10 Indian thinkers on the mind, in order of time

From Yajnavalkya's seer who cannot be seen to Tagore's argument with Einstein, ten Indian philosophers whose ideas about the mind still raise testable questions. Ordered by date, each with one idea and how it holds up.

Brick stupa of Temple 3, the Sariputta Stupa, among the ruins of Nalanda Mahavihara in Bihar
Photo: Sumitsurai, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Ten Indian philosophers on the mind, in order of time, are Yajnavalkya (c. 8th to 7th century BCE), the Buddha (fl. c. 450 BCE), Mahavira (died c. 425 BCE), Nagarjuna (c. 150 to 250 CE), Patanjali (c. 400 CE on one leading dating), Vasubandhu (4th to 5th century CE), Shankara (8th century), Abhinavagupta (c. 950 to 1016), Vivekananda (1863 to 1902) and Tagore (1861 to 1941). Each made a claim about the mind that modern psychology or neuroscience can at least partly test, from the nature of deep sleep to mind-wandering.

Key takeaways
  • About 2,700 years separate Yajnavalkya's dialogues from Tagore's 1930 talk with Einstein.
  • Self vs no-self is the great divide: the Upanishads and Shankara say yes, the Buddha and Nagarjuna say no.
  • 46.9% of waking moments are spent mind-wandering, the problem Patanjali's sutra 1.2 starts from.
  • Dreamless sleep, Yajnavalkya's test case, became a research agenda in a 2016 review.
  • Dates are uncertain, sometimes by centuries; Patanjali's datings alone sit centuries apart.

The order is the stated criterion: approximate date of life or main work, using the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, the Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy and standard scholarship. Ancient dates are uncertain, sometimes by centuries, and where scholars disagree I say so.

Order of time is not order of importance. Indian philosophy has dozens of schools and hundreds of authors, and this list picks ten who made the mind their central subject.

Each entry gives:

  • the idea, in one or two plain sentences;
  • the honest test: where a modern study bears on it, and where it does not;
  • a spec line with dates, key text and the modern link.

Philosophy is not a lab result, but several of these ideas make claims about experience that can be checked against what people report and what brains do.

~2,700 yearsfrom Yajnavalkya to Tagore
c. 700 BCEBrihadaranyaka Upanishad (Olivelle's dating)
195-196sutras in the Yoga Sutras
46.9%of waking moments spent mind-wandering (Killingsworth and Gilbert 2010)

Who are the most important Indian thinkers on the mind?

The ten below span every major tradition that made the mind its main subject: the Upanishads, Buddhism, Jainism, Yoga, Madhyamaka, Yogacara, Advaita Vedanta, Kashmir Shaivism and modern Indian thought. The table puts their dates, schools and central idea side by side.

#ThinkerApprox. datesTraditionKey textIdea about mind
1Yajnavalkyac. 8th-7th c. BCEUpanishadicBrihadaranyaka UpanishadThe self is the seer that cannot be seen
2The Buddhafl. c. 450 BCEBuddhistEarly discoursesNo permanent self; mind is a stream of events
3Mahavirad. c. 425 BCEJainJain canonReality has many sides; every view is partial
4Nagarjunac. 150-250 CEMadhyamakaMulamadhyamakakarikaNothing, including the self, has independent essence
5Patanjalic. 400 CE (Maas)YogaYoga SutrasYoga is stilling the mind's fluctuations
6Vasubandhu4th-5th c. CEYogacaraTwenty Verses, Thirty VersesExperience is appearance-only; dreams show how
7Shankara8th c. CEAdvaita VedantaBrahma Sutra commentaryError is superimposition; pure consciousness underlies all states
8Abhinavaguptac. 950-1016Kashmir ShaivismTantraloka, AbhinavabharatiAesthetic experience absorbs and expands consciousness
9Vivekananda1863-1902Modern VedantaRaja Yoga (1896)Concentration is a trainable science of mind
10Tagore1861-1941Modern humanistThe Religion of Man (1931)Truth as humans know it is human truth
How long ago each thinker lived (approximate midpoint, years before 2026)
See the data as a table
Years ago (years)
Yajnavalkya2726
The Buddha2476
Mahavira2451
Nagarjuna1826
Vasubandhu1650
Patanjali1626
Shankara1276
Abhinavagupta1043
Vivekananda144
Tagore125

Source: Dates from the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Buddha, Nagarjuna, Vasubandhu), Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Advaita Vedanta) and scholarship cited on Wikipedia (Olivelle, Maas, Dundas) · Midpoints of uncertain ranges: Yajnavalkya c. 700 BCE; Buddha c. 450 BCE; Mahavira death c. 425 BCE; Nagarjuna c. 200 CE; Vasubandhu c. 375 CE; Patanjali c. 400 CE; Shankara c. 750 CE; Abhinavagupta c. 983 CE. Errors of a century or more are possible for the ancients.

