If you lost your sense of smell tomorrow, food would shrink to what the tongue and mouth can feel: salt, sweet, sour, bitter, umami, chilli heat, temperature and texture. Cumin, cardamom, ghee and coffee would all taste like their basic outline, because their character is aroma. The bigger danger is not dull food but missed warnings: smoke, spoiled food and a leaking LPG cylinder. Most people who lose smell to a virus recover within months, and the rest can adapt.
- 75 to 95%: the much-quoted share of "taste" that is really smell. The exact number has no clean source, but the dominance is accepted.
- 37% vs 19%: people with impaired smell versus normal smell who reported at least one smell-related accident in a 445-patient clinic study.
- 95.7% of COVID-19 patients with smell loss had recovered by 180 days in a pooled analysis of 3,699 patients; about 5.6% may keep a lasting loss.
- About 26 g of LPG pooled on a small kitchen floor is enough for a normal nose to notice, by my estimate. An anosmic cook gets no warning at all.
- 12 weeks of twice-daily sniffing of four odours improved smell scores in a controlled trial, and it is the standard first treatment.
This what-if is not far-fetched. A 2021 meta-analysis of 175,073 people put the prevalence of smell dysfunction at 22.2% overall, rising to about a third in people over 55 when tested objectively. COVID-19 made millions more aware of it overnight.
What would food taste like without smell?
Without smell, food tastes like a sketch of itself: the tongue still reports the five basic tastes, the trigeminal nerve still reports chilli, mustard and mint, and the mouth still feels crunch and temperature, but the identity of each ingredient disappears.
That identity lives in volatile molecules. When you chew, they travel from the back of your mouth up into the nose, the retronasal route. The tongue has five kinds of taste receptor; the nose has hundreds of kinds of odorant receptor. Lose the nose and you lose the high-resolution channel.
At 22, Molly Birnbaum had just graduated, had been cooking in a restaurant kitchen, and was weeks away from starting at the Culinary Institute of America. Then, in 2005, a car hit her while she was out jogging. It broke her pelvis in two places, tore the tendons in her knee and fractured her skull. About a month later her stepmother baked an apple crisp, and everyone in the room praised the smell. Birnbaum smelled nothing. The skull fracture had cost her the sense she had planned a career on. She went on to interview scientists, chefs and perfumers about smell and wrote the memoir Season to Taste (2011).
Kirkus Reviews: Season to Taste by Molly BirnbaumHow much of flavour is smell? You will often read "80%". Oxford's Charles Spence traced that figure and found it is a popular claim, quoted between 75 and 95%, with no clean experiment behind it, and argued that a precise number may be impossible because "flavour" is hard to define. What researchers do agree on is the direction: most of what we call taste comes in through the nose.
Here is what survives and what goes, dish by dish, for an Indian kitchen:
| Element | Channel | After anosmia |
|---|---|---|
| Salt in dal | Taste | Intact |
| Tamarind, lime, curd sourness | Taste | Intact |
| Sugar in kheer | Taste | Intact; vanilla-like cardamom notes gone |
| Bitterness of karela, coffee | Taste | Intact; the roast aroma of coffee gone |
| Chilli heat, mustard oil sting, mint cool | Trigeminal | Intact |
| Cumin, hing, curry leaf, ghee, garam masala | Smell | Largely lost |
| Crunch of papad, softness of idli | Touch | Intact |
So a well-made tadka, which is mostly an aroma extraction (see the chemistry of tadka), would lose most of its point. A spicy, sour rasam would keep a surprising amount.

Why is losing smell dangerous?
Losing smell is dangerous because the nose is a chemical alarm system: it detects smoke, gas leaks and spoiled food before you see them. Without it, the warnings arrive late or never.
A retrospective cohort of 445 patients tested at a university smell and taste clinic in Virginia between 1983 and 2001. Testing found 76% had some impairment and 30% complete anosmia. At least one smell-related hazardous event was reported by 45.2% of anosmic patients against 19.0% of those with normal smell, with a clear dose-response across severity. Of the events among impaired patients, 45% were cooking accidents, 25% eating spoiled food, 23% missed gas leaks and 7% missed fires. The limit: self-reported events in a clinic population, which may overstate risk compared with the general public.
Read the abstract| Smell function (tested) | Reported at least one hazardous event |
|---|---|
| Anosmia | 45.2% |
| Severe hyposmia | 34.1% |
| Moderate hyposmia | 32.8% |
| Mild hyposmia | 24.2% |
| Normal | 19.0% |
A second study went further. In 2014, Jayant Pinto's team published a study that tested 3,005 older Americans with a five-pen smell test. Five years later, 39% of those who failed it had died, against 10% of those with normal smell.
The National Social Life, Health and Aging Project tested a nationally representative sample of 3,005 US adults aged 57 to 85 in 2005–06, using five scent pens (rose, leather, orange, fish, peppermint). Five-year mortality was 39% for anosmic people, 19% for hyposmic and 10% for normal. After adjusting for age, sex, health conditions and more, anosmia still carried 3.37 times the odds of death. The limit, which the authors stress: smell loss is a marker of declining health, not shown to be a cause, and the five-item test is crude.
