The usual order of adding spices to a curry is whole spices into hot fat first, then onions, then ginger and garlic, then ground spices with tomato or a splash of water, then the main ingredient, and garam masala, kasuri methi and fresh herbs at the end. The logic is physical: whole spices need hot fat to release their fat-soluble aroma, ground spices scorch in seconds unless water holds the pan near 100°C, and delicate aromatics lose a large share of their compounds with long cooking.
- Whole spices first: their aroma is fat-soluble and needs a minute in hot fat to come out.
- ~100°C is the ceiling while water is in the pan, which is why ground spices go in with tomato or a splash.
- 30 ml of water buys ground spices about 50 seconds on a 1.5 kW burner.
- 16–53% of curcumin, capsaicin and piperine is lost in 10–20 minutes of wet cooking (CFTRI).
- Garam masala and kasuri methi last, because their value is aroma, and aroma cooks off.
On the DonRockwell food forum, a long thread on tempering explains the habit in one line: many spice flavours don't dissolve in water, so you need fat to get them out. True, but it explains only the first step.
Indian cooks also add ground spices later than whole ones, add them with water, and hold some spices back until the end. This post walks through the sequence step by step and ties each move to a measurable reason: solubility, surface area, the boiling point of water and heat losses measured by CSIR-CFTRI.
Why do whole spices go into the hot fat first?
Whole spices go first because their aroma compounds are mostly fat-soluble oils locked inside seeds, bark and pods, and it takes direct contact with hot fat for a minute to drive them out into the oil that will carry flavour through the whole dish.
These whole spices can take that heat because they are dense, low in surface area for their mass, and protected by a husk or skin:
- seeds: cumin, mustard, fennel;
- bark and pods: cinnamon, cardamom, cloves;
- leaves and pods: bay leaf and dried red chilli.
What the lab shows
A Sri Lankan lab study shows the transfer directly. Perera and colleagues blended spice extracts into coconut oil and found eugenol (from cloves), cinnamaldehyde (from cinnamon) and piperine (from pepper) in the oil afterwards, compounds absent from plain oil.
They also measured a side effect worth knowing: the spiced oil's smoke point fell from about 193°C to 157°C. Spiced fat smokes earlier than plain fat, so the pan should be hot, not smoking, when whole spices go in.
Researchers at the University of Sri Jayewardenepura added an equal mix of ginger, garlic, nutmeg, clove, black pepper and cinnamon oleoresins to commercial coconut oil, then tested it by GC-MS, heated it at 170°C for two hours and stored it at 60°C for 12 weeks. Eugenol, cinnamaldehyde and piperine were present in the spiced oil, and it oxidised more slowly: after two hours at 170°C its free fatty acids were 1.25% against 1.73% for plain oil, and after 12 weeks at 60°C its peroxide value was 6.13 against 7.52. Its smoke point dropped from about 193°C to 157°C. Limits: oleoresins rather than whole spices, one oil, one blend, and an unclear dose.
Read the paper (free)The first known English-language curry recipe appeared in Hannah Glasse's The Art of Cookery Made Plain and Easy in 1747. In the 1755 edition it reads "To make a Currey the Indian Way", and its method is a sequence. Two small chickens are skinned, jointed and stewed for about five minutes in a quart of water, and the liquor is kept.
Three large onions are chopped and fried in about two ounces of butter, then the chicken goes in and fries until brown. Only then are a quarter-ounce of turmeric, a spoonful of ginger and beaten pepper, and salt strewn over the frying meat, and the liquor is poured straight back in to stew for half an hour. Cream and the juice of two lemons go in at the very end.
There is no whole-spice tempering in it, but the rest of the order is the one this post explains: onions browned in fat, ground spices on hot fat only briefly, liquid before they scorch.
Hannah Glasse, The Art of Cookery Made Plain and Easy (1755 edition), Internet Archive (Wellcome Collection copy)Which fat, and how hot should it be?
Use a fat whose smoke point sits comfortably above the temperature you need, and add whole spices when the fat shimmers, well before it smokes. Ghee, mustard oil, refined groundnut and refined sunflower oil all tolerate tempering heat; butter and unrefined oils smoke much earlier.
| Fat | Smoke point | Fit for tempering whole spices? |
|---|---|---|
| Ghee (clarified butter) | 250°C | Yes; the classic choice for North Indian tadka |
| Mustard oil | 250°C | Yes; usually heated until it pales, for Bengali and North Indian dishes |
| Sunflower oil, refined | 252-254°C | Yes; neutral |
| Groundnut oil, refined | 232°C | Yes |
| Coconut oil, refined | 204°C | Yes, with care |
| Coconut oil, virgin | 177°C | Gentle heat only |
| Sesame oil, unrefined | 177°C | Gentle heat only |
| Groundnut oil, unrefined | 160°C | Gentle heat only |
| Butter | 150°C | No; it burns. Use ghee |
Smoke points vary with refining, free fatty acid content and reuse, so treat these as a guide; values are from the cited references in Wikipedia's smoke point table. Reused oil smokes earlier and is the kind Kerala's food safety teams seized in October 2026.
