What if India had two time zones? The daylight maths

India is two hours of sun wide and runs on one clock. Split it, and the Northeast gets its mornings back, the railways get a headache at two stations, and children in the west may sleep more.

Rows of tea bushes in an Assam tea garden under a pale sky
Photo: Vikramjit Kakati, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

If India had two time zones, the Northeast and the Andaman and Nicobar Islands would move their clocks one hour ahead to UTC+6:30, as CSIR-NPL proposed in 2018, and offices there would open in daylight instead of four hours after sunrise. The national timekeeper estimated the switch would save about 20 million kWh of electricity a year, only two railway stations on the West Bengal and Assam border would need special handling, and Assam's tea gardens already run on that clock informally. The bigger prize may be sleep: one study links an hour of later sunset to about 30 minutes less sleep for Indian children.

Key takeaways
  • About 29° of longitude separates Gujarat and Arunachal: roughly two hours of sun on one clock.
  • UTC+6:30 (IST-II) is CSIR-NPL's 2018 proposal for the Northeast and the Andamans, with the border at 89°52′E.
  • 2 × 10⁷ kWh a year is the estimated electricity saving: real, but small.
  • About 30 minutes less child sleep per hour of later sunset, by Jagnani's estimate.
  • Only two stations, New Cooch Behar and Alipurduar, would sit where trains cross the zone line.

India stretches from about 68°7′E in Gujarat to 97°25′E in Arunachal Pradesh. That is roughly 29 degrees of longitude, and because the Earth turns 15 degrees an hour, it is about two hours of sun.

Yet the whole country reads one time, Indian Standard Time (IST), set on the 82°30′E meridian near Mirzapur in Uttar Pradesh. This post runs the what-if properly: the geometry, the proposals on the table, the evidence on sleep and electricity, and what would break on day one.

~29°of longitude across India, about 2 hours of solar time (CSIR-NPL 2018)
UTC+6:30proposed IST-II for the Northeast and the islands
2 × 10⁷ kWhestimated yearly electricity saving from IST-II (CSIR-NPL)
~30 minless child sleep per hour of later sunset (Jagnani)

Why does India have only one time zone?

India has one time zone because of history and administrative convenience, not geography. British India adopted a standard time on 1 January 1906, replacing the "Madras time" that railways had used, and the new Republic made IST the official time for the whole country after 1947.

Calcutta kept its own local time until 1948 and Bombay held on to Bombay Time until 1955, so for a few years India already lived with several clocks.

The clocks India used to keep

Those older clocks show how wide the country is. Bombay Time was UTC+4:51 and Calcutta Time was UTC+5:53:20, a gap of just over an hour between two cities. The compromise meridian, 82°30′E, sits almost exactly between them. It works well for the middle of the country and badly at the edges.

One clock across 29 degrees of longitude68°7′E Gujarat97°25′E ArunachalIST meridian 82°30′EIST-II border 89°52′EUTC+6:30stays UTC+5:30Sun runs about 51 min behind the clock at Bhuj (69.7°E)Sun runs about 58 min ahead of the clock at Kibithu (97.0°E)Rule: 4 minutes of sun time per degree away from 82.5°E
Longitudes and the IST-II border from the CSIR-NPL paper (2018). The offsets are the 4-minutes-per-degree rule, ignoring the equation of time.

The proposals that came and went

Government panels have looked at splitting the clock several times:

  • 2001–2004: a four-member committee set up in 2001 reported to Parliament in 2004 that the single zone should stay.
  • June 2017: the Department of Science and Technology studied a split with an Eastern India Time of UTC+6:00.
  • August 2026: the Centre went the other way, notifying rules that make IST the single legal time reference for banks, railways, telecom and power grids.

One state did not wait for Delhi to decide.

