The Maillard reaction in Indian cooking: bhuna, tandoor, toast

Browning is a sugar meeting an amino acid at the right temperature, pH and moisture. Get those three right and bhuna, tandoori chicken and a crisp parotta stop being luck.

Flatbread dough stuck to the hot inner wall of a clay tandoor, blistering and browning
Photo: Ravi Dwivedi, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The Maillard reaction in Indian cooking is the chemical browning that happens when a reducing sugar (glucose, fructose, lactose) reacts with an amino acid on a hot, fairly dry surface. It barely moves at 100°C and speeds up sharply between about 120 and 160°C, which is why onions only brown after their water has boiled off, why a tandoor's wall browns naan in a minute, and why acidic, wet masalas take patience.

Key takeaways
  • Three inputs: a reducing sugar, a free amino group and a dry surface well above 100°C.
  • About 30×: how much faster browning runs at 140°C than at 100°C (Arrhenius, 109 kJ/mol).
  • Water activity 0.6 to 0.7 is the sweet spot; a wet onion sits near 0.99.
  • Below pH 6 the reaction crawls, so tomato, tamarind and curd pause browning.
  • 930 µg/kg acrylamide in Prayagraj restaurant fries (2022): stop at golden, not dark.

Recipes say "fry the onions till golden" or "bhuno till the oil separates" and leave out the chemistry. The chemistry is simple enough to use at the stove: three inputs (sugar, amino groups, heat) and three brakes (water, acidity, time). This post puts numbers on each, using a 2025 review of Maillard kinetics, Indian measurements of acrylamide in fried foods, a review of the amines that form on grilled meat, and USDA composition data for the ingredients you actually cook.

109 kJ/molactivation energy, glucose plus glycine at pH 5.5 (El Hosry et al., 2025)
0.6 to 0.7water activity where browning runs fastest
>120°Cwhere acrylamide starts to form in starchy food
4.24 gtotal sugar in 100 g of raw onion (USDA)

What is the Maillard reaction, chemically?

The story

Around 1912 Louis-Camille Maillard, a physician and chemist then working at the University of Nancy, showed the French Academy of Sciences what happened when he mixed amino acids with sugars and heated them: the liquid turned yellow-brown. His three-page note in the Comptes rendus (volume 154, pages 66 to 68) called the brown products melanoidins.

It did not knock the academy off its chairs, and two world wars buried it. Only in 1953 did John E. Hodge, a chemist at the US Department of Agriculture, publish a step-by-step scheme in the Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, titled "Dehydrated Foods, Chemistry of Browning Reactions in Model Systems". His stages are still how chemists teach the reaction that browns every onion in a kadhai.

Wikipedia: Maillard reaction, history section with the 1912 and 1953 citations; The Brewers Journal: the Maillard reaction

The Maillard reaction is a cascade that starts when the carbonyl group of a reducing sugar condenses with a free amino group, usually the side chain of lysine or a free amino acid, and ends in brown polymers called melanoidins. The 2025 review by El Hosry and colleagues in Foods splits it into three stages, and each stage maps onto something you can see or smell in a kadhai.

  1. Early stage (colourless, odourless). Sugar and amine join into a glycosylamine, which rearranges into an Amadori product (for glucose) or a Heyns product (for fructose). Nothing looks different yet.
  2. Intermediate stage (aroma). Amadori products break into reactive dicarbonyls. These attack amino acids in Strecker degradation, which releases Strecker aldehydes (malty, chocolatey, potato-like notes) and builds pyrazines and thiazoles (roasted, nutty). In the review's asparagine-glucose model, pyrazines such as 2,5-dimethylpyrazine climb above 140°C.
  3. Advanced stage (colour). Fragments polymerise into melanoidins, the brown pigments. Labs track them by absorbance at 420 nm, the same yellow-brown band your eye reads as "golden".

Maillard is not caramelisation

Caramelisation is a different reaction: sugar alone breaking down with heat, no amino acid needed. Onions and jaggery do both at once, which is why the two words get mixed up. The practical difference is that Maillard flavour is savoury and meaty, while pure caramel is sweet and bitter.

Maillard reaction, simplified Reducing sugar glucose, fructose Amino group lysine, asparagine Amadori product early stage, no colour Dicarbonyls reactive fragments Strecker aldehydes, pyrazines: aroma Melanoidins: brown colour Side routes at high heat acrylamide (asparagine, >120°C) heterocyclic amines (meat, >150°C) Brakes: water (caps surface at 100°C), low pH, short time
The three stages, with the two side routes that matter for health. Simplified from the stage scheme in El Hosry et al. (2025).

