Kuvalayananda and the first yoga labs: India's 1924 experiment

In 1924 a Sanskrit scholar from Baroda put yogis in front of an X-ray machine and a mercury gauge in Lonavala. A century later, India still produces almost half the world's yoga trials. This is how that started.

Green hills of Lonavala in the Sahyadri range, Maharashtra
Photo: Inderneel Mani Kumar, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Swami Kuvalayananda (born Jagannath Ganesh Gune, 1883-1966) started testing yoga with laboratory instruments in 1920 and in 1924 founded both the Kaivalyadhama institute at Lonavala and Yoga Mimamsa, the first journal of scientific yoga research. Its first issue reported X-rays and pressure readings of the abdominal practices uddiyana and nauli, showing a partial vacuum in the colon of about -33 to -47 mm Hg.

Key takeaways
  • 1920: Kuvalayananda begins measuring hatha yoga practices with instruments.
  • 1924: he founds Kaivalyadhama at Lonavala and Yoga Mimamsa, the first journal of scientific yoga research.
  • -33 to -47 mm Hg: the suction he measured in the colon during nauli, the "Madhavdas vacuum".
  • 46.4% of articles reporting yoga RCTs to 2014 came from India, but 20% of those were duplicate publications.
  • SMD -0.27: the small short-term benefit a 2025 meta-analysis found for pranayama in mental disorders.

That 1924 experiment matters because it set the template for how yoga entered modern medicine: as a set of techniques that could be measured, not only a spiritual discipline to be believed. The anthropologist Joseph Alter calls Kuvalayananda one of the chief architects of the modern yoga renaissance.

A hundred years later, India is still the largest producer of yoga trials in the world, and the questions he asked (what does a practice do to the body, and can we measure it?) are the same ones today's pranayama trials ask.

1920Kuvalayananda begins experiments on uddiyana and nauli
1924Kaivalyadhama and Yoga Mimamsa founded
-33 to -47mm Hg colon pressure measured during nauli
46.4%of yoga RCT articles to 2014 came from India

Who was Swami Kuvalayananda?

Swami Kuvalayananda was born Jagannath Ganesh Gune on 30 August 1883 at Dabhoi, near Baroda in Gujarat, and he came to yoga through physical education and Sanskrit scholarship rather than a monastery. He won the Jagannath Shankarsheth Sanskrit scholarship at his matriculation in 1903, graduated from Baroda College in 1910, and between 1907 and 1910 trained in the Indian system of physical education under Rajaratna Manikrao.

In 1919 he met Paramahamsa Madhavdas, a yogi who taught him the hatha practices he would later measure. The combination was unusual: a man trained to think about bodies as a gym teacher, and to read texts as a Sanskritist, who now wanted to know what the texts' techniques actually did. He took the name Kuvalayananda and spent the rest of his life at Lonavala, where he died on 18 April 1966.

Lonavala town and the surrounding Sahyadri hills, Maharashtra
Lonavala, the hill town between Mumbai and Pune where Kuvalayananda set up Kaivalyadhama in 1924 and lived until his death in 1966.Photo: Fredericknoronha, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

What did the 1924 experiments find?

The 1924 experiments found that nauli and uddiyana, two hatha yoga abdominal practices, create negative pressure inside the abdomen and colon, which Kuvalayananda measured at about -33 to -47 mm Hg with a rectal tube connected to a mercury pressure gauge. In uddiyana you breathe out fully, then expand the ribs as if inhaling without letting air in, so the belly is sucked up under the ribs; nauli adds rolling contractions of the abdominal muscles.

The story

The puzzle was water. Hatha yoga texts describe cleansing the colon by drawing water up into it, and physiology of the day had no account of how that could happen without a pump. One suggestion was that nauli reversed peristalsis, the gut's normal one-way wave, which doctors would have considered unhealthy. Kuvalayananda's answer was to measure. A tube from the rectum ran to a mercury gauge, and the first issue of Yoga Mimamsa reported the reading in plain terms: as soon as the muscles moved for nauli, the mercury fell through 40 mm, a clear partial vacuum. Later readings put the suction at -33 to -47 mm Hg. He named it the Madhavdas vacuum, after his teacher Paramahamsa Madhavdas. Suction was a simple mechanical explanation, and it undercut the anti-peristalsis idea.

