Modern meditation research began with Robert Keith Wallace's 1970 paper in Science on Transcendental Meditation, which measured falling oxygen use and heart rate during practice. Herbert Benson recast it as the "relaxation response" in the 1970s, Jon Kabat-Zinn's mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR, 1979) moved it into hospitals, and brain imaging from the 2000s made it famous. PubMed papers mentioning meditation or mindfulness rose from 6 in 1970 to 3,266 in 2025, but the largest and best-controlled studies since 2014 show real, modest benefits and fewer dramatic ones.
- 1970: Robert Keith Wallace's Science paper on TM starts the modern field.
- 6 to 3,266: PubMed papers on meditation or mindfulness, 1970 vs 2025.
- 0.38: Goyal's 2014 effect size for anxiety at 8 weeks, real but modest, and no better than other active treatments.
- 218 people, no change: the 2022 MRI trial found no structural brain effect from 8 weeks of MBSR.
- About 30% of meditators in a 2025 US survey reported a challenging or distressing effect.
The field's history is a useful case study in how science treats an exciting claim. Each era started with small, enthusiastic studies, often by practitioners, and ended with bigger trials that kept some of the claim and dropped the rest.
The eras, in short:
- Physiology, 1966 to the 1970s. EEG and oxygen measurements of Zen and TM meditators.
- Clinic, 1979 to 2000. MBSR and MBCT turn meditation into a standard eight-week course.
- Imaging, 2004 to 2011. Small brain studies make meditation famous.
- Correction, 2014 to now. Meta-analyses and large trials shrink the claims and start counting harms.
This post walks through the eras with the landmark papers, their sample sizes and their numbers.
When did scientists start studying meditation?
Measurements of meditators predate 1970, including an EEG study of Zen meditation by Akira Kasamatsu and Tomio Hirai, published in 1966. But the field took off with Robert Keith Wallace's "Physiological effects of transcendental meditation" in Science on 27 March 1970.
Wallace recorded oxygen consumption, heart rate, skin resistance and EEG before, during and after practice and reported that:
- oxygen use and heart rate fell;
- skin resistance rose;
- EEG frequencies shifted.
The timing mattered. Maharishi Mahesh Yogi's TM movement was at its peak of Western fame, and TM was easy to study: a standardised mantra technique, taught in a fixed course, with thousands of willing practitioners.
In 1971 Wallace, Herbert Benson and Archie Wilson followed up in the American Journal of Physiology with "A wakeful hypometabolic physiologic state", the idea that meditation produced a distinct state of deep rest while awake.
What was Benson's relaxation response?
Herbert Benson, a Harvard cardiologist, argued that TM's effects were not unique to TM. Any technique with three ingredients would trigger the same physiological shift:
- a repeated word or phrase;
- a passive attitude to distracting thoughts;
- a quiet setting.
He called that shift the relaxation response, the opposite of the fight-or-flight reaction. His 1975 book The Relaxation Response turned that into a secular, mantra-free method and a bestseller.
Benson had come back to Boston in 1965 and set up a lab at Boston City Hospital to study blood pressure. He had trained monkeys to raise and lower their own blood pressure, a challenge to the belief that the stress response could not be reversed. Then young practitioners of Transcendental Meditation came to him, convinced that their meditation had lowered theirs, and asked to be studied.
He agreed reluctantly. He doubted meditation did anything, and he worried what his colleagues would think. So he led what Tricycle later called a double life: day jobs by day, meditators tested at night. The measurements changed his mind. Heart rate, breathing rate and blood pressure fell in ways he called striking, and the work became the relaxation response.
Tricycle: Herbert Benson dies (2022)Benson's move set the template for the next fifty years: strip a contemplative practice of its religious or commercial packaging, standardise it, and test it on a clinical problem.
His group applied it to hypertension, anxiety and headache; a 1974 paper in Headache reported its use in headache therapy. Indian laboratories had been measuring yogis since earlier decades, a story told in Kuvalayananda and the first yoga labs.

How did mindfulness enter medicine?