The deeper chemistry of the tempering step, including why mustard seeds pop and how curry leaves behave, is in the chemistry of tadka.

Why do onions, ginger and garlic come before the ground spices?
Because onions need the longest browning, and ginger and garlic need a short cook to lose their raw edge, and both release water that protects the ground spices that follow.
Onions browning in fat develop sweetness and colour through caramelisation and Maillard reactions over several minutes, which is why they come right after the whole spices. The chemistry of that browning is in the Maillard reaction in Indian cooking.
Ginger and garlic: short and late
Ginger-garlic paste goes in once the onions are golden. It burns easily because it is fine and full of sugars, so it gets a minute or two, not ten.
Heat also changes ginger's chemistry: a 2023 review in Molecules collects studies in which heating lowers ginger's gingerols and raises shogaols, the more pungent dehydration products, and in which microwave or hot-air treatment reduces its volatile oils. That is partly why fried ginger tastes sharper and less fresh than raw.
Why should ground spices go in with a splash of water?
Because ground spices have enormous surface area and almost no water, so in hot fat alone they go from raw to burnt in seconds; a little water or tomato caps the pan temperature near 100°C, giving them time to cook without scorching.
Water cannot get hotter than its boiling point at atmospheric pressure, about 99.6°C at 1 bar according to NIST, until it has all evaporated, and evaporating it takes a lot of energy: about 2,257 kJ for every kilogram.
Reading the equation
- m is the mass of water;
- cp = 4.2 kJ/kg·K, the heat needed to warm it;
- hfg = 2,257 kJ/kg, the heat needed to boil it off;
- P is the heat your burner actually delivers into the pan.
A 30 ml splash of tap water at 25°C on a burner delivering 1.5 kW holds the pan near 100°C for about 50 seconds: enough for turmeric, chilli, coriander and cumin powders to lose their raw taste. Use this to check what you just read.
How long a splash of water protects ground spices
Why "until the oil separates"
The calculation also explains the old instruction to cook the masala "until the oil separates". While water remains, the mixture sits near 100°C; once it has evaporated, the oil reappears at the edges and the temperature climbs again into the browning range.
That is your signal to add the main ingredient or more liquid. Cooks call this stage bhuna.

Why do garam masala and kasuri methi go in last?
Because the longer spices cook in a wet curry, the more of their characteristic compounds are lost, and the aromatic finishing spices have little else to offer once their volatiles are gone. CSIR-CFTRI researchers measured those losses for three key compounds.
The CFTRI team cooked turmeric, red pepper and black pepper by boiling for 10 or 20 minutes or pressure cooking for 10 minutes, alone and with toor dal or tamarind, and measured the remaining curcumin, capsaicin and piperine by HPLC. Losses were 27 to 53% for curcumin (12 to 30% with tamarind), 18 to 36% for capsaicin and 16 to 34% for piperine, with pressure cooking the harshest. An earlier study by the same group found more than 85% of curcumin lost when curry mixes were boiled 15 to 30 minutes. Limits: marker compounds only, not the full aroma, and lab rather than kitchen conditions.
Read the abstract (free)See the data as a table
| Lowest loss (%) | Highest loss (%) | |
|---|---|---|
| Curcumin (turmeric) | 27 | 53 |
| Capsaicin (red pepper) | 18 | 36 |
| Piperine (black pepper) | 16 | 34 |
Source: Suresh, Manjunatha and Srinivasan, Journal of Food Composition and Analysis 2007 · Range across boiling 10 min, boiling 20 min and pressure cooking 10 min; highest losses were in the pressure cooker.
What the finishing spices give
Turmeric, chilli and pepper can afford those losses because they also give colour, heat and body. The finishing spices are different:
- Garam masala: its cinnamon, clove and cardamom contribute mainly aroma, so it goes in during the last few minutes.
- Kasuri methi: crushed between the palms, it goes in last of all.
- Fresh coriander: goes on after the heat is off.
Why garam masala and curry powder are built differently for exactly this reason is in garam masala vs curry powder.

Where does hing (asafoetida) go?
Hing goes into the hot fat for a few seconds, usually right after the whole seeds and before onions or dal, because its sulfur-rich volatile oil is potent and fragile.