Ghosh Yoga: The science of uddiyana, 1924 (quoting Yoga Mimamsa, vol. 1)

The X-ray plates in the same issue showed that the colon could shift position substantially and its contents could be redistributed during these practices, and that the diaphragm and ribs could move independently, against the textbook view that their movements were tied together. Modern readers find the 1924 radiographs cloudy and hard to read; later X-ray work from the 1960s is much clearer.

Mercury gaugeLevel falls about 40 mmduring nauli: suctionof -33 to -47 mm HgRectal tube to gaugeX-raysourceAbdomen drawnup and inSubject doing uddiyana or nauli
A simplified sketch of the two instruments in Yoga Mimamsa's first issue: radiographs of the abdomen, and a tube from the colon to a mercury gauge that showed negative pressure during nauli.

What was Yoga Mimamsa?

Yoga Mimamsa was the journal Kuvalayananda launched in 1924 to publish his laboratory work alongside textual studies of yoga, and it is still published by Kaivalyadhama today. The name means "investigation of yoga"; mimamsa is the classical Indian word for systematic inquiry. Its stated aim was to describe practices accurately, study them scientifically and make the findings public, which is close to what a modern research institute's mission statement says.

A 2025 centenary review in the International Journal of Yoga Therapy by Dallaghan and Tiwari traces the journal's early output. After the nauli X-rays, the 1930s papers measured:

  • blood pressure during asanas;
  • pressure inside the stomach (intragastric pressure);
  • the composition of alveolar air, the air deep in the lungs;
  • pressure changes across different practices.

The review also discusses the limitations of that early era of research.

From a mercury gauge to meta-analysis 1920 first tests 1924 Kaivalyadhama,Yoga Mimamsa 1951 college of yoga 1961 AIIMS yogi studies 1975 first yoga RCT 2014: 312 RCTs counted 2025 pranayamameta-analysis Scale: 1920 to 2025, about 6.7 px per year. Half a century separates the first instrument readings from the first randomised trial.
A century of yoga research on one line. Dates from Kaivalyadhama, Wikipedia's Kuvalayananda biography, Cramer et al. (2014) and Mütze et al. (2025); the 1961 AIIMS studies are Anand, Chhina and Singh. Drawing by the author.
YearEvent
1883J. G. Gune born at Dabhoi, Gujarat (30 August)
1907-1910Trains in physical education under Rajaratna Manikrao, Baroda
1910Graduates from Baroda College
1919Meets Paramahamsa Madhavdas
1920-21First experiments on uddiyana and nauli
1924Founds Kaivalyadhama, Lonavala, and the journal Yoga Mimamsa
1930sStudies of blood pressure, intragastric pressure and alveolar air
1932Opens a Kaivalyadhama branch at Santacruz, Mumbai
1951Gordhandas Seksaria College of Yoga and Cultural Synthesis opens at Lonavala
1966Dies at Lonavala (18 April)
1975First randomised controlled trial of yoga published (Cramer 2014 bibliometric count)
2024Kaivalyadhama's centenary year
A Review of the Earliest Scientific Studies on Yoga and the Birth of Yoga Therapy in 1924: Swami Kuvalayananda, Founder of the Kaivalyadhama Yoga Institute and the Journal Yoga Mimamsa at 100 YearsDallaghan P, Tiwari S · International Journal of Yoga Therapy · 2025

A historical review of Yoga Mimamsa's first decades, written for the centenary. It identifies the 1924 X-ray study of nauli as the first published research, then follows the 1930s work on blood pressure, asanas, intragastric pressure, alveolar air and pressure changes across techniques. It argues these studies mark the birth of yoga therapy as a research field. Limit: it is a historical review, so it summarises rather than re-tests the early findings, and I could read only its abstract.

Read the paper

Why did Kuvalayananda use science at all?