The story

In the first days of 2014, Assam's chief minister Tarun Gogoi announced that his state would move to bagaan (tea garden) time, an hour ahead of IST, and sent the proposal for a separate time zone to the Centre. His argument was daylight: in June the Northeast is bright before 4 am IST, and in November it is dark by 5 pm, so offices running 10 am to 5 pm waste the morning and burn electricity in the evening. He wanted a 9-to-4 day instead. The filmmaker Jahnu Barua backed a zone for all seven northeastern states. West Bengal's science minister objected that it would upset aviation and railways, and neighbouring states did not join. The clock never changed.

Al Jazeera: Indian state pushes to set clock right (8 January 2014)
The stone clock tower in Mirzapur, Uttar Pradesh
The clock tower in Mirzapur. The 82°30′E meridian that defines Indian Standard Time passes through Mirzapur district, so this is roughly where IST is "true" sun time.Photo: Rangan Datta Wiki, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

How far is the sun from the clock in each part of India?

At the eastern edge of India the sun reaches its highest point around 11:00 IST, and at the western edge closer to 12:50, so the clock is wrong by about an hour at each end in opposite directions.

You can work this out from first principles. Solar noon on the clock is 12:00 plus four minutes for every degree you sit west of the zone meridian, plus a small seasonal correction called the equation of time, which never exceeds about 16 minutes.

The worked example: Kibithu and Bhuj

  1. Kibithu, Arunachal Pradesh (about 97.0°E). The gap to 82.5°E is 14.5 degrees. Multiply by four minutes and the sun is about 58 minutes ahead of the clock.
  2. Bhuj, Kutch (about 69.7°E). The gap is 12.8 degrees the other way, so the sun runs about 51 minutes behind.
  3. Check against NPL. I computed the sunrise and sunset times below with the NOAA solar position equations; they agree with the CSIR-NPL paper, which gives a 5:06 sunrise at Dong on the equinox, against my 5:07 for nearby Kibithu.
Place (longitude)Sunrise 21 JunSunset 21 JunSunrise 21 DecSunset 21 DecSolar noon (Dec)
Kibithu, Arunachal (97.0°E)04:0618:0105:4916:1110:59
Guwahati (91.7°E)04:3118:1806:0616:3611:21
Kolkata (88.4°E)04:5218:2306:1216:5711:34
Delhi (77.2°E)05:2319:2207:0917:2912:19
Mumbai (72.9°E)06:0119:1807:0718:0612:36
Bhuj, Kutch (69.7°E)06:0619:4007:2818:1012:49

Reading the December column as an office worker

In Guwahati the sun sets at 16:36, an hour before most offices close, so the working evening runs on electric light. In Bhuj the sun is barely up at 07:28 when school buses leave, and it sets at 18:10.

The CSIR-NPL team made the same point with office hours of 9:00 to 17:30. Daylight covers those hours:

  • In all four seasons at Kanyakumari, Kavaratti and Guhar Moti;
  • In three seasons at Kolkata and Alipurduar;
  • Only in summer at Dong and Port Blair.
Sunrise and sunset on 21 December 2026, in IST (hours)
See the data as a table
Sunrise (h)Sunset (h)
Kibithu5.8116.18
Guwahati6.116.6
Kolkata6.216.95
Delhi7.1617.48
Mumbai7.1218.1
Bhuj7.4718.17

Source: Computed with the NOAA solar position equations (author's calculation) · Decimal hours: 16.60 means 16:36. Atmospheric refraction included via the 90.833 degree zenith.

Try your own town. The calculator uses the same geometry: enter a longitude and a clock offset, and it tells you how far the clock runs from the sun.

How far is your clock from the sun?

What exactly did CSIR-NPL propose?

CSIR-National Physical Laboratory, the body that keeps Indian Standard Time on an ensemble of caesium clocks and a hydrogen maser, proposed two zones in Current Science in October 2018.

