The case for silence: why thinking needs empty time

In one famous experiment, two-thirds of men chose an electric shock over 15 quiet minutes with their thoughts. Why empty time feels so hard, and why the mind seems to need it anyway.

A large seated Buddha statue in meditation at the Buddha Park in Sarnath, Uttar Pradesh
Photo: K.Venkataramana, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons

Silence and unstructured time matter for thinking because the brain does a different kind of work when it is not handling outside input: it replays, links and recombines, and that "incubation" measurably helps creative problem-solving. People avoid it anyway. In Timothy Wilson's 2014 experiments, students left alone for 6 to 15 minutes found it hard to concentrate, and 67% of men and 25% of women gave themselves an electric shock they had earlier said they would pay to avoid. The skill is learnable, and India's tradition of mauna treats it as exactly that.

Key takeaways
  • 67% of men and 25% of women shocked themselves rather than sit 15 minutes with their thoughts (Wilson 2014).
  • Somewhat enjoyable, somewhat boring: a reanalysis of 190 people put the average near the midpoint.
  • Incubation: undemanding breaks that let the mind wander improved creative scores (Baird 2012).
  • Content decides: drifting into worry lowers mood; drifting into plans and good memories does not.
  • Mauna in the Gita is an austerity of the mind, not just not talking.

I think best in silence and need unstructured time alone. It turns out to be a contested idea in psychology, with two camps:

  • The aversive camp has data that being alone with your thoughts is unpleasant and that a wandering mind is an unhappy one.
  • The incubation camp has data that idle, wandering minds solve problems better.

Both are right, and the reason they are both right is the useful part. One of the best-known first-hand accounts of what idle time can do comes from a mathematician on a bus.

The story

In the early 1880s Henri Poincaré, then living in Caen, spent fifteen days at his desk trying to prove that a certain class of functions could not exist. A sleepless night after black coffee gave him the first breakthrough. Then he left on a geological excursion run by the School of Mines, and travel pushed the mathematics out of his head.

At Coutances, as he put his foot on the step of an omnibus, the key idea arrived with nothing seeming to lead to it: the transformations behind his Fuchsian functions were the same as those of non-Euclidean geometry. He carried on a conversation, felt certain, and checked it properly only back in Caen. He later described the same sudden certainty arriving on a seaside walk after he had given up on another problem.

Henri Poincaré: The Foundations of Science, Science and Method, Mathematical Creation (Halsted translation, Project Gutenberg)

Do people really prefer an electric shock to their own thoughts?

Some do, but fewer than the headline suggests. In study 10 of Wilson and colleagues' 2014 Science paper, participants first rated a mild shock and said they would pay to avoid it. Then they sat alone for 15 minutes with a button that could deliver the same shock. Among those who had said they would pay to avoid it, 12 of 18 men (67%) and 6 of 24 women (25%) pressed it at least once. Most pressed it once or twice; one man pressed it 190 times and was left out of the averages.

Gave themselves at least one shock during 15 minutes alone
See the data as a table
Share who self-shocked (%)
Men (12 of 18)67
Women (6 of 24)25

Source: Wilson et al., Science 2014, study 10 · Only participants who had said they would pay to avoid the shock. Samples are small: 42 people in all.

The broader finding came from the other studies in the paper. Across six lab studies with 146 students:

  • 57.5% said it was hard to concentrate;
  • 89% said their minds wandered;
  • 49.3% rated the experience at or below the midpoint for enjoyment (Wilson et al. 2014, studies 1 to 6).

When students tried it at home, 32% admitted they "cheated" by using a phone, listening to music or getting up (Wilson et al. 2014, study 7). A community sample aged 18 to 77, recruited at a farmers' market and a church, gave similar answers, and enjoyment was not related to age, income, or how much people used smartphones.

