What if chillies had never left the Americas? Indian food without chilli

India grows 27 lakh tonnes of chilli a year and eats most of it. Take the plant away and pepper, ginger and mustard would have to do the work. The arithmetic says they can't, not at today's heat.

Red chillies spread out to dry in the sun in India
Photo: Dr. Chinchu C., CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

If chillies had never left the Americas, Indian food would still be spiced, but its heat would come from black pepper, long pepper, ginger and mustard, as it did before the sixteenth century. It would be milder, more aromatic and far more expensive to make hot. By my estimate, matching the chilli heat India eats in a year with black pepper would need about 8 million tonnes of pepper, roughly nine times the entire world's harvest.

Key takeaways
  • 26.9 lakh tonnes: India's chilli production in 2024-25, against 1.05 lakh tonnes of black pepper (Spices Board).
  • 16,000,000 vs about 150,000: Scoville rating of pure capsaicin against a comparative estimate for pure piperine, pepper's pungent compound.
  • About 10 g of pepper to match the heat of one teaspoon of Guntur chilli powder, and about 14 times the cost, by my estimate.
  • Not before the 1600s: when India's chilli cultivation is first firmly documented, according to a careful 2020 review of the botanical record.
  • 1129 CE: the Manasollasa already describes dosa, idli and vada, seasoned with pepper, not chilli.

This what-if rewinds one plant. Capsicum annuum was domesticated in Mexico, reached Spain in the 1490s, and spread around the world on Portuguese and Spanish ships. India adopted it so completely that it now grows 26.9 lakh tonnes a year and exported 7.2 lakh tonnes in 2024-25. Remove that journey and the question becomes engineering: what else can deliver heat, and at what cost?

Where did chillies come from, and when did they reach India?

Chillies were domesticated in Mexico, most likely in the central-east of the country, and reached India only in the sixteenth or early seventeenth century. A 2014 study combined four kinds of evidence to locate the origin.

Multiple lines of evidence for the origin of domesticated chili pepper, Capsicum annuum, in MexicoKraft KH, Brown CH, Nabhan GP, Luedeling E, Luna Ruiz JJ, Coppens d'Eeckenbrugge G, Hijmans RJ, Gepts P · PNAS 111(17): 6165–6170 · 2014

The team combined species-distribution modelling, microsatellite genetics of wild and cultivated chillies, archaeobotanical finds and "paleobiolinguistics", the reconstruction of ancient words for chilli. All four lines together pointed to central-east Mexico, where preceramic chilli remains were found in the Tehuacán Valley and where Proto-Otomanguean, the oldest language with a reconstructable word for chilli, was spoken in the mid-Holocene. Genetics alone favoured north-eastern Mexico. The limit: each line of evidence is fuzzy, and the method finds the most likely region, not a single spot.

Read the paper (free)
The story

In 1493 the physician Diego Álvarez Chanca sailed with Christopher Columbus on his second voyage to the Caribbean. The Spaniards met a fruit the islanders called axi, and because it burned the tongue like the black pepper Columbus had been sent to find, they called it pimiento, pepper. Chanca returned and in 1494 became the first European to describe its medicinal use. That naming mistake still travels with the plant. In 1542 the German botanist Leonhart Fuchs listed it as "Calicut pepper" and "Indian pepper", names that later misled writers into thinking chilli came from India.

Wikipedia: Chili pepper (history: Columbus, Chanca 1494)

When did it actually reach India? Less certainly than most books say. Food historian Michael Krondl went back to the sixteenth-century botanical record and found a striking silence.

The Chile Diaspora: Unravelling Evidence from Sixteenth Century BotanicalsKrondl M · Proceedings of the Oxford Symposium on Food and Cookery · 2020

Krondl compared editions and translations of about a dozen sixteenth-century herbals. Chillies were common in Spain and Moravia by the 1580s, but in India he found no firm proof of cultivation until the seventeenth century: Garcia da Orta in Goa (1560s), Cristóbal Acosta (1570s) and Linschoten all describe Malabar's peppers without mentioning capsicum, and the first clear Indian description is van Rheede's Hortus Malabaricus in the 1670s. He also notes that Purandara Dasa's often-quoted sixteenth-century verse could describe green peppercorns, and was written down only in the nineteenth century. The limit: absence of mention is not proof of absence.