Through Jon Kabat-Zinn's Stress Reduction Clinic at the University of Massachusetts Medical Center, founded in 1979. He built a 10-week (later 8-week) group course of mindfulness meditation and gentle yoga for patients that conventional medicine had not helped, and called it Stress Reduction and Relaxation, later MBSR.
The first MBSR report
His first report, in General Hospital Psychiatry in 1982, studied 51 chronic pain patients. At 10 weeks, 65% of them reported at least a one-third reduction on the McGill pain rating index and 50% at least a halving, with large drops in mood disturbance. Kabat-Zinn was candid that the study was uncontrolled.
MBCT for depression
In 2000, John Teasdale, Zindel Segal and Mark Williams adapted MBSR into mindfulness-based cognitive therapy (MBCT) for recurrent depression and tested it in a randomised trial of 145 recovered patients over 60 weeks. It cut relapse risk in those with three or more past episodes (77% of the sample) but not in those with two.
| Year | Study | Design and sample | Main finding |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1966 | Kasamatsu and Hirai, Zen EEG | EEG of Zen meditators, Japan | Characteristic EEG changes during zazen |
| 1970 | Wallace, Science | Physiological recordings of TM practitioners | Oxygen use and heart rate fall during TM |
| 1971 | Wallace, Benson, Wilson, Am J Physiol | Metabolic measurements | "Wakeful hypometabolic" state |
| 1982 | Kabat-Zinn, Gen Hosp Psychiatry | 51 chronic pain patients, uncontrolled | 65% had 33%+ pain reduction at 10 weeks |
| 2000 | Teasdale et al., J Consult Clin Psychol | RCT, 145 recovered depressed patients | MBCT cut relapse with 3+ past episodes |
| 2004 | Lutz, Ricard, Davidson et al., PNAS | EEG, long-term Buddhist practitioners vs controls | High-amplitude gamma synchrony |
| 2005 | Lazar et al., Neuroreport | MRI, 20 experienced meditators vs controls | Thicker prefrontal cortex and insula |
| 2011 | Holzel et al., Psychiatry Res Neuroimaging | MRI, 16 MBSR vs 17 waitlist | Grey-matter increases incl. left hippocampus |
| 2014 | Goyal et al., JAMA Intern Med | Meta-analysis, 47 RCTs, 3,515 people | Moderate effects on anxiety, depression, pain |
| 2022 | Kral et al., Science Advances | Two RCTs, 218 people, active control | No structural brain change from MBSR |
| 2022 | Kuyken et al., MYRIAD | Cluster RCT, 84 schools, 8,376 students | School mindfulness no better than usual teaching |
| 2025 | Van Dam et al., Clin Psychol Sci | Survey of about 900 US meditators | About 30% had a challenging or distressing effect |
What did the brain-imaging era claim?
From 2004, imaging made meditation look like brain training. Antoine Lutz, Richard Davidson and colleagues reported in PNAS, with the monk Matthieu Ricard as a co-author, that long-term Buddhist practitioners could self-induce sustained high-amplitude gamma-band synchrony on EEG, a story told in the monk in the scanner.
In 2005 Sara Lazar's group at Massachusetts General Hospital found thicker prefrontal cortex and right anterior insula in 20 experienced insight meditators than in matched controls.
The 2011 headline
The headline that launched a thousand articles came in 2011. Britta Holzel, Lazar and colleagues scanned 16 meditation-naive people before and after an 8-week MBSR course and 17 waitlist controls, and reported grey-matter density increases in the left hippocampus, posterior cingulate, temporo-parietal junction and cerebellum.
Media coverage turned that into "eight weeks of meditation rebuilds your brain", the claim behind the Reddit thread that asks whether a Harvard neuroscientist really showed it.