Condition (Wilson et al. 2014)PeopleEnjoyment (1 to 9)Hard to concentrate (1 to 9)Mind wandered (1 to 9)
Thinking alone, in the lab (studies 1 to 6)1465.125.046.86
Thinking alone, at home (study 7)444.356.097.14
Thinking alone, at home (study 8)153.206.076.67
Reading, music or web, at home (study 8)156.872.803.67
Just think: the challenges of the disengaged mindWilson TD, Reinhard DA, Westgate EC, Gilbert DT, et al. · Science 345: 75 to 77 · 2014

Eleven studies asked mostly college students to sit in a bare room without phones or pens for 6 to 15 minutes and simply entertain themselves with their thoughts. Most found it hard and not very enjoyable, enjoyed reading or music far more (t = 4.83, p < 0.001), and in study 10 many self-administered a shock rather than sit idle. Two individual traits consistently predicted enjoyment: a tendency to positive, constructive daydreaming (higher enjoyment) and poor attentional control (lower). The limit: small samples in the key studies, an unusual setting, and a "thinking period" with no goal, which is not how most people use quiet time.

Read the paper (free)

Was the shock study overstated?

Partly. Later in 2014, Kieran Fox, Evan Thompson, Jessica Andrews-Hanna and Kalina Christoff reanalysed Wilson's open data in Frontiers in Psychology. Across 190 participants in studies 1 to 7, average ratings were 5.21 for enjoyment, 4.24 for entertainment and 4.60 for boredom on nine-point scales whose midpoints meant "somewhat". Their reading: thinking alone was, on average, somewhat enjoyable and somewhat boring, with very wide spread between people. They also showed that the shock counts were driven by a minority.

Is thinking really aversive? A commentary on Wilson et al.'s "Just think: the challenges of the disengaged mind"Fox KCR, Thompson E, Andrews-Hanna JR, Christoff K · Frontiers in Psychology 5: 1427 · 2014

Using the authors' publicly posted data, the commentary plotted distributions of enjoyment, entertainment and boredom for 190 participants and found means near the scale midpoints, not in the unpleasant range. It argues that Wilson's first and third claims (people do not enjoy thinking; many prefer shocks) are weakly supported, while the second (people enjoy engaging activities more) holds. It also summarises earlier daydreaming studies that found mixed or positive feelings. The limit: a reanalysis of the same small samples, so it narrows the claim rather than overturning it. Wilson's team replied in the same issue.

Read the paper (free)

The fair summary is that empty time is not torture, but it is effortful, and for people who are not used to it, the first few minutes feel worse than any distraction on offer. That is the same pattern the r/getdisciplined thread above describes from the other side: hours on a feed are easy, an hour of study is not, and the difference is less about focus than about how much effort the mind expects. Our post on why you can scroll for hours but cannot study takes that apart.

A painting of Adi Shankara seated with disciples on a riverbank
Shankara teaching by a river. In the Indian traditions, the teacher's quiet and the student's silence were part of the method, not a gap in it.Photo: Unknown authorUnknown author, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

What happens in the brain during quiet, unfocused time?

When attention is not pulled outward, activity shifts towards the default mode network, the set of brain regions most active at rest and during memory, imagination and thinking about people. Wilson's paper itself frames "just thinking" as default-mode processing. This network is not idle. Recent work shows it shapes what you think about next and consolidates what you have just learned.

Two experiments on idle minds and ideas

Two studies make the case that this matters for ideas. In a 2012 Psychological Science experiment, Benjamin Baird and colleagues gave people the Unusual Uses Task (think of new uses for a brick, say), then a break.

Those whose break was an undemanding task that let the mind wander improved substantially on problems they had already seen, more than those who rested, did a demanding task or had no break. The gain tracked how much their minds wandered, not how much they consciously thought about the problem.

And in a 2022 Molecular Psychiatry study, surgeons briefly disrupted a default-network node with electrical stimulation in patients undergoing awake brain surgery; their ability to produce alternative uses for objects dropped, while stimulation outside the network did not have that effect.