Why does browning stall at 100°C?

Browning stalls because liquid water cannot get hotter than its boiling point, and as long as a food surface is wet it sits at roughly 100°C at sea level and about 97°C in Bengaluru, too cool for fast Maillard chemistry. The heat from the burner goes into evaporating water (about 2,257 kJ per kg) instead of raising the surface temperature.

The reaction is not zero at 100°C, it is just slow. The El Hosry review collects activation energies of 109 kJ/mol for glucose with glycine at pH 5.5 and 145 kJ/mol for glucose with phenylalanine at pH 7. Plug the first into the Arrhenius equation and moving a surface from 100°C to 140°C makes the reaction roughly 30 times faster; going to 160°C makes it about 130 times faster.

That is the whole reason a tava, a tandoor and a hot kadhai of oil brown food while a pot of dal never does. Dry the surface and get it past 120°C, or nothing browns.

Water activity: the second brake

Water activity matters as much as temperature. The same review puts the fastest browning at a water activity of about 0.6 to 0.7. Below 0.4 the reactants cannot move; above 0.9 water dilutes them and pushes the equilibrium back. A wet onion is at about 0.99, a properly bhuna masala sits much lower, and a tandoori crust is lower still.

How much faster browning runs as the surface heats up
See the data as a table
Relative rate (Ea 109 kJ/mol) (× rate at 100°C)
100°C1
110°C2.5
120°C6.0
130°C13.7
140°C30.0
150°C63.5
160°C129.9
180°C494.1

Source: Computed with the Arrhenius equation from the 109 kJ/mol activation energy (glucose plus glycine, pH 5.5) in El Hosry et al., Foods 2025 · Model system in solution; real food also depends on water activity and pH

Try your own numbers. The calculator uses the same Arrhenius relation: put in the temperature you are at, the temperature you could reach, and an activation energy from the review's range.

Browning speed-up from a hotter surface

The browning temperature ladder 97°CBoiling point in Bengaluru 100°CSea level: dal, rice, wet onion 118–120°CPressure cooker: still wet, no browning >120°CAcrylamide starts in starchy food >140°CPyrazines climb: nutty, roasted aroma 150–250°CPolar heterocyclic amines on meat tava, tandoor wall, kadhai of hot oil >250°CNon-polar amines, charring Shaded band: where water caps the food surface
Where each thing happens. Boiling points are physics; the 120°C, 140°C and 150 to 250°C thresholds come from El Hosry et al. (2025) and Nadeem et al. (2021).

What actually browns in bhuna masala?

In onion-tomato bhuna the reactants are the onion's free sugars and amino acids, joined later by tomato's sugars and glutamic acid, and the browning only takes off once frying has driven the water out and the oil can heat the solids past 120°C. Raw onion is about 89% water by weight (USDA FoodData Central), so most of a typical bhuna is spent boiling water away.

What onion and tomato bring to the pan

USDA FoodData Central gives the starting chemistry. Per 100 g of raw onion: 4.24 g of sugars (glucose 1.97 g, fructose 1.29 g, sucrose 0.99 g), 1.1 g of protein, 0.258 g of glutamic acid and 0.039 g of lysine. Glucose and fructose are reducing sugars and react directly; sucrose has to split first, which heat and the onion's mild acidity slowly do.

Tomato brings 1.25 g of glucose and 1.37 g of fructose per 100 g and 0.431 g of glutamic acid, but it is 94.5% water and acidic (USDA FoodData Central), so adding it stops browning and starts a second round of evaporation.

