What if every pothole in India were filled with gulab jamun?

About 95 crore gulab jamuns, 32,000 tonnes of sweet and 5 hours of India's sugar. A car tyre presses 19 times harder than a gulab jamun can push back.

Two syrup-soaked gulab jamuns on a plate
Photo: Suyash.dwivedi, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

If every pothole in India were filled with gulab jamun, the country would need roughly 95 crore of them, about 32,000 tonnes of sweets plus syrup holding some 17,000 tonnes of sugar, five hours of India's sugar consumption. The road would fail at once: a gulab jamun squashed to half its height pushes back with only about 12 kPa, while a car tyre presses down at around 220 kPa, about 19 times more. The jamuns would flatten to paste on the first pass and the syrup would bring every ant in the district.

Key takeaways
  • 2,385 people died in pothole-related crashes in India in 2024, and 9,438 from 2020 to 2024.
  • 95 crore gulab jamuns would fill an estimated 63 lakh potholes, at about 151 per pothole.
  • 0.634 is the random close packing fraction: the other 36.6% of every pothole is syrup.
  • ~19×: a car tyre presses at about 220 kPa; a squashed gulab jamun resists about 11.8 kPa.
  • Impossible as a road repair; the sugar, about five hours of India's use, is the easy part.

Potholes are not a joke statistic. Union government data given in Parliament counted 2,385 deaths in pothole-related crashes in 2024 and 9,438 between 2020 and 2024.

This what-if uses the absurd filler to ask a serious engineering question: what does a pothole patch actually need to do, and how far short does a soft, sweet, spherical mithai fall?

2,385pothole-related road deaths in 2024
95 croregulab jamuns to fill 63 lakh potholes, my estimate
3.4–10.7 Nmeasured hardness of market gulab jamun
~19×car tyre pressure over gulab jamun strength

How many potholes does India have?

Nobody publishes a national pothole count, so I estimate one pothole per kilometre of road on average, about 63 lakh across India's 63 lakh km network, with a plausible range of 32 lakh to 3.2 crore. The anchor is Bengaluru, where civic data in 2025 showed about five potholes per kilometre.

The Bengaluru anchor

In September 2025, The Week reported 9,973 potholes on Bengaluru's ward-level roads and 4,400 on arterial and sub-arterial roads, against the city's total of about 2,900 km of roads in that report: roughly 14,400 potholes, or five per kilometre.

By December 2025 the Greater Bengaluru Authority said it had filled 22,539 potholes since April. A big city in monsoon is the worst case; rural roads with little traffic and new highways have far fewer. One per kilometre nationally is my central guess, and I carry the range through every calculation.

ScenarioPotholes per kmPotholes in India
Low0.532 lakh
Central estimate163 lakh
Bengaluru rate everywhere53.2 crore
Deaths in pothole-related road crashes in India
See the data as a table
Deaths (deaths)
20201555
20211481
20221856
20232161
20242385

Source: MoRTH data in a written reply in Parliament, reported by Outlook India (PTI) · Based on state police reports; under-reporting is likely.

The story

On 28 July 2015, 16-year-old Prakash Bilhore and his cousin were riding a motorcycle home along Mumbai's Jogeshwari-Vikhroli Link Road when it hit a pothole hidden under monsoon water. Prakash died of his injuries. His father, Dadarao Bilhore, a vegetable seller, decided to deal with the holes himself.

From December 2015, starting on Marol Maroshi Road, he filled potholes by hand with broken paver blocks and rubble collected from construction sites. By 2018 news reports were counting his 556th pothole. Notice his material: hard, load-bearing debris, not anything soft. The engineering in this post shows why that instinct is right.

The Better India: Dadarao Bilhore and Mumbai's potholes (February 2016)
A Bengaluru road surface broken by several water-filled potholes
Potholes on a Bengaluru road. The city reported about 14,400 in September 2025, roughly five per kilometre of road.Photo: Mallikarjunasj, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons

How many gulab jamuns fill one pothole?