Kuvalayananda used laboratory methods because he wanted yoga accepted by doctors and educators who trusted instruments more than texts, and because he believed the practices had real, testable effects. Alter's history, Yoga in Modern India (Princeton, 2004), uses his work as the starting point for an argument about how modern yoga was built: by blending physiology and anatomy with older ideas of transcendence and power, until yoga could be sold as health.

That blend is still visible. Kaivalyadhama ran a research department and, from 1951, a college side by side, so the measuring and the teaching grew together. The same health-and-science framing later travelled abroad with yoga, all the way to the postural studios of London. If you want the older textual side of the story, the history of the Yoga Sutras follows Patanjali's text from about 400 CE to its 20th-century revival.

Opening of an Iyengar Yoga studio in Maida Vale, London
The opening of an Iyengar Yoga studio in Maida Vale, London. By the late 20th century, yoga had travelled from Indian labs and ashrams to studios worldwide, carrying its "scientific" label with it.Photo: Melissaloddo, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

How much yoga research does India produce today?

India still produces the largest share of yoga trials: a 2014 bibliometric analysis by Cramer and colleagues counted 366 articles reporting 312 randomised trials with 22,548 participants from 23 countries, and 170 of the articles (46.4%) came from India against 98 (26.8%) from the USA. The first randomised trial appeared in 1975, and 86.9% of the articles were published after 2000.

Articles reporting randomised trials of yoga, by country (to 2014)
See the data as a table
Articles (articles)
India170
USA98
All other countries98

Source: Cramer H et al., BMC Complementary and Alternative Medicine 2014 · 366 articles on 312 RCTs; 34 Indian articles were duplicate publications of the same trial.

The same paper carries a warning Kuvalayananda's successors would recognise: 34 of the Indian articles (20%) were duplicate publications of trials already reported, against 11.2% of US articles. Volume is not the same as quality. An earlier count by Sat Bir Khalsa in 2004 had found 72 randomised trials, more than half from India, so the field roughly quadrupled in a decade.

Characteristics of randomized controlled trials of yoga: a bibliometric analysisCramer H, Lauche R, Dobos G · BMC Complementary and Alternative Medicine · 2014

The authors searched the literature from 1975 to 2014 and found 366 articles reporting 312 randomised trials of yoga (22,548 participants, median sample 59, 23 countries). India produced 170 articles and the USA 98. The most studied conditions were breast cancer (17 trials), depression (14), asthma (14) and type 2 diabetes (13); only six conditions had ten or more trials. Limit: counting trials says nothing about their quality, and duplicate publication was common, especially among Indian articles.

Read the paper (free)

Is pranayama scientifically proven now?

Pranayama now has randomised trials, which Kuvalayananda never had, but the result is modest: a 2025 meta-analysis in Frontiers in Psychiatry found only 6 randomised trials of pranayama for diagnosed mental disorders and a small short-term benefit over passive controls (SMD -0.27), with no advantage over standard care. Fast techniques such as kapalbhati produced more side effects.

Healthy-volunteer research is more encouraging:

  • Stanford, 2023: a trial in Cell Reports Medicine randomised 108 adults to 5 minutes a day of different breathing practices or mindfulness for a month, and found that structured breathing, especially cyclic sighing, lifted daily mood more than mindfulness.

A smaller 2020 Brazilian trial in Frontiers in Psychiatry (Novaes and colleagues, 30 young adults) found four weeks of pranayama lowered state anxiety and negative mood against a control group doing crosswords and card games, with matching changes in amygdala activity on fMRI, results the authors called preliminary and exploratory. The full ranking of techniques by research is in 8 pranayama techniques ranked by research evidence, and the physiology of why slow breathing calms you is in slow breathing and the vagus nerve.

Effectiveness of pranayama for mental disorders: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trialsMütze C, Mitzinger D, Haller H · Frontiers in Psychiatry · 2025

Six randomised trials (517 adults with PTSD, depression, alcohol dependence or mixed disorders, from the USA, India and Germany) were pooled. Pranayama reduced symptom severity a little against passive controls (SMD -0.27) and improved quality of life in per-protocol analysis, but was not better than standard care. Adverse events clustered in fast techniques, especially kapalbhati. Limit: four trials were at high risk of bias, and most participants were men.