Ten thinkers, one line c. 700 BCEc. 450 BCEc. 425 BCEc. 200 CEc. 375 CEc. 400 CEc. 750 CEc. 983 CE1863-19021861-1941 Yajnavalkya: the unseen seer The Buddha: no permanent self Mahavira: many-sided truth Nagarjuna: no independent essence Vasubandhu: appearance-only Patanjali: stilling the mind Shankara: superimposition Abhinavagupta: aesthetic relish about 850 years later Vivekananda: Raja Yoga Tagore: human truth
Not to scale: equal steps for readability. Dates are approximate midpoints from the chart above; the dashed stretch marks the gap between Abhinavagupta and the modern pair.

1. Yajnavalkya

Yajnavalkya is the main teacher of the Brihadaranyaka Upanishad, which Patrick Olivelle dates to about 700 BCE, and his core claim is that the self is the knower that can never itself become an object of knowing.

The story

The Upanishad tells it as a contest. King Janaka of Videha offered a prize of a thousand cows, each with gold tied to it, to the most learned scholar at his court. Before anyone could speak, Yajnavalkya told his pupil Samsrava to drive the cows home, and the other scholars began questioning him one by one.

Gargi Vachaknavi asked what the world is woven on, warp and woof. Each answer pushed her to the next layer, through air and the intermediate regions to the worlds beyond, until Yajnavalkya told her to stop asking. She came back for a second round, the only questioner to challenge him twice, and asked what space itself is woven across. His answer was the imperishable: the one that sees but is not seen.

Wikipedia: Gargi Vachaknavi (on Brihadaranyaka Upanishad 3.6 and 3.8)

Asked by King Janaka what light a person has when sun, moon, fire and speech are gone, he answers that the self is its own light, and he walks Janaka through waking, dreaming and dreamless sleep to show it.

The test

The claim that something of awareness persists in dreamless sleep was long treated as untestable. In 2016, Jennifer Windt, Tore Nielsen and Evan Thompson argued in Trends in Cognitive Sciences that the standard assumption, that consciousness simply vanishes in deep sleep, is oversimplified, and proposed ways to study dreamless sleep experience. Yajnavalkya's question is now a research programme.

  • Text: Brihadaranyaka Upanishad, c. 700 BCE
  • Idea: the seer that cannot be seen; analysis of sleep states
  • Modern link: dreamless sleep experience research

2. The Buddha

The Buddha, whom Mark Siderits dates to around 450 BCE in the Stanford Encyclopedia, argued that there is no permanent self: what we call a person is five changing aggregates, one physical and four mental, and "mind" is a name for bundles of passing mental events.

Two of his arguments survive:

  • Impermanence: nothing in the aggregates is permanent, so none of them is a self.
  • Lack of control: we can wish any of them to be different, which we could not if it were the self in control.

The test

Contemplative neuroscience treats self-related processing as something that can be trained. Cortland Dahl, Antoine Lutz and Richard Davidson's 2015 framework groups meditation into attentional, constructive and deconstructive families, the last aimed at insight into how the sense of self is built.

Whether there "is" a self is philosophy; whether the felt self is a constructed, changeable process is now an empirical question. I take this further in atman, anatta and neuroscience.

  • Dates: fl. c. 450 BCE (traditional c. 560-480 BCE)
  • Idea: no-self; the mind as a stream of events
  • Modern link: deconstructive meditation research
Modern statue of the Buddha seated in meditation at Sarnath Buddha Park, Uttar Pradesh
A modern statue at Sarnath, where tradition places the Buddha's first sermon. The early teaching on the five aggregates is the root of every Buddhist theory of mind on this list.Photo: K.Venkataramana, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons

3. Mahavira

Mahavira, the 24th Jain tirthankara, is dated by tradition to 599 to 527 BCE and by many scholars to the 5th century BCE, with Paul Dundas placing his death around 425 BCE.