Read the paper (free)
Heat in the Indian kitchen: a timelineAncient1129149415421560s1670s2024-25Pepper, long pepper, ginger, mustard:India's native heatManasollasa: fish seasoned withpepper and cardamomChanca describes the American "pepper"after Columbus's second voyageFuchs, Germany: "Calicut pepper",a misleading nameGarcia da Orta in Goa lists Malabar'speppers: no chilli mentionedvan Rheede's Hortus Malabaricusdescribes chilli in KeralaIndia grows 26.9 lakh tonnes of chilli,26 times its pepper crop
Chilli is a late arrival. India's documented history of heat is mostly pepper; the chilli era is about 350 to 450 years long.

What did Indian food taste like before chillies?

Before chillies, Indian heat came from black pepper, long pepper (pippali), ginger and mustard, and the cuisine already had most of its modern structure. The clearest window is the Manasollasa, an encyclopaedia completed in 1129 CE by the Chalukya king Someshvara III in present-day Karnataka.

Its food chapters describe dosaka, iddarika and vataka, recognisable as dosa, idli and vada, along with pakoras and dahi vada. A fish recipe cooks the fish in Malabar tamarind, fries it and seasons it with rock salt, cardamom and pepper. So the sour, salty and fried backbone was there. Only the burn was different.

Green unripe pepper berries hanging on a black pepper vine in Thiruvananthapuram, Kerala
Unripe pepper berries on a vine in Thiruvananthapuram. For two thousand years before chilli, this was India's heat and its most valuable export.Photo: K Hari Krishnan, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Each native heat source has its own character, which matters because the counterfactual cuisine would lean on all four:

Heat sourceMain pungent compoundScoville (pure compound)Character
Chilli (for comparison)Capsaicin16,000,000Slow build, long burn
Black pepperPiperine (4.6–9.7% of the berry)About 150,000 (comparative estimate)Sharp, quick, aromatic
Long pepperPiperineNot ratedStronger than black pepper
Ginger, driedShogaolAbout 160,000Warm, lingering
Ginger, freshGingerolAbout 60,000 (comparative estimate)Bright, citrusy
MustardAllyl isothiocyanateNot on the scaleNasal, volatile, fades fast
Leaves and catkin-like fruits of long pepper, Piper longum
Long pepper (pippali). Pliny recorded it at 15 denarii a pound against 4 for black pepper. It faded from Europe's kitchens once chillies arrived.Photo: Myrmux, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Could black pepper replace chilli heat?

Not at today's level. Pure capsaicin is roughly 100 times more pungent than pure piperine, and pepper berries carry only 5–10% piperine, so pepper delivers far less burn per gram, at several times the price.

Worked solution: one teaspoon of chilli powder

Assumptions. A curry for four uses one teaspoon, about 2.5 g, of Guntur Sannam chilli powder, which the Spices Board lists at 0.226% capsaicin. Black pepper is taken at 6% piperine (the middle of the 4.6–9.7% range). I treat Scoville units as additive and comparable, which is a simplification.

  1. Capsaicin in the spoon (the 2.5 g is the example spoon above; 0.226% is the Spices Board's figure for Guntur Sannam):
    \[ m_{cap} = 2.5\ \text{g} \times 0.00226 = 5.65\ \text{mg} \]
  2. Piperine with the same Scoville heat.
    \[ m_{pip} = 5.65\ \text{mg} \times \frac{16{,}000{,}000}{150{,}000} \approx 603\ \text{mg} \]
  3. Black pepper needed.
    \[ m_{pepper} = \frac{603\ \text{mg}}{0.06} \approx 10\ \text{g} \]
    That is four times the mass of the chilli powder it replaces.
  4. Cost. At Guntur's January 2026 price for Teja chilli (₹20,500 a quintal, ₹205/kg) and Kochi's February 2026 pepper price (about ₹700/kg):
    \[ \frac{10\ \text{g} \times ₹0.70/\text{g}}{2.5\ \text{g} \times ₹0.205/\text{g}} = \frac{₹7.0}{₹0.51} \approx 14 \]

And 10 g of ground pepper in a curry for four would not taste like a chilli curry. It would be dominated by pepper's resinous aroma, and piperine's sting fades much faster than capsaicin's. Chilli gives heat without changing the dish's aroma; pepper cannot.

