Brand vs performance marketing: why the 60/40 split holds

Performance marketing harvests demand that brand building created. Starve the brand and the harvest gets more expensive every quarter.

A Victorian-era illustrated advertisement for Sunlight Soap
Photo: Unknown authorUnknown author, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

The brand vs performance marketing debate has a data-backed answer: Les Binet and Peter Field's analysis of 996 campaigns in the IPA Effectiveness Databank found the most effective consumer brands spend roughly 60% on brand building and 40% on sales activation. Brand building reaches the 95% of buyers who are not in the market today, so that when they are, your performance ads convert cheaply. Cut brand to fund performance and acquisition costs rise, because the ads are now asking strangers to buy.

Key takeaways
  • 60:40 brand to activation was the split linked to the most very large effects across 996 IPA campaigns; about 46:54 for B2B.
  • 95% of category buyers are not in the market in a given quarter, so performance ads compete for the other 5%.
  • 13% vs 10% in year one, 43% vs 23% by year three: emotional brand campaigns pull away only with time (Binet and Field, IPA).
  • −63% was eBay's experimental ROI on non-brand search, against +4,173% in a naive analysis.
  • Falling blended CAC and rising branded search are the signs brand spend is working.

Most Indian founders I meet treat Meta and Google as the only levers, because those levers show a number by Monday. The number is real. What it measures is narrower than it looks.

This post is about what the dashboards miss, what the long-run data says, and how to apply a 60/40 logic when your company is still small enough that every rupee has to pay back.

60:40brand to activation split linked to the most very large effects (Binet and Field)
95%of category buyers are not in the market at any given time (95-5 rule)
−63%experimental ROI of eBay's non-brand search ads, against +4,173% in naive analysis

What is the difference between brand and performance marketing?

Brand marketing builds memories that make a brand easy to think of and easy to choose later; performance marketing, or sales activation, prompts people who are already looking to act now. Binet and Field's summary contrasts the two:

  • activation produces narrow, early effects with small paybacks;
  • brand building produces broad, slower effects with large paybacks.

You need both, because there are no long-term effects without short-term ones, but they behave differently over time.

The job, not the channel

The useful distinction is not channel. A YouTube ad can be either. It is the job: is this piece trying to make someone buy this week, or trying to make sure they think of you first in eight months?

In their IPA deck, Binet and Field show that rational messages give a big direct effect that decays quickly, while emotional priming gives a smaller immediate effect that builds over repeated exposure and lasts.

Two shapes of effect (illustrative)time: weeks to yearssales effectactivation: big, shortbrand: small, then buildsquarterly dashboard sees this far
The shapes Binet and Field describe, drawn as concepts rather than data. A dashboard that stops at the dotted line will always prefer the grey curve.
The story

In October 2019, Adidas's global media director Simon Peel stood up at EffWeek, a marketing-effectiveness conference in London, and admitted the company had become overly focused on digital attribution. Real-time dashboards had pushed money toward the channels that reported sales fastest.

The evidence arrived by accident. A Google AdWords error stopped Adidas buying search keywords for two days, and sales did not drop. About six months later a week-long outage told the same story. Of the search spend, Peel said: "it was sales we were going to get anyway." When Adidas built better models, they pointed the other way: toward video, and toward out-of-home and cinema, which were driving e-commerce sales.

Footwear News via Yahoo: Adidas reveals surprising finding (October 2019)
Share of campaigns reporting very large profit effects, by campaign length
See the data as a table
Emotional campaigns (%)Rational campaigns (%)
1 year1310
2 years3020
3+ years4323

Source: Binet and Field, The Long and the Short of It, IPA presentation (996 IPA Databank campaigns)

In year one the two styles look almost identical: 13% against 10% (Binet and Field, IPA). If you judge on a quarterly dashboard you will conclude they are equal and pick the cheaper one.

By year three, emotional brand campaigns are almost twice as likely to report very large profit effects. That is the core of the argument, and it is why short-term metrics alone mislead.

Where does the 60/40 rule come from?

The 60/40 rule comes from Binet and Field's meta-analysis of the IPA Effectiveness Databank, covering 996 campaigns, 700 brands and 83 categories. When they plotted the number of very large business effects against the share of budget going to activation, the curve peaked at about 40% activation. Hence 60:40.

The Long and the Short of It: Balancing Short and Long-Term Marketing StrategiesLes Binet and Peter Field · IPA (Institute of Practitioners in Advertising) · 2013 study, IPA presentation

A meta-analysis of IPA Effectiveness Awards entries: 996 campaigns, 700 brands, 83 categories. The authors compared what drove short-term and long-term effects. Findings include the 60:40 optimum, that broad targeting of the whole market produced more very large effects than targeting existing customers (6.7 against 2.2 in their count), that fame campaigns were about four times as efficient in share-of-voice terms, and that integrated brand plus activation campaigns beat either alone. The limit: award entries are not a random sample, and the optimum is an average across categories, not a law for any single brand.

