, on Indian traditions, and one came from the Centre for Neuroscience at IISc in Bengaluru. The field that began with a Tibetan practitioner flown to Wisconsin is now partly being done at home. For the practice most of those Rishikesh meditators follow, see whether a 10-day Vipassana course is worth it, and for Vipassana inside an Indian prison, the Tihar Jail course.

Thiksey Monastery, a white Tibetan Buddhist monastery complex climbing a hillside in Ladakh
Thiksey Monastery in Ladakh. India now hosts some of the replication work: the 2017 gamma study was recorded in Rishikesh and the 2026 one at IISc, Bengaluru.Photo: Bernard Gagnon Canon EOS REBEL T4i, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Long-term meditators self-induce high-amplitude gamma synchrony during mental practiceLutz, Greischar, Rawlings, Ricard, Davidson · PNAS · 2004

Eight long-term Tibetan Buddhist practitioners (mean age 49, 10,000 to 50,000 hours) and ten students given one week of training were recorded with 128-channel EEG during compassion meditation and rest. Practitioners had a higher gamma-to-slow ratio at baseline (P < 0.001), a muscle-adjusted gamma rise more than 30 times that of controls, larger long-distance synchrony, and baseline gamma that tracked practice hours (r = 0.79). Limits: tiny sample, large age and cultural gaps, estimated hours and possible muscle artefact; the authors say causation is not shown.

Read the paper (free)
Increased gamma brainwave amplitude compared to control in three different meditation traditionsBraboszcz, Cahn, Levy, Fernandez, Delorme · PLOS ONE · 2017

Recorded at the Meditation Research Institute in Rishikesh with 64-channel EEG: practitioners of Vipassana, Himalayan Yoga and Isha Shoonya (16 analysed per group, from 67 recruited) against 16 controls, during meditation and instructed mind-wandering. All three meditator groups showed higher 60–110 Hz parieto-occipital gamma than controls (group effect p = 0.03), and gamma correlated with log lifetime meditation hours (r = 0.33). Limits: self-selected participants, one time point, posture differences and no control of neck muscles.

Read the paper (free)

What's new

Questions people ask

Did the study show that meditation rewires the brain?

It showed that eight people with very long practice had different EEG rhythms from ten beginners, and that the difference scaled with practice hours. It did not follow anyone over time, so it cannot show that practice changed their brains. The authors said this themselves.

Is Matthieu Ricard really the happiest man in the world?

That label was coined by newspapers after Ricard scored unusually high in Wisconsin emotion research. No study measures a "happiest person", and Ricard has called the title absurd. He is a co-author of the 2004 gamma paper, which reports group results.

What are gamma waves?

Gamma is the fastest common brain rhythm on EEG, usually defined from about 25 to 30 Hz upward. The 2004 study used 25 to 42 Hz and the 2017 Rishikesh study used 60 to 110 Hz. Gamma is linked to attention and to binding perceptions together, but scalp gamma is easily confused with muscle noise, so studies must correct for it.

Can beginners raise their gamma by meditating?

In the 2004 study, only two of the ten students showed a gamma rise of more than twice their baseline variation, against all eight practitioners. There is no good evidence yet that short courses produce the same signature.

Sources

  1. Lutz A, Greischar LL, Rawlings NB, Ricard M, Davidson RJ: Long-term meditators self-induce high-amplitude gamma synchrony during mental practice, PNAS 101(46) (2004)
  2. Braboszcz C et al.: Increased gamma brainwave amplitude compared to control in three different meditation traditions, PLOS ONE 12(1) (2017)
  3. Lee KCG et al.: Neural pattern of chanting-driven intuitive inquiry meditation in expert Chan practitioners, Behavioral Sciences 15(9) (2025)
  4. Indian Institute of Science: Meditation strengthens gamma oscillations in the brain (2026)
  5. Waisman Center, UW–Madison: Davidson's 1992 meeting with the Dalai Lama in Dharamshala (2013)
  6. Wikipedia: Mind and Life Institute, history of the dialogues (accessed 2026)
  7. Wikipedia: Matthieu Ricard, with references to The Independent (2007) and The Guardian (2023) (accessed 2026)
  8. Mind Hacks: Dalai Lama to lecture on neuroscience amidst protests (2005)
  9. Scoop: Scientists argue over planned Dalai Lama lecture (2005)
gamma wavesMatthieu RicardRichard DavidsonMind and LifeEEGcompassion meditationcontemplative neuroscience
Sapta

Sapta (Saptarshi Sarkar) is a mechanical engineer turned marketer in Bengaluru and a solo touring rider. He writes the seven Saptaverse blogs. Work with him or read more of Mindblog.

Keep reading in Mindblog

From the other blogs