A typical pothole of 50 cm across and 5 cm deep holds about 4.9 litres and takes about 150 gulab jamuns, because spheres poured into a hole fill only 63.4% of the space. That fraction, called random close packing, is one of the best-measured numbers in granular physics.

\[ n = \frac{\phi\,V_p}{V_j}, \qquad V_p \approx \tfrac{1}{2}\pi r^{2} h, \qquad V_j = \tfrac{\pi}{6} d^{3} \]

Pour marbles into a jar and shake: however you try, you cannot get above about 64% solid without arranging them by hand. Wang, Song, Jin and Makse derived the random close packing fraction from statistical mechanics as \( \phi_{RCP} = 6/(6 + 2\sqrt{3}) \approx 0.634 \). The other 36.6% is gaps, which in our case fill with syrup.

SymbolMeaningValueBasis
\(D_p, h\)Pothole diameter and depth0.50 m, 0.05 mMy estimate of a typical urban pothole
\(V_p\)Pothole volume, a shallow bowl \( \approx \tfrac{1}{2}\pi r^{2} h \)4.9 lCalculated
\(d\)Gulab jamun diameter3.4 cmMarket samples 3.09–3.60 cm (Sukre et al., 2021)
\(m_j\)Gulab jamun mass34 gMarket samples 24.2–44.4 g (same study)
\(\phi\)Random close packing fraction0.634Wang et al., 2011
\(s\)Sugar in the syrup60% by mass, density 1.29 kg/lMy assumption for a thick chashni
  1. Volume of one jamun. \( V_j = \tfrac{\pi}{6} d^{3} = \tfrac{\pi}{6}(0.034)^{3} = 2.06\times10^{-5}\ \text{m}^{3} \), about 20.6 ml.
  2. Jamuns per pothole. \( n = \dfrac{\phi V_p}{V_j} = \dfrac{0.634 \times 0.0049}{2.06\times10^{-5}} = 151 \).
  3. National total. \( 151 \times 6.3\times10^{6} = 9.5\times10^{8} \), about 95 crore gulab jamuns, roughly two for every three Indians.
  4. Mass of sweets. \( 151 \times 0.034 = 5.1 \) kg per pothole; about 32,000 tonnes in all.
road surface50 cm across, 5 cm deep, about 4.9 litres63.4% gulab jamun, 36.6% syrup (random close packing)
A pothole as a container of spheres. Random packing leaves just over a third of the volume as gaps, which the syrup fills. Drawing not to scale.

How much sugar would that take?

About 2.7 kg of sugar per pothole and roughly 17,000 tonnes nationally, which is about five hours of what India eats in sugar, using ISMA's estimate of 280 lakh tonnes a year. The sugar is the easy part.

  1. Syrup between the jamuns. Gaps are \( (1-\phi)V_p = 0.366 \times 4.9 = 1.79 \) l, holding \( 1.79 \times 1.29 = 2.31 \) kg of syrup, of which 60% is sugar: 1.39 kg.
  2. Sugar inside the jamuns. Market gulab jamuns absorbed 12.2% to 37.7% sugar in one study. At 25%: \( 0.25 \times 5.1 = 1.28 \) kg.
  3. Per pothole. \( 1.39 + 1.28 = 2.67 \) kg.
  4. National. \( 2.67 \times 6.3\times10^{6} = 1.68\times10^{7} \) kg, about 16,800 tonnes. India's daily sugar use is about 76,700 tonnes, so this is 0.22 days, or 5.3 hours.

Fill India's potholes with gulab jamun

Evaluation of selected physico-chemical, colour and textural characteristics of market GulabjamunVivekanand Natha Sukre, Pradyuman Barnwal, Bhavesh B. Chavhan, Ankit Deep, Pooja N. Bhagat · Indian Journal of Dairy Science 74(6) · 2021

The authors bought six brands of market gulab jamun and measured composition, colour and texture with a texture analyser. Moisture ranged from 40.5% to 47.5% (dry basis), fat 6.5–12.3%, absorbed sugar 12.2–37.7%, diameter 3.09–3.60 cm and unit weight 24.2–44.4 g. Hardness, the peak force in compression, ranged from 3.36 to 10.71 N. The limit: six commercial brands from one region; home-made jamuns and different syrup strengths will differ.

Read the abstract (free)
A bowl of gulab jamuns in sugar syrup served as a Diwali sweet
Gulab jamun in chashni. Soft, porous and up to 38% absorbed sugar: an excellent dessert and, as the numbers show, a terrible road base.Photo: Yakshitha, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Could a gulab jamun hold up a car?