Same heat, two spices (estimate)Guntur chilli powderBlack pepper2.5 g10 g5.65 mg capsaicin603 mg piperineabout ₹0.51about ₹7.004 times the mass14 times the costScoville-equivalent heat; prices Jan-Feb 2026
Bar heights are to scale by mass. The trade is the heart of this what-if: chilli is the cheapest heat humans have ever grown.

Use this to check your own kitchen's numbers.

How much black pepper would replace your chilli?

Could the world even grow that much pepper?

No. Replacing the chilli heat India eats in a year would take roughly 8 million tonnes of black pepper, about nine times the world's whole 2023 harvest of 855,105 tonnes.

Worked solution: the national heat budget

  1. Chilli eaten in India, as production minus exports in 2024-25 (Spices Board; ignoring stock changes):
    \[ 2{,}694{,}838\ \text{t} - 715{,}506\ \text{t} \approx 1{,}979{,}000\ \text{t} \]
  2. Capsaicin in it, at the Guntur Sannam value of 0.226%:
    \[ 1{,}979{,}000 \times 0.00226 \approx 4{,}470\ \text{t} \]
  3. Pepper with equal heat, at 6% piperine (inside the 4.6 to 9.7% range; Scoville values from Wikipedia):
    \[ 4{,}470 \times \frac{16{,}000{,}000}{150{,}000} \div 0.06 \approx 7.9 \times 10^{6}\ \text{t} \]
  4. Against world supply:
    \[ \frac{7.9 \times 10^{6}}{855{,}105} \approx 9.3 \]

Sensitivity check. With the richest pepper (9.7% piperine) the need drops to about 4.9 million tonnes, still 5.8 times world output. With the leanest (4.6%) it rises to about 10 million tonnes, 12 times. If India's average chilli were milder, say 0.15% capsaicin, every figure falls by a third. No assumption gets anywhere near world supply. At ₹700/kg, 7.9 million tonnes of pepper would cost about ₹5.5 lakh crore a year.

Calculated in this post from the same inputs as above, with the piperine range and the 2023 world harvest of 855,105 tonnes from Wikipedia: Black pepper (FAOSTAT), and Kochi's pepper price from Onmanorama.

India: chilli vs black pepper production, 2021-22 to 2025-26
See the data as a table
Chilli (tonnes)Black pepper (tonnes)
2021-22183622295000
2022-232782009117067
2023-242909844126038
2024-252694838104751
2025-26 (est.)246418093716

Source: Spices Board of India: Spice-wise area and production in India · 2024-25 is a final estimate and 2025-26 an advance estimate. Pepper figures from DASD Kozhikode.

Chilli did not just add heat to Indian food. It made heat cheap enough for everyone.

So what would Indian food taste like today?

It would taste closer to the food of the Malabar coast, Bengal and the old courts: aromatic, peppery, ginger-warm and mustard-sharp, with heat used as a seasoning rather than a main event. Here is my reconstruction, region by region, marked as informed speculation:

  • South India would keep its sour and fermented base: tamarind, curd, idli and dosa batter. Pepper rasam, already a classic, would be the default rasam. Sambar would lean on pepper and ginger.
  • Bengal and the east would lose little of its character: mustard paste and mustard oil already carry the sharpness in many fish dishes (see Bengali food history).
  • North India would cook more like the Mughal court's richer dishes, with ginger, black cardamom and pepper. Street food such as chaat would depend on black salt, tamarind, ginger and pepper.
  • Pickles would be mustard-led, and the bright red colour of Indian food would be gone: no Kashmiri chilli, no Byadgi. Colour would come from turmeric and saffron.

Two second-order effects follow. First, pepper prices would carry far more political weight, as they did when pepper drew Roman, Arab and Portuguese traders to Kerala (see the Malabar pepper trade). Second, the 7.9 lakh hectares now under chilli would grow something else, and the farmers of Guntur, Khammam and Byadgi would be growing other crops.