Read the presentation (free PDF)

The split is not universal, and its authors say so. In a 2019 cut of the same data for LinkedIn's B2B Institute, Binet and Field found B2B brands grew best at about 46% brand and 54% activation, because B2B buying is more rational and more activation-heavy.

Newer brands with little awareness tend to need more brand; category leaders with high awareness can run lighter.

A 1924 Coca-Cola magazine advertisement
Coca-Cola in 1924. A century of ads that rarely asked anyone to buy this week, and a brand most people can picture without being shown it.Photo: Various, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Why are 95% of your buyers not in the market?

Most of your future customers are not buying right now, so ads aimed only at people ready to buy miss nearly all of them. The 95-5 rule, from LinkedIn's B2B Institute and its research with the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute, estimates that in a typical B2B category only about 5% of buyers are in the market in a given quarter.

The logic is arithmetic: if companies replace a service every five years, roughly one in twenty is shopping in any three-month window.

100 buyers in your category this quarter5 in market: performance ads compete for these. 95 others: brand reaches them.
The 95-5 rule as a grid: with a five-year purchase cycle and a three-month window, five buyers in a hundred are shopping now.

The same logic applies to consumer categories with long purchase cycles: mattresses, two-wheelers, insurance, online degrees, laptops. Use the calculator to see how small the in-market pool is for your category.

How many of your buyers are in the market right now?

With a five-year cycle and a three-month window, 5% are in market and 95% are not. Performance marketing competes, at auction prices, for the 5%. Brand marketing works on the 95%, at much lower cost per person reached, so that when they enter the market your name is already on their short list.

LinkedIn's page on the rule adds a striking survey point: 96% of B2B marketers expected their ads' main effect within two weeks. If that is what you expect, you will always underfund the work that pays later. I go deeper on this in why B2B buyers decide before the sales call.

Why does performance marketing look better than it is?

Performance marketing looks better than it is because platform reports credit ads for sales that would have happened anyway. People who were already going to buy are the most likely to see and click your ads, so attribution counts their purchases as ad-driven. The best evidence on this comes from experiments that switched ads off.

Consumer Heterogeneity and Paid Search Effectiveness: A Large Scale Field ExperimentTom Blake, Chris Nosko and Steven Tadelis · NBER Working Paper 20171, published in Econometrica · 2014–2015

eBay ran controlled experiments, switching paid search on and off across US regions and halting brand-keyword ads on Yahoo! and MSN. When brand ads stopped, 99.5% of the lost clicks came back through free organic links. For non-brand keywords, a naive regression put the return on investment at 4,173%; with time and region controls it was still 1,632%; the experimental estimate was minus 63%. Ads did help new and infrequent users, but most spend went to frequent buyers who would have bought anyway. The limit: eBay is a hugely familiar brand, so a small unknown brand gains more from search ads than eBay did.

Read the paper (free)
How eBay measured non-brand searchEstimated ROI
Naive regression, no controls4,173%
Regression with time and region controls1,632%
Instrumental variables−22%
Controlled experiment−63%

Notice the last line of the summary. The ads worked on people who did not already know eBay well. That is the hidden link between the two budgets: performance ads convert well among people who already know and like you, and convert expensively among people who do not.

Brand building is what moves people from the second group to the first.

Traditional brand advertising is not exempt from scrutiny either. A large 2021 study of TV advertising for 288 consumer brands in the US found that most brands over-spend at the margin.

TV Advertising Effectiveness and Profitability: Generalizable Results from 288 BrandsBradley Shapiro, Günter Hitsch and Anna Tuchman · Econometrica · 2021

Using Nielsen data for 288 established packaged-goods brands, the authors estimated long-run TV advertising elasticities: a mean of 0.023 and a median of 0.014, meaning a 1% increase in advertising lifts sales by about 0.014% for the typical brand. Two-thirds of the estimates were not statistically different from zero, and more than 80% of brands had a negative return at the margin. The limit: these are mature, well-known brands, where extra advertising has the least left to do. The finding argues for spending brand money well, not for skipping it.

Read the paper (free)

Put the two studies together and a sensible position emerges. Both kinds of spend are routinely over-credited by the people who buy them. The answer is not to pick a side; it is to measure each with methods that can catch over-crediting, such as geo holdouts and marketing mix models like Meridian and Robyn, and to hold brand work to the standard of distinctiveness and reach rather than clicks.

A Thums Up cola advertisement or signage in India
Thums Up has kept one personality for decades. That consistency is what brand budgets actually buy.Photo: Andy Li, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons

How should an Indian D2C founder split the budget?

An Indian D2C founder should start activation-heavy while finding product-market fit, then move steadily toward brand as growth from paid social slows. A pre-revenue brand cannot spend 60% on fame.

But take an illustrative brand doing ₹30 crore a year that still spends 90% on Meta conversion campaigns (a made-up case, not data): it is likely paying more each quarter for the same customer.