The Jain theory of knowledge associated with him, anekantavada, holds that reality has many aspects and that any statement captures it only partially; syadvada answers metaphysical questions with a qualified "in some respect".

The test

This is a claim about the limits of a single viewpoint, and its modern cousin is perspective-taking, which Dahl and colleagues list as a mechanism of the "constructive" family of meditation practices. The logic itself is unpacked in Jain syadvada's seven-fold logic.

  • Dates: traditional 599-527 BCE; scholarly death c. 425 BCE
  • Idea: many-sidedness of truth
  • Modern link: perspective-taking and cognitive reappraisal
Yellow stone statue of Mahavira from Gujarat, dated 1470, in the Royal Museums of Art and History, Brussels
A Mahavira image carved in Gujarat in 1470, now in Brussels. Jain epistemology, with its insistence on partial viewpoints, grew from his teaching.Photo: Vassil, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons

4. Nagarjuna

Nagarjuna, who lived roughly 150 to 250 CE probably in southern India, founded the Madhyamaka school and argued that nothing has svabhava, an independent essence that grounds it. His central work, the Mulamadhyamakakarika, runs to about 450 verses.

On the mind, he argues that a self cannot be both the subject and the object of its own knowing, and he compares the agent to a magical illusion that still has real ethical stakes.

The test

Jan Westerhoff's Stanford Encyclopedia entry, substantively revised in May 2026, stresses that Madhyamaka aims at a change in how things appear, not just a theory, which links it to the deconstructive practices above. The logic is in Nagarjuna, the catuskoti and emptiness.

  • Dates: c. 150-250 CE
  • Idea: emptiness of independent essence, including the self
  • Modern link: the constructed self in cognitive science

5. Patanjali

Patanjali compiled the Yoga Sutras, 195 or 196 aphorisms in four books, and defined yoga in sutra 1.2 as the stilling of the fluctuations (vrttis) of the mind (citta).

Dating is disputed: Philipp Maas places the Patanjala Yogashastra around 400 CE through links to Vasubandhu's work, while Edwin Bryant reports that many scholars place it shortly after the start of the Common Era. The eight limbs run from ethical restraints through posture and breath control to concentration, meditation and samadhi.

The test

The idea that the untrained mind is constantly busy is directly measurable. Matthew Killingsworth and Daniel Gilbert's 2010 study in Science sampled the thoughts of 2,250 people through an iPhone app and found minds wandering in 46.9% of samples, with wandering usually making people less happy.

Patanjali's starting problem is real. The history of the text is in the history of the Yoga Sutras.

  • Dates: c. 400 CE (Maas) or earlier (others)
  • Idea: yoga as stilling mental fluctuations
  • Modern link: mind-wandering research

6. Vasubandhu

Vasubandhu, dated by the Stanford Encyclopedia to the 4th to 5th century CE, wrote both the Abhidharmakosha, a systematic Buddhist psychology, and the founding texts of Yogacara, which hold that what we experience is "appearance-only" (vijnaptimatra).

Against the objection that mental images could not have a definite place and time, he points to dreams, where we see objects in a specific place and moment that are wholly mind-made. Yogacara also posited a "store consciousness" (alayavijnana) to explain continuity when the six ordinary consciousnesses are absent.

The test

The dream argument anticipates a modern view that perception is the brain's best model of the world, built from prediction and only checked against the senses. That parallel is explored in predictive processing and maya.

  • Dates: 4th-5th century CE
  • Idea: experience as appearance; the dream argument
  • Modern link: predictive processing

7. Shankara

Shankara, who the Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy says lived in the 8th century and only 32 years, systematised Advaita Vedanta, holding that the individual self and Brahman are identical and that consciousness is Brahman's very nature.

He defined error as superimposition (adhyasa), apprehending something as something else, and read waking, dream and deep sleep as pointing to a fourth state, pure consciousness, which deep sleep partly reveals.

The test

The superimposition idea fits what perception science calls top-down influence, expectation shaping what is seen. The deep-sleep claim meets the same research Windt and colleagues proposed. The contrast with the dualist school is in Advaita vs Dvaita explained.