Ingredient (per 100 g)WaterReducing sugarsProteinLysineRole in browning
Onion, raw89.1 g3.26 g (glucose + fructose)1.1 g0.039 gSugar-rich, amino-poor: browns sweet and deep once dry
Tomato, ripe94.5 g2.62 g0.88 g0.027 gAdds glutamate, but its water and acid pause browning
Whole milk88.1 g5.05 g (lactose)3.15 g0.264 gKhoa and rabri brown as lactose meets milk lysine
Bread flour (maida-type)13.4 g0.31 g total sugars12.0 g0.231 gLow sugar: parotta and naan crusts lean on dough enzymes and heat
Chicken breast, roasted65.3 g031.0 g2.64 gAmino-rich, sugar-poor: marinade sugars and onion help

Two practical lessons fall out of that table:

  • Onion is sugar-rich and amino-poor, so even small amounts of protein in the pan (a spoon of curd, ginger-garlic paste, the meat itself) speed browning.
  • "Oil separates" is a moisture gauge. Oil only pools visibly once the masala's water has dropped far enough that the solids no longer hold it in an emulsion, which is the same point at which the surface can climb past 100°C.
Chopped onions frying in a pan, starting to turn translucent and brown at the edges
Onions at this stage are still mostly boiling off water. Real browning starts when the edges dry and the pan's sizzle drops in pitch.Photo: Dnor, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Why do onions take 20 minutes to brown when recipes say five?

With these example inputs, onions take long because a 500 g batch holds about 445 g of water that must evaporate before the surface can exceed 100°C, and a domestic burner can only boil off that water so fast. Cooks on eGullet and r/AskCulinary say it bluntly: recipe timings for browned onions are routinely optimistic, and keeping the heat low enough not to scorch spices stretches the time further.

Calculated in this post from an example 500 g batch of onions and the 89.1% water content of raw onion (USDA FoodData Central).

The energy arithmetic

Here is the energy arithmetic. Evaporating 445 g of water takes about 445 × 2.257 ≈ 1,000 kJ. A typical Indian LPG burner delivers a few kilowatts into the flame, but only part of that reaches the food; at an effective 1 kW into the pan, evaporation alone needs about 17 minutes. That number is my estimate from textbook latent heat, not a measurement, but it lines up with the 20 to 30 minutes experienced cooks report.

Three things shorten it without burning anything:

  • A wider pan. More surface area means faster evaporation per minute. A crowded kadhai steams instead of fries.
  • A pinch of salt early. Salt draws water out of the cut cells by osmosis, so it reaches the hot oil sooner.
  • Adding tomato late. Every wet, acidic addition resets the surface to 100°C and lowers pH, so add it after the onions have the colour you want.

Soda and sugar shortcuts

There is one shortcut that works and one to avoid. A pinch of baking soda raises pH and speeds browning a lot, because the review notes the reaction is very slow below pH 6 and quick in alkaline conditions; the cost is soft, mushy onion and a soapy edge if overdone. Sugar or jaggery speeds colour too, but mostly through caramelisation, which tastes sweeter than true bhuna.

How does a tandoor brown food so fast?

A tandoor browns food fast because its clay wall and coals push surface temperatures far above 150°C while radiant heat dries the food's outer layer in seconds, so the surface gets out of the 100°C water trap almost immediately. Naan slapped on the wall browns in a minute or two; tandoori chicken chars at the tips while the inside is still cooking.

The marinade as a Maillard toolkit

The marinade is a Maillard toolkit. Curd supplies lactose (a reducing sugar) and milk proteins rich in lysine; the El Hosry review notes lysine makes up 14 of 199 residues in αs1-casein and 24 of 207 in αs2-casein. The spice paste adds more sugar and amino acids. Yet curd is also acidic, which on its own would slow browning; the tandoor's sheer heat overrides that, and the acid's job is tenderising.

The trade-off: heterocyclic amines

The trade-off is heterocyclic aromatic amines (HAAs), mutagens that form on cooked muscle. The 2021 review by Nadeem and colleagues in Foods gives the mechanism: creatine or creatinine in meat reacts with Maillard products and free amino acids. Polar HAAs form at 150 to 250°C, non-polar ones above 250°C, and household cooking typically leaves 0.1 to 50 ng per gram of meat.

Pieces of red-orange tandoori chicken with charred edges on a plate
Charred tips are Maillard plus pyrolysis. The darkest spots are where heterocyclic amines concentrate, which is a reason to trim, not to panic.Photo: pelican, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Heterocyclic Aromatic Amines in Meat: Formation, Isolation, Risk Assessment, and Inhibitory Effect of Plant ExtractsNadeem et al. · Foods · 2021

A review of how HAAs form, at what temperatures, and what reduces them, pooling dozens of cooking experiments. It places polar HAAs at 150 to 250°C and non-polar ones above 250°C, with home-cooked meat usually at 0.1 to 50 ng/g. Spices help: 3% turmeric cut total HAAs in beef cooked at 240°C by 75.4%, and 1% black pepper removed PhIP entirely in fried tilapia. The limit is that each study used different meats, doses and methods, so the percentages cannot be compared directly or assumed for a home tandoor.