No. The hardest market gulab jamun resists with about 11.8 kPa when squashed by half, and a car tyre presses on the road at roughly 220 kPa, close to its inflation pressure. The tyre wins by a factor of about 19, so the jamuns collapse to a paste and the wheel drops into the hole anyway.

A tyre's contact patch carries the vehicle's load at a pressure close to the air pressure inside the tyre; that is why a softer tyre has a bigger footprint. For a car at 32 psi, about 220 kPa, and a loaded truck at several times that (both my working figures). The question is whether the filler can carry that stress without deforming far.

\[ \sigma_{jamun} = \frac{F_{hardness}}{\tfrac{\pi}{4} d^{2}} \quad \text{versus} \quad p_{tyre} \approx p_{inflation} \]
  1. Jamun cross-section. \( A = \tfrac{\pi}{4} d^{2} = \tfrac{\pi}{4}(0.034)^{2} = 9.08\times10^{-4}\ \text{m}^{2} \).
  2. Stress at measured hardness. \( \sigma = F/A = 10.71 / 9.08\times10^{-4} = 11{,}800\ \text{Pa} \), 11.8 kPa, for the hardest brand; the softest gives 3.7 kPa.
  3. Tyre against jamun. \( 220 / 11.8 = 18.6 \). The tyre applies about 19 times the stress the gulab jamun can resist even after being squashed to half height.
  4. Effective stiffness. Dividing that stress by the 50% strain of the test gives an apparent modulus of about 24 kPa, softer than most foam rubber.

Packing helps less than you might hope. In a bed of spheres, load travels through a few chains of touching spheres, so the contact stress on each sphere is higher than the average, not lower. Under the first scooter the top layer bursts, the syrup squeezes out sideways, and the hole is back, now slippery as well as open.

Load against resistance, drawn to scale (kPa)Car tyre≈ 220Scooter tyre≈ 200Hardest jamun11.8Softest jamun3.71 kPa = 2.2 px; the jamun bars are the whole of their strength
The stress ratio behind the verdict, using the working figures above: tyre contact near inflation pressure against the hardness of market gulab jamuns (Sukre et al., 2021) converted to stress. The tyre wins by about 19 times for the hardest jamun.
A patch must be stiffer than the load, waterproof and not food.

What would the ants do?

Ants would find every pothole within hours, because the syrup is more than twice as concentrated as the sugar solutions ants are already shown to prefer. A 60% syrup is about 2.3 molar sucrose; Argentine ants in a 2025 study reliably chose 1 molar over 0.75 molar.

\[ c = \frac{0.60 \times 1{,}290\ \text{g/l}}{342.3\ \text{g/mol}} = 2.26\ \text{mol/l} \]

Rain would then dilute the syrup and wash it into drains, turning roadside water sweet and feeding microbes as well as ants. The jamuns themselves, with 40–47% moisture and plenty of milk solids, would begin to spoil in Indian heat within a day or two.

A high-throughput and sensitive method for food preference assays in the Argentine antThomas Wagner, Henrique Galante, Tomer J. Czaczkes · Pest Management Science 81(10) · 2025

The team built a 3D-printed dual-choice feeder in which an ant meets two solutions a fraction of a millimetre apart, and tested 422 ants from nine colony fragments for sucrose preference. Ants spent 15.8% more time on 1 M sucrose than on 0.5 M and 19.4% more than on 0.75 M, and the method detected aversion to quinine as low as 0.31 mM. The limit: one invasive species in the lab; Indian ants and street conditions will differ, though the preference for stronger sugar is common.

Read the paper (free)
Jamming II: Edwards' statistical mechanics of random packings of hard spheresPing Wang, Chaoming Song, Yuliang Jin, Hernan A. Makse · Physica A 390(3) · 2011

The authors use Edwards' statistical mechanics of granular matter to derive the densest random packing of equal hard spheres, arriving at a volume fraction of \( 6/(6+2\sqrt{3}) \approx 0.634 \), in line with experiments on poured and shaken spheres. The limit: hard, frictionless-to-frictional rigid spheres; soft, sticky gulab jamuns deform and will pack a little more densely once squashed.