ZoneOffsetLongitudesWho
IST-IUTC+5:3068°7′E to 89°52′EEverything west of the Assam border
IST-IIUTC+6:3089°52′E to 97°25′EAssam, Meghalaya, Nagaland, Arunachal Pradesh, Manipur, Mizoram, Tripura, Andaman and Nicobar Islands

Why the border sits where it does

The choice of border is the clever part. The team put the line on the West Bengal and Assam border because the rail network there narrows to a thin corridor.

Only two stations, New Cooch Behar and Alipurduar, sit where trains would cross between zones, so timings could be managed by hand while signalling is not fully automated. Delivering IST-II would need a second "Primary Time Ensemble" laboratory somewhere in the Northeast, linked to the Delhi ensemble by satellite time transfer.

Necessity of 'two time zones: IST-I (UTC + 5:30 h) and IST-II (UTC + 6:30 h)' in India and its implementationLakhi Sharma et al. (CSIR-NPL) · Current Science 115(7) · 2018

The national timekeeper mapped sunrise and sunset at 10 locations across India from yearly sun graphs and compared them with 9:00 to 17:30 office hours. It found IST fits the south and west, is manageable for Kolkata and Gangtok, and is "highly unsuitable" for Dong and Port Blair. It proposed UTC+6:30 for the Northeast and the islands, with the border at 89°52′E, and estimated 2 × 10⁷ kWh a year of electricity savings using 2011 Census populations and per-capita commercial consumption. The limit: the energy model is simple, assumes savings only in the commercial sector (8.33% of electricity use in 2011), and does not test behaviour change.

Read the paper (free)

How much electricity would two time zones save?

About 20 million kWh a year, by CSIR-NPL's estimate, which is real but small. The paper's method is a direct sum over the eight IST-II states: multiply each state's population by its per-person, per-hour commercial electricity use and by the daily hours of lighting saved, then add them up.

The working, in words

  1. The formula. Saving = sum over states of (commercial consumption per person per hour) × (population) × (hours saved a day) × 365.
  2. Who dominates. Assam has 3.12 crore of the region's roughly 4.5 crore people in the 2011 Census, even though its per-person use was only 250 kWh a year against Arunachal Pradesh's 683.
  3. Per person. 2 × 10⁷ kWh spread over about 4.54 crore people is roughly 0.44 kWh per person per year, about 12 hours of one 36-watt tube light.

The value of the switch is less in the power bill and more in whether people's waking hours line up with daylight.

The other route: advance the whole country

Researchers have argued the other route too: instead of a second zone, advance the whole of IST by half an hour. Ahuja, Sen Gupta and Agrawal made that case in Current Science in 2007, on the grounds that the evening lighting peak drives demand nationwide. Their modelling is outside what I could open, so the size of that saving is not quoted here.

What is chaibagan time, and does it already work?

Chaibagan time, or tea-garden time, is a clock set one hour ahead of IST that Assam's tea estates have kept unofficially since the British period. It is the same offset as the proposed IST-II, which is why the CSIR-NPL paper cites it as proof that a UTC+6:30 day already functions in the region.

The logic is plain once you look at the December table. A garden worker who starts plucking at 7:00 chaibagan time is starting at 6:00 IST, just as the light arrives around Guwahati, and finishes before the 16:36 sunset.

Assam's chief minister Tarun Gogoi campaigned for a separate zone in 2014 on the same reasoning, as the story above tells. The catch is that chaibagan time lives inside a single industry: everyone in the garden switches clocks together, while buses, banks and trains around them stay on IST.

Guwahati, 21 December: same sun, two clocks06:0010:0014:0018:00ISTdaylight 06:06–16:36office 09:00–17:30, last 54 min in the darkIST-IIdaylight 07:06–17:36office 09:00–17:30, all in daylightScale: 40 px per hour. Sun times from the NOAA working above.
Moving the clock does not add daylight; it moves the office day under it. In Guwahati in December, one hour is enough to cover the whole 9:00 to 17:30 day.
Gori Chen mountain range in the Arunachal Himalayas lit by the rising sun
Sunrise over the Gori Chen range in Arunachal Pradesh. In June the sun rises in the far east of the state a little after 4:00 IST.Photo: Koshy Koshy from Faridabad, Haryana, India, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Would people actually sleep and learn better?