Read the paper (free)

Why does a parotta or roti brown on a tava?

A parotta browns because a thin layer of dough touches iron far hotter than boiling water, so its surface dries and passes the Maillard range in seconds while the inside steams. Maida itself is low in free sugar (USDA lists 0.31 g per 100 g of bread flour), so the reducing sugars come mostly from the dough's own amylase enzymes breaking starch into maltose during resting, plus any sugar or milk in the dough.

Fat matters too. Oil or ghee on a parotta conducts heat evenly into every ridge of the layers, which is why a well-oiled parotta browns uniformly while a dry roti spots. Ghee brings its own milk solids (lactose and protein), the reason ghee-roasted dosa smells nuttier than one made with neutral oil.

Is acrylamide in Indian fried snacks something to worry about?

Acrylamide forms when the amino acid asparagine reacts with reducing sugars above about 120°C, so it shows up in chips, fries, biscuits and dark-fried snacks, and Indian samples vary over a wide range. Food Standards Scotland describes it as a natural by-product of high-temperature cooking of starchy foods and recommends cutting intake as a precaution, without setting a legal maximum.

The best Indian numbers come from a 2022 study in Prayagraj. Verma and Yadav tested 43 commercial products by HPLC. French fries from local restaurants averaged 930 µg/kg (range 826 to 1,143), branded biscuits 370 µg/kg and bakery biscuits 398 µg/kg.

Product (Prayagraj, 2022)SamplesMean acrylamide
French fries, local restaurants16930 µg/kg (826 to 1,143)
Bakery biscuits14398 µg/kg
Branded biscuits13370 µg/kg

Acrylamide rose with browning index and with HMF, another Maillard marker, which means the darker the product, the higher the reading.

Acrylamide content in starch based commercial foods by using high performance liquid chromatography and its association with browning indexVerma and Yadav · Current Research in Food Science · 2022

The authors bought 16 French fry samples, 13 branded biscuits and 14 bakery biscuits in Prayagraj and measured acrylamide with HPLC-DAD (recovery about 100.6%). Fries ranged from 826 to 1,143 µg/kg with a mean of 930, and every fry sample exceeded the benchmark the authors used. Acrylamide correlated positively with HMF, redness and browning index (P ≤ 0.01), so they suggest colour as a cheap screening tool. Limits: one city, one sampling round, 43 products, and no data on frying temperature or oil.

Read the paper (free)

The darker the product, the higher the acrylamide reading: in Prayagraj, colour alone tracked the toxin.

Summarising Verma and Yadav, Current Research in Food Science, 2022

The practical rule is the same as the paper's: aim for golden, not dark brown. The Prayagraj data show the darkest products carrying the most acrylamide, and the El Hosry review explains why: every 10°C of extra surface heat multiplies the reaction rate. The El Hosry review puts typical adult exposure at 0.3 to 1.0 µg per kg of body weight per day, a range regulators treat as worth reducing rather than as an emergency.

How is coffee roasting the same reaction?

Coffee roasting is the Maillard reaction run on dry green beans, which hold sucrose, free amino acids and very little water, so once the beans dry, their surface can climb far past 150°C and build hundreds of aroma compounds. Pyrazines give the nutty, roasted notes, and furans and Strecker aldehydes give the caramel and chocolate ones. The El Hosry review reports that coffee melanoidins can bind aroma thiols: the roasty 2-furfurylthiol fell 16-fold in one coffee study, which is part of why brewed coffee loses aroma as it sits.

The same rules apply. Water is driven out first (the "drying" phase), browning starts as the bean dries, and roast degree is a direct readout of how far the Maillard and caramelisation reactions have gone.

A heap of dark brown roasted coffee beans
Roasted beans are Maillard chemistry made visible: the colour is melanoidins, the aroma is pyrazines and Strecker aldehydes.Photo: Sridhar Rao, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

What does pH do to browning?

pH controls how many amino groups are free to react: below about pH 6 most are protonated and the rate is very low, while above pH 7 the reaction speeds up. The El Hosry review states that pH 5 or below is enough to stop browning under moderate heating (up to 100°C for under a day).

Indian cooking runs into this constantly. Tamarind, tomato, kokum, curd and lemon all push pH down; soda and lye push it up.