See the data as a table
| Papers (papers) | |
|---|---|
| 1970 | 6 |
| 1975 | 30 |
| 1980 | 37 |
| 1985 | 25 |
| 1990 | 22 |
| 1995 | 32 |
| 2000 | 46 |
| 2005 | 117 |
| 2010 | 354 |
| 2015 | 1024 |
| 2020 | 1977 |
| 2021 | 2368 |
| 2022 | 2710 |
| 2023 | 2467 |
| 2024 | 2689 |
| 2025 | 3266 |
Source: PubMed (NCBI), search (meditation[tiab] OR mindfulness[tiab]) by publication year, run 11 Nov 2026 · Counts papers with the words in title or abstract; papers from before the mid-1970s often lack abstracts and are undercounted.
What did the big meta-analyses find?
The turning point was a 2014 systematic review by Madhav Goyal and colleagues at Johns Hopkins in JAMA Internal Medicine, which kept only randomised trials with active controls for placebo effects. From 18,753 citations they included 47 trials with 3,515 participants.
| Strength of evidence (Goyal 2014) | Outcomes |
|---|---|
| Moderate | Anxiety, depression, pain |
| Low or insufficient | Positive mood, attention, sleep, substance use, eating, weight |
The team searched nine databases to November 2012 and kept 47 randomised trials (3,515 participants) that used an active control. Mindfulness programmes improved anxiety with an effect size of 0.38 at 8 weeks and 0.22 at 3-6 months, depression 0.30 and 0.23, and pain 0.33. Evidence for stress and quality of life was low, and for attention, positive mood, sleep, substance use, eating and weight it was low or insufficient. Crucially, meditation was no better than other active treatments such as drugs, exercise or other behavioural therapies. The limit: most trials were small and short, and outcomes were mostly self-reported.
Read the paper (free)An effect size of 0.3 is real but modest: roughly the size of many other psychological treatments, much smaller than the "rewire your brain" coverage implied.
In 2018, 15 researchers led by Nicholas Van Dam published "Mind the Hype" in Perspectives on Psychological Science, warning that loose definitions of mindfulness, weak methods and media spin risked misleading the public. Several of the co-authors, including Sara Lazar, were themselves leaders of the field.
Does meditation change brain structure? What the large trials show
The best-controlled test so far says the 8-week MBSR course does not measurably change brain structure. In 2022 Tammi Kral, Richard Davidson and colleagues combined two randomised trials: 218 meditation-naive adults were scanned before and after being assigned to MBSR (75), a matched active health programme (73) or a waitlist (70).
They found no MBSR effect on grey-matter volume, grey-matter density or cortical thickness, either across the brain or in the regions earlier studies had highlighted.
This study is a direct test of the 2011-style claim, run by one of the labs most associated with meditation neuroscience. With 218 participants, three arms including an active control, and pre-registered regions of interest drawn from prior MBSR studies, it is the largest and most rigorous structural MRI trial of MBSR to date. It failed to replicate earlier findings: no MBSR-specific change in grey-matter volume, density or cortical thickness compared with either control. The limit: it tested an 8-week course in healthy adults, so it says nothing about years of intensive practice, where cross-sectional differences such as Lazar's 2005 finding might reflect practice, or simply who chooses to meditate.
Read the paper (free)The same year, the MYRIAD trial in the UK randomised 84 secondary schools (8,376 students aged 11 to 14) to a 10-lesson mindfulness course or usual social-emotional teaching. At one year there was no difference in depression risk, social-emotional functioning or well-being; the standardised differences were 0.005, 0.02 and 0.02.
A follow-up analysis suggested that students already at risk did slightly worse, and the authors concluded that universal school mindfulness in this format is not recommended. These results, and what meditation can still do, are weighed in mindfulness hype vs evidence.
Can meditation have side effects?
Yes, and the field now measures them. In August 2025 a study in Clinical Psychological Science led by Nicholas Van Dam surveyed close to 900 US meditators, matched to the national meditating population, with a 30-item checklist.
- Nearly 60% reported at least one side effect.
- About 30% reported something challenging or distressing.
- About 9% reported an effect that impaired daily functioning.
Risk was higher in people with recent psychological distress and among those who had attended residential retreats.
Where does meditation research stand in 2026?