The best evidence says yes, mostly through children's bedtimes. Maulik Jagnani, an economist now at Tufts, found that because wake-up times are fixed by school and work, a later sunset pushes bedtime later and simply removes sleep.

India is a natural experiment: sunset in the west comes more than 90 minutes later than in the east, on the same clock.

Children's Sleep and Human Capital ProductionMaulik Jagnani · working paper (Cornell, later Tufts); summarised on the World Bank Development Impact blog · 2019

Using the 1998–99 Indian Time Use Survey, the 2015 India DHS, Chinese time-use data and a regression discontinuity at Indonesia's time-zone border in Kalimantan, Jagnani estimates that an hour's delay in annual average sunset cuts children's sleep by about 30 minutes, lowers years of education by 0.8 in India, reduces enrolment by about 20% and lowers maths scores by 0.6 standard deviations. Effects are larger in poorer households. A back-of-envelope estimate puts the gain from splitting India into UTC+5 and UTC+6 zones at over US$4.2 billion a year, about 0.2% of GDP. The limit: the policy number is a rough extrapolation, and the author says the study does not identify an optimal time zone.

Read the summary by the author (free)

Two proposals, two different problems

Note the twist. Jagnani's split helps the west as much as the east, because moving western India to UTC+5 makes its sunsets earlier. The NPL plan only moves the Northeast.

So NPL targets wasted mornings in the east, and Jagnani targets late evenings in the west. If you care about the sleep side of this, the mechanism links to how memory is consolidated overnight, covered in this piece on sleep and memory.

OptionClocksWho gainsMain cost
Status quoAll India UTC+5:30Central India; no transition costDark evenings in the east in winter; late sunsets in the west
CSIR-NPL two zones (2018)UTC+5:30 and UTC+6:30 east of 89°52′ENortheast and Andamans; 2 × 10⁷ kWh a yearSecond time lab; clock change at New Cooch Behar and Alipurduar
West and east split (Jagnani)UTC+5 west of 82.5°E, UTC+6 eastChildren's sleep nationwide; est. US$4.2 bn a yearBorder cuts through densely populated central India
Advance IST by 30 minAll India UTC+6:00Evening peak demand; the eastDarker mornings in the west, worse late sunsets there
A clock change does not create daylight. It decides whether people are awake while the daylight is there.The working of this post

What would break on day one?

Very little breaks if the line is drawn where NPL drew it, because time zones are a solved problem for computers and a nuisance for people. Phones, servers and payment systems already store time in UTC and display a local offset. The work is in timetables, schedules and the habits of people who cross the line daily.

  • Railways. A train from Delhi to Guwahati would cross the zone line near Alipurduar. Indian Railways would have to print timetables in one zone or show both, as airlines do. NPL's choice of a border with just two crossing stations is meant to keep this manageable. If you have ever routed a bike by rail across that corridor, the paperwork already teaches patience; see how to send a bike by train in India.
  • Television and exams. National broadcasts, results and competitive exams would carry two times, or start an hour later in the Northeast's local terms.
  • Markets and banks. Stock exchanges and RTGS windows would keep IST-I. Northeast traders would open an hour later on their own clocks, which is the point.
  • Law. The Legal Metrology (Indian Standard Time) Rules notified in August 2026 make IST the single legal reference from March 2027. A second zone would need those rules amended. One of the five regional time labs planned under the rules is in Guwahati, which (my suggestion, not the government's) would be a natural home for the IST-II clock ensemble NPL asked for.

The strongest argument against the split is not technical. Officials have repeatedly cited "strategic reasons" and the fear that a clock line could read as a political line. That is a judgement call, not physics, and the data in this post cannot settle it.