So the useful kind of empty time is not a blank. It is a light, undemanding state in which the mind is free to drift: a walk, a shower, a long ride, a bus window. Our default mode network explainer covers the anatomy.

Wallas's four stages of creative thought (1926) Preparationload the problem Incubationstep away, let it drift Illuminationthe idea arrives Verificationtest it properly Baird et al. 2012: undemanding breaks with more mind-wandering improved later creative scores Silence protects stage two, which is the stage busy days delete first.
Graham Wallas's model from The Art of Thought (1926). Incubation is the stage that needs empty time, and it is the one modern experiments have tested most.

Is a wandering mind an unhappy mind?

Sometimes, and that is the catch. Matthew Killingsworth and Daniel Gilbert's 2010 Science study used a smartphone app to sample people's thoughts and moods through the day and found that people think about something other than what they are doing almost as often as they think about the task in hand, and that doing so typically makes them less happy. The content matters: drifting into worry or regret feels bad, drifting into plans and pleasant memories does not.

Erin Westgate, a co-author of the shock study, later tested what makes "thinking for pleasure" work. Her 2021 studies in Emotion found that giving people examples of topics that were both meaningful and pleasant made the thinking time more enjoyable, while asking for "meaningful" thoughts alone did not, because some people chose heavy subjects. Press coverage put the gain at about 50% more enjoyment. In other words, quiet time goes better if you walk in with something good to think about.

Which empty time helps?Light activitySitting still, no taskGoodquestion,pleasanttopicsWorry,regretIncubationwalk, shower, commute;creative gains inBaird 2012Effortful but OKmore enjoyable withpleasant, meaningfultopics (Westgate 2021)Drifting lowmind-wandering toworry lowers mood(Killingsworth 2010)Hardestwhere Wilson'sparticipants reachedfor the shock buttonPlacement in the grid is this post's synthesis of the four studies.
Empty time is not one thing. The setting (light activity or sitting still) and the content (a good question or worry) decide whether it feels bad or does useful work.

What do Indian traditions say about silence?

Indian thought treats silence, mauna, as a discipline of the mind rather than just not talking. The Bhagavad Gita lists maunam among the austerities of the mind, alongside serenity, gentleness and self-control (17.16), and Krishna names himself as silence among secrets (10.38).

The Upanishads go further and treat silence as the nearest pointer to the self: the Kena Upanishad describes the self as what cannot be spoken by speech but by which speech is revealed, and the Mandukya Upanishad identifies the silence after the sound of Om with turiya, the fourth state of pure consciousness.

Ramana Maharshi, the 20th-century sage of Tiruvannamalai, taught that real mauna is the state in which the "I"-thought has subsided, which he called egolessness.

The modern practice most Indians meet first is the "noble silence" of Vipassana courses. According to the course code of discipline:

  • students keep silence of body, speech and mind;
  • there is no communication between students by signs or notes;
  • it runs from the start of the course until the morning of the last full day;
  • students may still speak to the teacher and course management.

See our post on whether a 10-day Vipassana course is worth it.

The research adds one caution here. A 2025 survey of nearly 900 American meditators by Nicholas Van Dam and colleagues in Clinical Psychological Science found that attending intensive residential retreats with long periods of silent meditation was linked to more reported functional impairment from meditation side effects. Long silence is a strong intervention; it is wise to build up to it and to go to well-run retreats.

The Ramana Maharshi Shrine and Meditation Centre in Bengaluru
The Ramana Maharshi Shrine and Meditation Centre in Bengaluru. Ramana taught that real mauna is the state in which the "I"-thought falls quiet.Photo: Gpkp, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Is silence golden? Effects of auditory stimuli and their absence on adult hippocampal neurogenesisKirste I, Nicola Z, Kronenberg G, Walker TL, Liu RC, Kempermann G · Brain Structure and Function 220: 1221 to 1228 · 2015

Mice were exposed to background facility noise (the baseline), white noise, recorded pup calls, Mozart's Sonata for Two Pianos (K. 448) or silence, with sounds shifted into the mouse hearing range. All stimuli except white noise raised the division of precursor cells in the hippocampus at 24 hours. After seven days, only silence was still linked to more surviving new cells, and to significantly more new neurons than controls. The limit: this is a mouse study of cell counts, it says nothing direct about human thinking, and the authors interpret silence as unusual, alerting input for mice rather than as rest.