  • Dates: 8th century CE
  • Idea: superimposition; consciousness as the ground of all states
  • Modern link: top-down perception; sleep consciousness
Raja Ravi Varma painting of Adi Shankara seated with four disciples
Raja Ravi Varma's painting of Shankara with his disciples. Shankara also founded four centres of Advaita learning led by his pupils.Photo: Raja Ravi Varma, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
Is there a lasting self behind the mind? Yes: a witness or soul Yajnavalkya (atman) Mahavira (jiva) Patanjali (purusha) Shankara (atman = Brahman) Abhinavagupta Vivekananda No: a stream of events The Buddha (anatta) Nagarjuna (no svabhava) Vasubandhu (appearance-only; store consciousness for continuity) Tagore asked a different question: can truth exist apart from the human mind?
The fault line that runs through the list. A simplification: Jain jiva, Samkhya-Yoga purusha and Advaita atman are very different selves, but all three are lasting; the Buddhist side denies any such thing.

8. Abhinavagupta

Abhinavagupta, a Kashmiri scholar of about 950 to 1016, wrote more than 35 works, including the encyclopedic Tantraloka on Trika (Kashmir Shaivism) and the Abhinavabharati, the most studied commentary on Bharata's Natyashastra.

His contribution to the mind is through aesthetics: he described the sahrdaya, the sensitive spectator whose mind mirrors poetic emotion, and held that the full relish of art, even of painful emotion, expands consciousness, close to though never equal to yogic realisation.

The test

The claim that aesthetic absorption is a distinct mental state, different from ordinary emotion, is one that modern aesthetics and psychology of "absorption" study, though no single experiment settles it.

It is the most humane entry on this list: the mind is not only a problem to be stilled.
  • Dates: c. 950-1016
  • Idea: rasa, aesthetic relish, as expanded awareness
  • Modern link: psychology of absorption and aesthetic emotion

9. Vivekananda

Swami Vivekananda (1863 to 1902) published Raja Yoga in July 1896, a set of lectures with a free translation of and commentary on Patanjali's Yoga Sutras.

Scholars such as Elizabeth De Michelis argue that it blended Patanjali with Western ideas of the time, including William James's functional psychology, and that it marks the start of modern yoga in the West.

The test

His core claim, that concentration is a trainable skill, is now well supported in a narrow form. Trials of short daily meditation in beginners report better attention after eight weeks; a starting plan is in how to start meditating.

His larger metaphysical claims are not testable this way. The story of his 1893 Chicago speech is in Vivekananda in Chicago, 1893.

  • Dates: 1863-1902
  • Key text: Raja Yoga, July 1896
  • Modern link: attention training
Portrait photograph of Swami Vivekananda in 1893
Vivekananda in 1893, the year of his Chicago address. Raja Yoga, his book on Patanjali, followed three years laterPhoto: Thomas Harrison, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

10. Rabindranath Tagore

Rabindranath Tagore (1861 to 1941), the 1913 Nobel laureate in literature, set out his philosophy in The Religion of Man (1931), drawn largely from his Hibbert Lectures at Oxford in May 1930.

Its appendix, "Note on the Nature of Reality", records his 1930 conversation with Albert Einstein about whether truth and beauty exist independently of the human mind. Tagore's side of it, that truth as we know it is human truth, runs through the whole book.

The test

This is a question about realism that physics and philosophy still argue over, not one an experiment closes. The full exchange is in the Tagore-Einstein conversation of 1930.

  • Dates: 1861-1941
  • Key text: The Religion of Man, 1931
  • Idea: human-bound truth
Does Consciousness Disappear in Dreamless Sleep?Windt, Nielsen and Thompson · Trends in Cognitive Sciences · 2016

A review arguing that the standard view, that consciousness vanishes in dreamless sleep, is oversimplified. Unless dreamless sleep is defined as unconscious from the start, there are empirical and theoretical reasons to think several kinds of sleep experience, some distinct from dreaming, occur in every sleep stage. The authors propose a taxonomy and research methods, including work on memory consolidation, sleep disorders and sleep-state misperception. Limit: a conceptual review that sets a research agenda; it does not itself measure awareness in deep sleep.

Read the paper
Reconstructing and deconstructing the self: cognitive mechanisms in meditation practiceDahl, Lutz and Davidson · Trends in Cognitive Sciences · 2015

Proposes classifying meditation into attentional, constructive and deconstructive families by their main cognitive mechanisms: meta-awareness, perspective-taking and reappraisal, and self-inquiry. The deconstructive family targets "experiential fusion" and reified self-schemas, which links Buddhist no-self analysis to testable psychological processes. Limit: a theoretical framework, not a trial; its categories still need experimental validation.