Read the paper (free)

How sensitive is the answer?

The count of jamuns moves by a factor of ten with the pothole estimate, but the verdict does not move at all, because it rests on a stress ratio of about 19 that no plausible jamun closes.

ChangeJamuns neededSugarVerdict changes?
0.5 potholes per km48 crore8,400 tNo
1 pothole per km (central)95 crore16,800 tNo
5 potholes per km (Bengaluru rate everywhere)476 crore84,000 t, about 1.1 days of sugarNo
Softest market jamun (3.36 N)SameSameTyre now wins by about 60 times
Scooter at 200 kPa instead of a carSameSameTyre still wins by about 17 times

Where the model breaks: real potholes are irregular and often deeper at the edges, and a texture-analyser hardness is measured at one speed. A tyre hits much faster, and a wet, sugary material may stiffen briefly under fast loading. Not by a factor of 19.

Verdict: impossible as a road repair

India could make the roughly 95 crore gulab jamuns and spare the 17,000 tonnes of sugar in about five hours of national consumption. The road would still fail, because simple stress, \( \sigma = F/A \), shows a squashed gulab jamun resists about 11.8 kPa while a car tyre applies about 220 kPa. A patch must be stiffer than the load, waterproof and not food; a properly compacted bituminous patch is all three, which is why road crews use it rather than mithai.

For why roads break in the first place, read why Indian cities flood and how speed breakers are supposed to be designed. State-by-state crash data is in road deaths by state. Riders should also see the Motoverse guide to monsoon motorcycle maintenance, the season when potholes multiply.

What if next?

Questions people ask

How many people die because of potholes in India?

Government data placed before Parliament counted 2,385 deaths in pothole-related crashes in 2024 and 9,438 from 2020 to 2024, based on state police reports.

How many potholes are there in Bengaluru?

In September 2025 The Week reported about 9,973 potholes on ward roads and 4,400 on arterial and sub-arterial roads. By December 2025 the Greater Bengaluru Authority said it had filled 22,539 since April.

How much does a gulab jamun weigh?

Market gulab jamuns in a 2021 Indian Journal of Dairy Science study weighed 24.2 to 44.4 g, with diameters of 3.1 to 3.6 cm and 12–38% absorbed sugar.

Why do potholes form so fast in the monsoon?

Water gets into cracks in the bituminous surface and weakens the layers below; traffic then pumps the wet base out and the surface breaks away. Poor drainage and thin patches make it worse.

Sources

  1. Outlook India (PTI): Pothole deaths rise 53% in 5 years (2026). Source for 2020–2024 deaths.
  2. The Week: City of potholes? Bengaluru's road crisis (2025). Source for Bengaluru pothole counts and road length.
  3. Swarajya: Over 22,000 potholes filled in Bengaluru (2025)
  4. PRS Legislative Research: Road Transport and Highways, Demand for Grants 2023-24 (2023). Source for the 63 lakh km road network.
  5. Sukre V.N. et al.: Characteristics of market Gulabjamun, Indian Journal of Dairy Science (2021). Source for size, mass, sugar and hardness.
  6. Wang P., Song C., Jin Y., Makse H.A.: Jamming II, Physica A (2011). Source for the 0.634 packing fraction.
  7. Wagner T., Galante H., Czaczkes T.J.: Food preference assays in the Argentine ant, Pest Management Science (2025). Source for ant sucrose preference.
  8. ChiniMandi: Sugar consumption likely at 280 lakh tonnes in 2024-25, says ISMA (2025). Source for daily sugar use.
  9. The Better India: Dadarao Bilhore fills Mumbai's potholes after his son's death (2016). Source for the story: date, road and materials.
  10. Gulf News: Indian father fills 556 potholes after his son dies in accident (2018). Source for the first pothole in December 2015 and the 556 count.
potholesgulab jamunrandom close packingroad safetyMoRTHsucroseantscontact pressure
Sapta

Sapta (Saptarshi Sarkar) is a mechanical engineer turned marketer in Bengaluru and a solo touring rider. He writes the seven Saptaverse blogs. Work with him or read more of Whyblog.

Keep reading in Whyblog

From the other blogs