What Indian founders and investors report

The Indian evidence is anecdotal but consistent. Inc42 reported in July 2026 that many D2C brands now set aside 20% to 30% of budgets for retention and brand. Founders and investors it spoke to described the same squeeze:

  • Renée Cosmetics: co-founder Ashutosh Valani said the ad-spend-to-revenue ratio fell from about 1:1 at launch to about 0.45:1, yet marketing still eats about 45% of revenue because paid channels keep getting costlier.
  • Kae Capital: Sunitha Viswanathan described cheap Meta and Google growth as gone for good.
  • Traya: Saloni Anand described a logo test: an ad should be recognisably Traya even with the logo covered.
StageBrand share (starting point)What brand money buysWhat to measure
Finding fit, under ₹10 crore revenue10–20%Distinctive assets, founder content, reviews, packagingRepeat rate, organic search for brand name
Scaling, ₹10–100 crore30–50%Video reach, creators, regional languages, PRBranded search, blended CAC, new-customer share
Leading the category50–60%Mass reach, sponsorships, TV or CTVShare of voice vs share of market, price elasticity

These bands are my working ranges built from the Binet and Field logic, not published benchmarks; adjust them with your own holdout tests. Why so many brands hit a ceiling in the second stage is the subject of why Indian D2C brands stall before ₹100 crore.

Indian marketing history is full of the long game working. The Amul girl has run topical ads for decades with almost no direct-response element, and the brands at the top of the BrandZ ranking of Indian brands all built memory long before they built funnels.

How do you know if your brand spend is working?

Brand spend is working when performance gets cheaper without you changing the performance campaigns. Watch for:

  • falling blended customer acquisition cost;
  • rising branded search volume;
  • a higher share of sales from direct and organic traffic;
  • better conversion rates on the same ads;
  • the ability to hold price with fewer discounts.

In Binet and Field's data, brands whose share of voice exceeded their share of market tended to grow, and the clearest long-term marker of a strong brand was lower price sensitivity.

  1. Track blended CAC, not platform CAC. Total marketing spend divided by new customers, from your own books.
  2. Watch branded search. Google Trends and Search Console show whether more people look for you by name.
  3. Run a geo holdout. Turn brand activity off in a few comparable cities for eight to twelve weeks and compare sales.
  4. Test distinctiveness. Show your ads with the logo hidden; if people cannot name the brand, the spend is building the category, not you.
  5. Give it four quarters. The IPA data shows year-one effects that look like noise. Decide the review date before you start.

My own view, from 10+ years of working on both kinds of budget, is simple: brand and reputation compound, and buyer psychology has to come before the campaign. If you want help setting this up for your company, my hire page explains how I work.

Questions people ask

Is the 60/40 rule still valid in a digital-first world?

Binet and Field have re-run the analysis as digital grew and still find an optimum near 60:40 for consumer brands, with about 46:54 for B2B. What changed is that digital made activation easier to measure, which tempted teams to over-invest in it. The rule is an average, so test your own split.

How do I grow online sales for a D2C food brand?

For an unknown food brand, trust comes first: reviews, founder-led content, clear sourcing and packaging that looks like a real brand. Retargeting converts people who already know you; cold conversion ads on strangers are expensive. Build recognition in a few cities or communities before scaling paid acquisition.

Is performance marketing the same as digital marketing?

No. Performance marketing is any activity judged on immediate response, and it can run on TV with a phone number. Digital channels such as YouTube, Instagram and CTV can carry brand building just as well as conversion ads. The split is about the job, not the medium.

When should a startup start brand marketing?

From day one in small ways: a name, colours, a voice and assets that stay consistent. Larger brand budgets make sense once paid acquisition costs start rising faster than order values, usually after product-market fit.

Sources

  1. Binet and Field: The Long and the Short of It, 10 key principles (IPA presentation)
  2. IPA: The Long and the Short of It, publication page
  3. LinkedIn B2B Institute: The 95-5 rule
  4. LinkedIn: How B2B marketing really drives growth (Binet and Field, B2B Institute) (2019)
  5. Blake, Nosko and Tadelis: Consumer Heterogeneity and Paid Search Effectiveness, NBER (2014)
  6. Shapiro, Hitsch and Tuchman: TV Advertising Effectiveness and Profitability (2021)
  7. Inc42: The end of the ROAS era in D2C? (2026)
  8. Footwear News via Yahoo: Adidas reveals surprising finding, traditional not digital ads driving e-commerce sales (2019)
  9. Entrepreneur India: Why most Indian D2C brands fail to cross ₹100 crore (2025)
  10. Social Samosa: Pitch Madison Advertising Report 2026 (2026)
  11. Reddit r/digital_marketing: How to grow online sales for a D2C food brand now? (2026)
brand vs performance marketing60/40 ruleBinet and Field95-5 rulebrand buildingROASIndian D2C
Sapta

Sapta (Saptarshi Sarkar) is a mechanical engineer turned marketer in Bengaluru and a solo touring rider. He writes the seven Saptaverse blogs. Work with him or read more of Marketblog.

Keep reading in Marketblog

From the other blogs