Asafoetida is about 40 to 64% resin, around 25% gum and 10 to 17% essential oil, according to a 2017 review in the Journal of Traditional and Complementary Medicine, and its smell comes from disulfides in that oil. A pinch in hot fat mellows the raw sulfur note; too long and it turns bitter.
| Spice | Form | When | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cumin, mustard, fennel seeds | Whole | First, in hot fat | Fat-soluble oils need heat and fat; husks protect them |
| Cloves, cardamom, cinnamon, bay leaf | Whole | First | Release eugenol and cinnamaldehyde into the oil |
| Hing | Powder | Seconds after the seeds | Potent sulfur volatiles; burns fast |
| Ginger, garlic | Paste | After onions brown | Fine, sugary, burns easily |
| Turmeric, chilli, coriander, cumin powder | Ground | With tomato or water | High surface area; water caps the temperature |
| Garam masala | Ground blend | Last 2 to 5 minutes | Aroma lost with long simmering |
| Kasuri methi | Dried leaf | Last minute | Delicate aroma |
| Fresh coriander | Leaf | Off the heat | Fresh volatiles fade quickly |
Is there only one correct order?
No. The six-step sequence is the North Indian restaurant default, and regional cooking reorders it for good reasons:
- South Indian dal and sambar: the tadka of mustard seeds, urad dal and curry leaves is often poured over the finished dish at the end, the "finished dish" method the DonRockwell thread describes.
- Bengali cooking: it often starts with whole spices in mustard oil and adds ground spices as a wet paste, which builds in the water from the start.
What all of them respect is the same physics: fat for whole spices, water for ground spices, and little time for fragile aromatics.
Why Indian food uses so many spices at all is covered in why Indian food uses so many spices, and how chilli heat behaves in fat in how capsaicin works.
Fat for whole spices, water for ground spices, and little time for fragile aromatics. The rule behind every regional order
What's new
- Kerala inspects 1,834 eateries, shuts 74 and destroys 1,436 litres of over-used cooking oil Onmanorama, Oct 2026
- Maharashtra FDA bans loose spice powders and ethylene oxide sterilisation The Week, Oct 2026
- 474 of 4,054 spice samples failed FSSAI checks in mid-2024 Free Press Journal, Aug 2024
Questions people ask
Do you add spices before or after onions?
Whole spices before onions, in the hot fat; ground spices after onions and ginger-garlic, usually with tomato or a splash of water so they don't burn.
Why do my ground spices burn?
They have a large surface area and no water, so in hot oil alone they scorch in seconds. Lower the heat and add them with tomato or a little water, which holds the pan near 100°C.
When should I add garam masala?
In the last two to five minutes, or sprinkled on top. Long simmering costs a large share of spice compounds; CFTRI measured 16 to 53% losses for key compounds in 10 to 20 minutes.
Should I add turmeric to hot oil?
Briefly, and at moderate heat, or with the onions and tomatoes. Turmeric burns fast as a dry powder in hot fat; a few seconds is enough before liquid goes in.
Why is it called "bhuna" when the oil separates?
Bhuna means frying the masala until its water has evaporated and the oil comes back out at the edges. That is the point where the temperature rises above 100°C again and browning resumes.
More from the Taste Lab on Rasa.
Sources
- Suresh, Manjunatha, Srinivasan: Effect of heat processing of spices on the concentrations of their bioactive principles, J Food Compos Anal 20 (2007)
- Srinivasan, Sambaiah, Chandrasekhara: Loss of active principles of common spices during domestic cooking, Food Chemistry 43(4) (1992; source for more than 85% curcumin loss)
- Perera, Hewavitharana, Navaratne: Physicochemical and functional properties of coconut oil with bioactive compounds from spices, Journal of Lipids (2020)
- Zagórska et al.: Impact of Thermal Processing on the Selected Biological Activities of Ginger Rhizome, Molecules 28(1):412 (2023)
- Amalraj and Gopi: Biological activities and medicinal properties of Asafoetida, J Tradit Complement Med 7(3) (2017)
- NIST Chemistry WebBook: Thermophysical properties of water at saturation (source for 99.6°C, 2,257.4 kJ/kg and cp)
- Wikipedia: Smoke point (table of fats with cited references) (accessed 2026)
- Onmanorama: Operation Thelima, used cooking oil seized in Kerala (2026)
- DonRockwell forum: Tempering thread (accessed 2026)
- Glasse, H.: The Art of Cookery Made Plain and Easy, 1755 edition (Internet Archive, Wellcome Collection) (source for the story's recipe)
- Wikipedia: Hannah Glasse (first edition 1747; first known English curry recipe) (accessed 2026)