Read the paper (free)
A practitioner seated cross-legged doing alternate nostril breathing
Nadi shuddhi, alternate nostril breathing. Kaivalyadhama's 1930s work moved from abdominal kriyas to breathing practices like this one, which now have dozens of randomised trials.Photo: Thamizhpparithi Maari, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

What would a modern scientist say about the 1924 study?

A modern reviewer would praise the instinct and fault the method: the 1924 work measured real physical quantities with real instruments, but as far as the published accounts show, on trained practitioners, with no control group and no blinding. Those are the same weaknesses the 2025 pranayama meta-analysis still finds in many Indian trials, where four of six were at high risk of bias.

The lasting contribution is the question, not the answer. Kuvalayananda refused to treat a yogic claim as true because a text said so, and refused to dismiss it because Western physiology had not studied it.

Test before you believe, and test before you reject: the thread from a 1924 mercury gauge to a 2023 breathing trial.

That stance is the stance of this whole section of the site. If you plan to try the practices yourself, start with how to start pranayama safely. More essays on the mind are on the Manthan world page.

Questions people ask

Who founded Kaivalyadhama and when?

Swami Kuvalayananda founded Kaivalyadhama at Lonavala, Maharashtra, in 1924, the same year he started the journal Yoga Mimamsa. He added a Mumbai branch at Santacruz in 1932 and a college of yoga at Lonavala in 1951.

What was the first scientific study of yoga?

The first published laboratory study is usually taken to be Kuvalayananda's X-ray and pressure work on uddiyana and nauli in the first issue of Yoga Mimamsa in 1924, following experiments he began in 1920-21. The first randomised controlled trial of yoga came much later, in 1975.

Is Yoga Mimamsa still published?

Yes. Kaivalyadhama still publishes Yoga Mimamsa, and its research department lists a current editor. The journal turned 100 in 2024.

Is nauli safe to try at home?

Nauli and uddiyana are advanced practices done with the lungs empty and strong abdominal suction, and the early research measured them in trained practitioners, not beginners. Learn them only from an experienced teacher, and check with a doctor first if you have high blood pressure, heart disease, a hernia, abdominal surgery or are pregnant.

Sources

  1. Dallaghan P, Tiwari S: A review of the earliest scientific studies on yoga and the birth of yoga therapy in 1924, International Journal of Yoga Therapy (2025)
  2. Kaivalyadhama: Swami Kuvalayananda's research on nauli, uddiyana and the Madhavdas vacuum
  3. Ghosh Yoga: The science of uddiyana, 1924
  4. Wikipedia: Swami Kuvalayananda (biography and dates)
  5. Alter JS: Yoga in Modern India: The Body between Science and Philosophy, Princeton University Press (2004)
  6. Indian Journal of Physiology and Pharmacology: A retrospective on yoga research (the 1961 AIIMS studies of Anand, Chhina and Singh) (1991)
  7. Cramer H, Lauche R, Dobos G: Characteristics of randomized controlled trials of yoga: a bibliometric analysis, BMC CAM (2014)
  8. Mütze C, Mitzinger D, Haller H: Effectiveness of pranayama for mental disorders, Frontiers in Psychiatry (2025)
  9. Balban MY et al.: Brief structured respiration practices enhance mood, Cell Reports Medicine (2023)
  10. PsyPost: Four weeks of pranayama reduces anxiety and negative affect (Novaes et al., Frontiers in Psychiatry) (2020)
  11. The Week: Will India's new yoga protocols help fight lifestyle diseases? (2026)
Swami KuvalayanandaKaivalyadhamaYoga MimamsaLonavalahistory of yoga researchnauliuddiyanapranayama trials
Sapta

Sapta (Saptarshi Sarkar) is a mechanical engineer turned marketer in Bengaluru and a solo touring rider. He writes the seven Saptaverse blogs. Work with him or read more of Mindblog.

Keep reading in Mindblog

From the other blogs