A sixteenth-century woodcut illustration of a black pepper plant from a printed herbal
A sixteenth-century herbal's black pepper. European printers of the same era mislabelled the new American capsicum as "Indian" and "Calicut" pepper.Photo: Unknown, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Verdict: possible with changes

Indian cuisine would exist without chillies, because its structure (sour, salty, fermented, fried, layered with aromatics) is older than chilli, as the Manasollasa shows in 1129. What could not exist is today's level of heat at today's price. Pure capsaicin is about 100 times more pungent than piperine, so one teaspoon of chilli powder needs about 10 g of pepper at about 14 times the cost, and India's annual chilli heat would need about 8 million tonnes of pepper, nine times the world's harvest. The deciding limit is economic and agricultural, not chemical.

Where my model breaks down: the Scoville rating of piperine is a comparative estimate, and perceived heat is not simply additive. Cooks would also never try to match chilli heat with pepper; they would cook a different, milder cuisine. The numbers show why.

What if next?

Questions people ask

When did chillies come to India?

Most accounts say the Portuguese brought them in the sixteenth century, and the Spices Board says the late fifteenth. The firm documentary evidence is later: Krondl's 2020 review finds no clear record of cultivation in India before the seventeenth century, with van Rheede describing chilli in Kerala in the 1670s.

What did Indians use before chillies?

Black pepper, long pepper, ginger and mustard for heat, along with asafoetida, cumin, coriander, cardamom and tamarind. The 1129 CE Manasollasa seasons fish with rock salt, cardamom and pepper.

Is black pepper hotter than chilli?

No. Pure capsaicin rates 16,000,000 Scoville units, and pure piperine only about 150,000 by comparative estimate. Pepper berries also contain just 4.6–9.7% piperine, so gram for gram most chilli powders are much hotter. (For India's hottest varieties, see Indian chillies by Scoville.)

Which country produces the most chillies?

For green chillies and peppers, China, with 17.3 million tonnes in 2024, about 39% of world output; India was second at 5.3 million tonnes. India grew 26.9 lakh tonnes of dried chilli in 2024-25 and exported 7.2 lakh tonnes, by Spices Board figures. More on the arrival story in the history of chilli in India and on the science in how chilli heat works.

Sources

  1. Kraft KH et al.: Multiple lines of evidence for the origin of domesticated chili pepper, Capsicum annuum, in Mexico, PNAS 111(17) (2014) (central-east Mexico, Tehuacán, Proto-Otomanguean)
  2. Krondl M: The Chile Diaspora, Oxford Symposium on Food and Cookery (2020) (no firm Indian record before the 1600s; Fuchs 1542; Garcia da Orta; van Rheede)
  3. Spices Board of India: Spice-wise area and production in India (2026) (chilli 2,694,838 t and pepper 104,751 t in 2024-25)
  4. Spices Board of India: Item-wise export of spices, 2021-22 to 2025-26 (2026) (chilli exports 715,506 t in 2024-25)
  5. Spices Board of India: Chilli varieties (Guntur Sannam 0.226% capsaicin; Portuguese introduction)
  6. Wikipedia: Scoville scale (capsaicin 16,000,000; piperine about 150,000; shogaol 160,000; gingerol 60,000)
  7. Wikipedia: Black pepper (FAOSTAT 2023 world production 855,105 t; piperine 4.6–9.7%; Pliny's prices)
  8. Wikipedia: Chili pepper (Chanca 1494; Portuguese spread to Goa; FAOSTAT 2024 green chilli production)
  9. Wikipedia: Manasollasa (1129 CE; dosaka, iddarika, vataka; fish with pepper and cardamom)
  10. The Hans India: Red chilli prices touch new highs at Guntur Mirchi Yard (Jan 2026) (Teja about ₹20,500 a quintal)
  11. Onmanorama: Falling price, thinning production force pepper farmers to switch crops (Feb 2026) (₹680–728/kg)
chilli historyblack pepperlong pepperpiperinecapsaicinScoville scaleColumbian exchangeManasollasaSpices Board India
Sapta

Sapta (Saptarshi Sarkar) is a mechanical engineer turned marketer in Bengaluru and a solo touring rider. He writes the seven Saptaverse blogs. Work with him or read more of Foodblog.

Keep reading in Foodblog

From the other blogs