Kitchen movepH directionWhat you see
Tomato-heavy gravyDown (acidic)Never browns, however long it simmers
Tamarind-based rasamDownStays bright
A teaspoon of curd in a marinadeDownDoes less for colour than the grill's heat
Soda in street-style bhaji batterUp (alkaline)Browns fast
Alkaline lye in some noodlesUpBrowns fast

For the next step in the same chemistry, read how hot oil carries spice aroma in tadka chemistry, how roasting builds flavour in coffee roasting chemistry, why glutamate makes browned food taste savoury in umami in Indian food, and why a pressure cooker cooks fast but never browns. More food science lives on the Rasa world page.

Maillard Reaction: Mechanism, Influencing Parameters, Advantages, Disadvantages, and Food Industrial Applications: A ReviewEl Hosry et al. · Foods · 2025

A broad review of Maillard chemistry that pulls kinetic data from many model studies. Useful numbers: activation energies of 109 to 145 kJ/mol depending on the sugar and amino acid; the fastest rate at water activity 0.6 to 0.7; very low rates below pH 6; pyrazines and thiazoles rising above 140°C; heterocyclic amines needing more than 150°C; acrylamide above about 120°C. The limit is that most numbers come from simple sugar-amino acid solutions, not whole foods, so they set direction and order of magnitude rather than exact cooking times.

Read the paper (free)

Questions people ask

Is the Maillard reaction the same as caramelisation?

No. The Maillard reaction needs a reducing sugar and an amino group and gives savoury, roasted flavours. Caramelisation needs only sugar and higher heat. Onions do both, so "caramelised onions" are really a mix of the two.

Why don't boiled or pressure-cooked foods brown?

Because the food stays wet, its temperature is capped near the boiling point: about 100°C in an open pot and about 118 to 120°C in a pressure cooker. At those temperatures and with that much water the reaction is too slow to colour food in normal cooking times.

Does adding a pinch of sugar help onions brown?

It adds colour faster, mostly through caramelisation, and gives a sweeter base. Salt early and a wide pan help more with true browning because they remove water, the real bottleneck.

Is burnt or dark-brown food dangerous?

Very dark starchy food carries more acrylamide and charred meat more heterocyclic amines. Regulators advise reducing intake as a precaution, and a 2026 fact check found the claim that burnt roti causes cancer to be false. Aim for golden, trim black bits, and do not worry about an occasional dark edge.

Sources

  1. El Hosry L. et al., Foods: Maillard Reaction: Mechanism, Influencing Parameters, Advantages, Disadvantages, and Food Industrial Applications: A Review (2025; activation energies, pH, water activity, temperature thresholds)
  2. Nadeem H.R. et al., Foods: Heterocyclic Aromatic Amines in Meat: Formation, Isolation, Risk Assessment, and Inhibitory Effect of Plant Extracts (2021; HAA temperatures and spice reductions)
  3. Verma V. and Yadav N., Current Research in Food Science: Acrylamide content in starch based commercial foods by HPLC and its association with browning index (2022; Prayagraj acrylamide data)
  4. USDA FoodData Central: Onions, raw (FDC 170000) (sugars, amino acids, water)
  5. USDA FoodData Central: Tomatoes, red, ripe, raw (FDC 170457)
  6. USDA FoodData Central: Milk, whole, 3.25% (FDC 171265); also chicken breast roasted (FDC 171477) and bread flour (FDC 168913)
  7. Food Standards Scotland: Call for data, acrylamide in food (2025)
  8. The Week: Fact check, does burnt roti lead to cancer due to acrylamide? (2026)
  9. Wikipedia: Maillard reaction (history: Maillard 1912, Comptes rendus 154: 66-68; Hodge 1953, J. Agric. Food Chem. 1: 928-43)
  10. The Brewers Journal: the Maillard reaction (Maillard's demonstration to the French Academy and its reception)
  11. India Science and Technology: Evaluating mitigation strategies of acrylamide in Indian festive snack foods (DST project, 2024 to 2028)
Maillard reactionbhunatandoorbrowningacrylamidepyrazinesfood chemistryheterocyclic amines
Sapta

Sapta (Saptarshi Sarkar) is a mechanical engineer turned marketer in Bengaluru and a solo touring rider. He writes the seven Saptaverse blogs. Work with him or read more of Foodblog.

Keep reading in Foodblog

From the other blogs