Read the paper (free)

How much empty time do you actually need?

No study gives a dose, so be suspicious of anyone who quotes one. What the research supports is a direction: protect some daily time with no input, make it light rather than effortful, and give it a good question to work on. The bigger obstacle in India now is the phone. Our post on India's screen time and attention lays out how much of the day it already takes.

  1. Start with 10 minutes. Wilson's participants struggled most in the first minutes of an unfamiliar task. Short, regular sessions get past that.
  2. Remove the escape hatch. Leave the phone in another room. A third of Wilson's at-home participants reached for theirs.
  3. Choose low-demand settings. Walking, a commute without earphones, washing up. Baird's best results came from undemanding activity, not from sitting still.
  4. Load a problem first. Incubation works on problems you have already worked on. Think hard, then step away.
  5. Write it down after. Ideas from quiet time fade fast. Verification is Wallas's last stage; it needs a notebook.

Long solo riding, the subject of this site's Yatri section, is one setting where hours pass without input. A deep-work block is another; our deep work routine pairs focused sessions with deliberate breaks.

Questions people ask

Why do I feel restless when it is quiet?

Because thinking without a task is effortful, and most of us have little practice at it. In Wilson's studies, 89% of people said their mind wandered and more than half found it hard to concentrate. It gets easier with short, regular sessions and a pleasant topic to return to.

Is daydreaming bad for you?

It depends on content. Smartphone sampling found that mind-wandering often lowers mood, especially when it turns to worry. But undemanding, wandering breaks improved creative problem-solving in Baird's 2012 experiment. Daydreaming about plans and good memories is not the same as ruminating.

Does silence grow new brain cells?

In mice, a 2015 study found silence was linked to more new hippocampal neurons after seven days than background noise. There is no equivalent result in humans, so treat headlines that say "silence grows your brain" with caution.

Is a Vipassana retreat the best way to practise silence?

It is the most intense way. A 2025 survey linked long silent retreats to more reported impairment from side effects, so it suits people who are well and prepared. Daily short silences are a gentler place to start.

Sources

  1. Wilson et al.: Just think: the challenges of the disengaged mind, Science (2014)
  2. Fox et al.: Is thinking really aversive? Frontiers in Psychology (2014)
  3. Killingsworth and Gilbert: A wandering mind is an unhappy mind, Science (2010)
  4. Baird et al.: Inspired by distraction: mind wandering facilitates creative incubation, Psychological Science (2012)
  5. Shofty et al.: The default network is causally linked to creative thinking, Molecular Psychiatry (2022)
  6. Kirste et al.: Is silence golden? Brain Structure and Function (2015)
  7. University of Florida: Why we're so bad at daydreaming, and how to fix it (Westgate, Emotion 2021) (2021)
  8. ScienceDaily: Van Dam et al., meditation-related adverse effects, Clinical Psychological Science (2025)
  9. Geisler and Meyer: A neural signature of the bias toward self-focus, Journal of Neuroscience (2025)
  10. Henri Poincaré: The Foundations of Science, translated by G. B. Halsted, Science and Method, Mathematical Creation (1913; source for the Coutances story)
  11. Wikipedia: Mauna (silence), with Upanishad and Ramana Maharshi sources
  12. Dhamma.org: Vipassana code of discipline
silencesolitudemind-wanderingdefault mode networkcreativitymaunaincubation
Sapta

Sapta (Saptarshi Sarkar) is a mechanical engineer turned marketer in Bengaluru and a solo touring rider. He writes the seven Saptaverse blogs. Work with him or read more of Mindblog.

Keep reading in Mindblog

From the other blogs