Read the paper (free)The nose is the only smoke alarm most kitchens have. Anosmia switches it off without telling you.
How long before an anosmic cook would notice a gas leak?
An anosmic cook would not notice a slow LPG leak at all until something else warned them. A cook with normal smell would, by my estimate, notice a leak of 100 g per hour within about a quarter of an hour, roughly an hour before the gas near the floor could ignite.
LPG has no smell of its own. Indian refiners add a mercaptan stench for exactly this reason; BPCL's safety data sheet says so in as many words. Here is the worked case.
Worked solution: LPG pooling on a kitchen floor
Assumptions. Gas composition from BPCL's Kochi refinery data sheet: 65% butane, 24% propane, 11% propylene by volume, lower explosive limit (LEL) 2.2%. Kitchen floor 3 m × 3 m. Because LPG is heavier than air, it pools in a low layer, which I take as 0.3 m deep and well mixed (my assumption). Gas is odorised so that a normal nose detects it at one-fifth of the LEL, the rule written into US federal pipeline regulations. Leak rate 100 g/h, a slow leak at a loose fitting (illustrative).
- Molar mass of the mix.
\[ M = 0.65(58.1) + 0.24(44.1) + 0.11(42.1) \approx 53.0\ \text{g/mol} \]
- Vapour density from the ideal gas law at 25°C:
\[ \rho = \frac{PM}{RT} = \frac{101{,}325 \times 0.0530}{8.314 \times 298} \approx 2.17\ \text{kg/m}^3 \]That is about 1.8 times denser than air, which is why it hugs the floor.
- Gas needed to reach the LEL in the floor layer, \(V = 3 \times 3 \times 0.3 = 2.7\ \text{m}^3\):
\[ m_{LEL} = 0.022 \times 2.7\ \text{m}^3 \times 2.17\ \text{kg/m}^3 \approx 0.129\ \text{kg} \]
- Gas needed for a normal nose to notice (one-fifth of the LEL):
\[ m_{smell} = \tfrac{1}{5} m_{LEL} \approx 26\ \text{g} \]
- Time at 100 g/h.
\[ t_{smell} = \frac{26}{100} \times 60 \approx 15\ \text{min}, \qquad t_{LEL} = \frac{129}{100} \times 60 \approx 77\ \text{min} \]
Sensitivity check. If the gas spreads through the whole 24 m³ kitchen instead of pooling, the LEL needs about 1.2 kg and takes about 12 hours at the same rate, and ventilation stretches it further. If it pools in a thinner 0.1 m layer, the danger point falls to about 43 g and 26 minutes. Pooling is the dangerous case, and it is the one a nose catches first.
Use this to check your own kitchen. Change the leak rate, the floor area and how deep the gas pools.
LPG leak: when would you smell it, and when is it dangerous?
Does lost smell come back?
Usually, if the cause is a virus. In the largest pooled analysis of COVID-19 smell loss, 74% of patients had recovered at 30 days and 95.7% at 180 days, but about 1 in 18 may keep a lasting deficit.
The team pooled 18 studies covering 3,699 patients and reconstructed individual recovery curves. Smell recovered in 74.1% by 30 days, 85.8% by 60, 90.0% by 90 and 95.7% by 180 days. Cure modelling estimated that 5.6% (95% CI 2.7 to 11.0%) could develop persistent smell loss. Women, people with a more severe initial loss and those with nasal congestion were less likely to recover. The limit: most data were self-reported, which the authors say may underestimate lasting loss.
Read the paper (free)See the data as a table
| Patients who recovered smell (%) | Patients who recovered taste (%) | |
|---|---|---|
| 30 days | 74.1 | 78.8 |
| 60 days | 85.8 | 87.7 |
| 90 days | 90.0 | 90.3 |
| 180 days | 95.7 | 98.0 |
Source: Tan et al., BMJ 2022 (18 studies, 3,699 patients) · Pooled, reconstructed individual patient data; mostly self-reported recovery.
Other causes behave differently. A head injury that shears the olfactory nerve fibres where they pass through the skull, as in Birnbaum's case, recovers less often and more slowly. Age-related loss usually does not reverse.
Does smell training work?
Smell training is the standard first treatment and costs almost nothing. In the original trial at Dresden, 40 patients sniffed four strong odours (rose, eucalyptus, lemon and clove) twice a day for 12 weeks. Their test scores improved; 16 untrained patients did not change. It is not a cure for everyone, but the trade-off is easy:
- Pick four distinct smells. The trial used rose, eucalyptus, lemon and clove; an Indian kitchen has clove, lemon peel, and eucalyptus oil at most chemists.
- Sniff each one twice a day, morning and evening, concentrating on what it should smell like.
- Keep going for at least 12 weeks, and get your smell tested before and after by an ENT doctor if you can.
How do people with anosmia actually eat?