It is large, more careful and less sensational. A June 2026 network meta-analysis in Applied Psychology: Health and Well-Being pooled 88 randomised trials with 8,728 university students and found meditation-only programmes improved resilience-related mental health outcomes (standardised mean difference 0.27) and resilience factors (0.54), but showed no clear effect on resilience scales themselves (-0.11, with a wide confidence interval).
That is the field's current shape:
- consistent small-to-moderate benefits for anxiety, depression, stress and pain;
- weaker or absent effects on broad claims;
- serious attention to dose, control groups and harms.
The techniques with the best evidence are ranked in 7 meditation techniques ranked by evidence, and the question of brain change gets its own answer in does meditation actually change your brain? More on the mind is on the Manthan page.
What's new
- Network meta-analysis of 88 trials: meditation helps students' mental health, not resilience scores Applied Psychology: Health and Well-Being, Jun 2026
- Nearly a third of meditators report a challenging or distressing side effect Association for Psychological Science, Aug 2025
- PubMed records 3,266 meditation or mindfulness papers in 2025, a new high NCBI PubMed, 2025 data
Questions people ask
Did a Harvard study prove meditation changes your brain?
Small Harvard-affiliated studies (Lazar 2005, 20 meditators; Holzel 2011, 16 MBSR participants) reported structural differences. A much larger 2022 randomised trial of 218 people with an active control found no structural change from an 8-week MBSR course, so the strong claim has not held up.
Who started scientific research on meditation?
Earlier EEG studies existed, including Kasamatsu and Hirai's 1966 study of Zen, but Robert Keith Wallace's 1970 Science paper on Transcendental Meditation is usually treated as the start of the modern field, followed by Herbert Benson's relaxation response work.
How effective is meditation for anxiety and depression?
Moderately. Goyal's 2014 meta-analysis of 47 controlled trials found effect sizes around 0.3 to 0.38 at 8 weeks, similar to other active treatments rather than better than them.
What is the difference between MBSR and MBCT?
MBSR is Kabat-Zinn's 8-week general stress course from 1979. MBCT, from 2000, combines it with cognitive therapy to prevent relapse in people who have had recurrent depression, and works best for those with three or more past episodes.
Sources
- Wallace R.K.: Physiological effects of transcendental meditation, Science 167:1751-4 (1970)
- Wallace R.K., Benson H., Wilson A.F.: A wakeful hypometabolic physiologic state, Am J Physiol (1971)
- Kasamatsu A., Hirai T.: An electroencephalographic study on the Zen meditation (Zazen) (1966)
- Benson H. et al.: The usefulness of the relaxation response in the therapy of headache, Headache (1974)
- Kabat-Zinn J.: An outpatient program in behavioral medicine for chronic pain patients based on mindfulness meditation, Gen Hosp Psychiatry (1982)
- Teasdale J.D. et al.: Prevention of relapse/recurrence in major depression by MBCT (2000)
- Lutz A. et al.: Long-term meditators self-induce high-amplitude gamma synchrony, PNAS (2004)
- Lazar S.W. et al.: Meditation experience is associated with increased cortical thickness, Neuroreport (2005)
- Holzel B.K. et al.: Mindfulness practice leads to increases in regional brain gray matter density (2011)
- Goyal M. et al.: Meditation programs for psychological stress and well-being, JAMA Intern Med (2014)
- Van Dam N.T. et al.: Mind the Hype, Perspectives on Psychological Science (2018)
- Kral T.R.A. et al.: Absence of structural brain changes from MBSR, Science Advances (2022)
- Kuyken W. et al.: The MYRIAD cluster randomised controlled trial, Evidence-Based Mental Health (2022)
- Association for Psychological Science: Does meditation come with side effects? (Aug 2025)
- Tricycle: Herbert Benson dies (source for the story of the first TM measurements) (2022)
- Benson-Henry Institute: how TM practitioners approached Benson in the late 1960s
- Jacob R. et al.: Impact of meditation-only interventions on university students' resilience, network meta-analysis (2026)