Read the paper (free)
A wandering mind is an unhappy mindKillingsworth and Gilbert · Science · 2010

An iPhone app sampled the current thoughts, feelings and activities of 2,250 volunteers at random moments. Minds wandered in 46.9% of samples, and people were usually less happy when their minds wandered than when they focused on what they were doing. Limit: volunteers self-selected (74% were American), and experience sampling shows association, not proof of cause.

Read the paper

Where should a beginner start reading Indian philosophy of mind?

Start with one thinker and a modern guide, not the whole tradition. On the Indian Philosophy Blog, scholars answering exactly this question recommended:

  • Richard King's introduction, for general readers;
  • Mark Siderits's Buddhism as Philosophy and Jonardon Ganeri's Philosophy in Classical India, for analytic readers;
  • the Stanford and Internet encyclopedias, online and free.
  1. Get the map. Read the six darshanas timeline to place the schools.
  2. Read the oldest texts. Start with the oldest Indian texts on the mind, then one Upanishad dialogue of Yajnavalkya in Olivelle's translation.
  3. Pair a self and a no-self thinker. Read the Buddha's arguments against a self alongside Shankara's or Nyaya's arguments for one.
  4. Then the hard ones. Nagarjuna and Vasubandhu repay a second year, not a first week.

Intuition and insight in Indian thought did not stop with philosophers; the mathematician who said his results came to him in dreams is in Ramanujan's intuition. More on these worlds is on the Manthan page.

Questions people ask

Who is the greatest Indian philosopher of mind?

There is no agreed answer, which is why this list is ordered by time, not rank. Shankara and Nagarjuna are the most studied in philosophy departments; Patanjali has the widest practical influence; Vasubandhu wrote the most systematic Buddhist psychology.

What is the difference between atman and anatta?

Atman, in the Upanishads and Advaita, is the unchanging self that witnesses all experience. Anatta, in Buddhism, denies any such permanent self and treats the person as a changing stream of physical and mental events.

Was Patanjali before or after the Buddha?

After. Even the earliest scholarly datings put the Yoga Sutras around the turn of the Common Era, and Philipp Maas dates the work to around 400 CE, centuries after the Buddha's fifth-century BCE floruit.

Did Indian philosophers influence Western psychology?

Some did, through specific channels. Vivekananda's Raja Yoga (1896) drew on William James's psychology, by Elizabeth De Michelis's analysis, and was widely read in the West; mindfulness programmes from the 1970s onward drew on Buddhist practice. Most Western psychology developed independently.

Sources

  1. Siderits M.: Buddha, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (rev. 2023)
  2. Westerhoff J.C.: Nagarjuna, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (rev. 2026)
  3. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: Vasubandhu (rev. 2021)
  4. Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy: Advaita Vedanta
  5. Wikipedia: Yajnavalkya (citing Olivelle 1998)
  6. Wikipedia: Gargi Vachaknavi (source for the debate at Janaka's court)
  7. Wikipedia: Mahavira (citing Dundas 2002)
  8. Wikipedia: Yoga Sutras of Patanjali (citing Maas, Bryant)
  9. Wikipedia: Abhinavagupta and Rasa (aesthetics)
  10. Wikipedia: Raja Yoga (book) (citing De Michelis)
  11. Wikipedia: The Religion of Man
  12. Windt J.M., Nielsen T. and Thompson E.: Does Consciousness Disappear in Dreamless Sleep? Trends in Cognitive Sciences 20(12):871-882 (2016)
  13. Dahl C.J., Lutz A. and Davidson R.J.: Reconstructing and deconstructing the self, Trends in Cognitive Sciences 19(9):515-523 (2015)
  14. Killingsworth M.A. and Gilbert D.T.: A wandering mind is an unhappy mind, Science 330:932 (2010)
  15. Harvard Gazette: Wandering mind not a happy mind (2010)
  16. The Indian Philosophy Blog: Getting started in Indian philosophy (2015)
Indian philosophyphilosophy of mindBuddhismAdvaita VedantaYogacaraPatanjaliKashmir Shaivism
Sapta

Sapta (Saptarshi Sarkar) is a mechanical engineer turned marketer in Bengaluru and a solo touring rider. He writes the seven Saptaverse blogs. Work with him or read more of Mindblog.

Keep reading in Mindblog

From the other blogs