People with anosmia cook for the channels that still work: salt, acid, heat, bitterness and texture. The UEA review published in June 2026 found eating often becomes functional; some people lose weight from low appetite while others gain it chasing stronger flavours.
The practical playbook, built from the four surviving channels:
- Acid and salt do the work aroma used to do: lime, tamarind, amchur, kokum and a pinch of black salt.
- Trigeminal hits add excitement: green chilli, mustard oil, raw onion, ginger, pepper. (See how chilli heat works.)
- Umami adds depth: tomatoes, curd, fermented batter and aged cheese. (See umami in Indian food.)
- Texture contrast: papad with dal, crisp dosa with soft chutney, sev on chaat.
- Temperature: very cold and very hot both read as sensations, not flavours.
Indian food is, by accident, well suited to this. It already layers sour, hot and salty on top of aroma, which is part of why it uses so many spices (see why Indian food uses so many spices).
You can live and eat well without smell, but not safely by default. Flavour shrinks to five tastes plus heat and texture; the deciding risk is the missing alarm. By my estimate a normal nose would flag a slow 100 g/h LPG leak about an hour before the floor layer could ignite, and an anosmic cook would get no warning. Fix that with a floor-level gas detector, a smoke alarm and dated leftovers, cook for acid, salt, chilli and crunch, start smell training, and see an ENT doctor. If the cause was a virus, the odds of recovery within six months are better than nine in ten.
Where my model breaks down: the one-fifth-LEL odorisation rule is a US pipeline standard I used as a benchmark, and real leaks are rarely steady or well mixed. Treat the minutes as an order of magnitude, not a promise.
What's new
- Review finds smell and taste loss can hit quality of life as hard as diabetes or stroke News-Medical (University of East Anglia), Jun 2026
- US RECOVER cohort finds post-COVID smell loss often persists unnoticed JAMA Network Open, Sep 2025
- Randomised trial finds stellate ganglion block no better than placebo for COVID parosmia Washington University, 2025
What if next?
- How would you cook dinner on Mars? A sealed habitat makes every smell matter, and every fire deadly.
- What if chillies had never left the Americas? The anosmic cook's best friend would vanish from Indian food.
- What if you had to grow food on Mars? Fresh herbs might be the most valuable crop a crew could grow.
Questions people ask
Can you taste food without a sense of smell?
Yes, but only the basics: sweet, sour, salty, bitter and umami, plus chilli heat, cooling and texture through other nerves. The flavours that tell cumin from coriander or coffee from chicory are aromas, and those are lost.
How long does it take for smell to come back after COVID?
In a 2022 BMJ meta-analysis of 3,699 patients, 74% recovered by one month, 90% by three months and 95.7% by six months. About 5.6% may have a lasting loss, and women and people with severe initial loss recovered less often.
Is smell training worth doing?
Yes; it is cheap, safe and the standard first-line treatment. The original 2009 trial used rose, eucalyptus, lemon and clove twice daily for 12 weeks and found improved scores, while untrained patients stayed the same.
What should I do if I suddenly lose my sense of smell?
See a doctor, ideally an ENT specialist, especially if the loss is one-sided or comes with blockage, bleeding or headache. Meanwhile, fit a gas detector and smoke alarm and be careful with stored food.
Sources
- Santos DV et al.: Hazardous events associated with impaired olfactory function, Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 130(3):317–319 (2004) (445 patients; 45.2% vs 19.0%; event breakdown)
- Pinto JM et al.: Olfactory Dysfunction Predicts 5-Year Mortality in Older Adults, PLOS ONE (2014) (3,005 adults; 39% vs 10%; OR 3.37)
- Tan BKJ et al.: Prognosis and persistence of smell and taste dysfunction in covid-19, BMJ 378:e069503 (2022) (recovery curve; 5.6% persistent)
- Hummel T et al.: Effects of olfactory training in patients with olfactory loss, Laryngoscope 119(3):496–499 (2009) (40 trained vs 16 untrained, 12 weeks, four odours)
- Desiato VM et al.: The prevalence of olfactory dysfunction in the general population, Am J Rhinol Allergy (2021) (175,073 subjects; 22.2%)
- Spence C, Youssef J: Olfactory dining, designing for the dominant sense, Flavour 4:32 (2015) (the 75–95% claim and why it can't be pinned down)
- Bharat Petroleum: LPG material safety data sheet, Kochi Refinery (composition, LEL 2.2%, heavier than air, mercaptan stench)
- 49 CFR 192.625: Odorization of gas (Cornell LII) (detectable at one-fifth of the LEL)
- Kirkus Reviews: Season to Taste by Molly Birnbaum (2011) (the accident and the apple crisp)
- America's Test Kitchen: Molly Birnbaum on anosmia (2005 accident)
- News-Medical: Losing smell and taste may profoundly affect wellbeing (2026) (UEA review, Clinical Otolaryngology)
- Horwitz LI et al.: Olfactory dysfunction after SARS-CoV-2 infection in the RECOVER adult cohort, JAMA Network Open (2025)