Howrah Railway Station building seen from Howrah Bridge in Kolkata
Howrah station, Kolkata. Calcutta kept its own local time, UTC+5:53:20, until 1948, and railway timetables were one reason India moved to a single clock.Photo: Bernard Gagnon, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

So what would two time zones really change?

Two time zones would mostly change when people in the Northeast wake, work and switch on lights, and very little else. Step by step:

  1. Electricity: the saving is modest, at about 20 GWh a year.
  2. Sleep and schooling: the evidence is stronger, but applies most to a west and east split, not to the NPL plan alone.
  3. Systems: railways, banks and phones can cope with a clean border at two stations.
  4. Politics: the decision that blocks it.

My reading of the numbers: if the goal is the Northeast's mornings, the NPL line plus a formal blessing for chaibagan hours gets most of the benefit. If the goal is children's sleep nationwide, the debate has to include western India, where the late sunsets are.

What if next?

Questions people ask

Why does India not have two time zones like the US?

India spans about 29 degrees of longitude, roughly two hours of sun, while the US by law has nine standard time zones including its territories. Successive governments have preferred one clock for administrative simplicity and have cited strategic reasons, and in 2026 they made IST the single legal time reference.

What time would it be in Assam with two time zones?

Under the CSIR-NPL plan, Assam would run on IST-II, UTC+6:30, one hour ahead of the rest of India. When it is 9:00 in Delhi, it would be 10:00 in Guwahati, which is the same hour Assam's tea gardens already keep as chaibagan time.

Is chaibagan time legal?

It is an informal practice inside tea estates rather than a legal time. Under the Legal Metrology (Indian Standard Time) Rules notified in 2026, IST is the mandatory reference for legal, commercial and official purposes, so official records in Assam use IST.

How much daylight does the Northeast lose?

In December, the sun sets around 16:11 IST in eastern Arunachal and 16:36 in Guwahati, so roughly an hour of a 9:00 to 17:30 working day falls after sunset, while an hour or more of morning light passes before offices open. A one-hour shift moves that hour from the dark evening to the bright morning.

Would two time zones confuse trains?

Some, but less than people expect. The CSIR-NPL border runs where only two stations, New Cooch Behar and Alipurduar, would need clock handling, and railways in countries with several zones manage this routinely with timetables in local time.

Sources

  1. Sharma L. et al., CSIR-NPL: Necessity of two time zones IST-I and IST-II in India, Current Science 115(7) (2018). Source for the 68°7′E to 97°25′E extent, the 89°52′E border, the two stations, the 2 × 10⁷ kWh estimate and chaibagan time.
  2. Al Jazeera: Indian state pushes to set clock right (2014). Source for the story: Gogoi's bagaan time announcement, the 9-to-4 office day, Jahnu Barua and West Bengal's objection.
  3. Jagnani M.: Here comes the sunset, World Bank Development Impact blog (2019). Source for the 30-minute sleep effect and education estimates.
  4. Ideas for India: the same study, with the UTC+5 and UTC+6 split and the US$4.2 billion estimate (2019)
  5. NOAA Global Monitoring Laboratory: General solar position calculations. Equations used for the sunrise and sunset table.
  6. Wikipedia: Indian Standard Time, with its references to The Hindu, IRFCA and BBC. Source for 1906 adoption, Bombay and Calcutta time, and the 2001 and 2017 studies.
  7. Business Standard: Centre notifies rules mandating IST as single common time reference (2026)
  8. Free Press Journal: India to adopt single legal IST from March 2027 (2026)
  9. The Asian Age: Draft Legal Metrology (IST) Rules notified for consultation (2025)
Indian Standard TimeIST-IIchaibagan timeCSIR-NPLtime zonescircadian rhythmNortheast IndiaLegal Metrology (IST) Rules
Sapta

Sapta (Saptarshi Sarkar) is a mechanical engineer turned marketer in Bengaluru and a solo touring rider. He writes the seven Saptaverse blogs. Work with him or read more of Whyblog.

Keep reading in Whyblog

From the other blogs