Spice adulteration in India: lead chromate, dyes and tests

Lead chromate in Patna turmeric, ethylene oxide in export masalas, Sudan dye in chilli: what the lab data actually shows, and which kitchen tests are worth doing.

Rooftop view over the backs of the spice shops at the Khari Baoli spice market in Old Delhi
Photo: Jakub Hałun, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Spice adulteration in India is real but concentrated: the dangerous cases are industrial pigments such as lead chromate in turmeric and synthetic dyes in chilli, not the chalk and sawdust most home tests look for. A 2024 survey of 356 South Asian turmeric samples found lead above 2 µg/g in 14% of them, with Patna samples reaching 2,274 µg/g against FSSAI's limit of 10 µg/g. Packaged branded spices have a different problem, residues such as ethylene oxide, which no kitchen test can detect.

Key takeaways
  • 2,274 µg/g of lead in one Patna turmeric sample, against an FSSAI limit of 10 µg/g.
  • 14% of 356 South Asian turmeric samples carried lead above 2 µg/g (2020–21).
  • 47% to 0%: Bangladesh cleared lead chromate from market turmeric in about two years.
  • 474 of 4,054 Indian spice samples failed FSSAI checks in mid-2024.
  • Kitchen tests catch fillers and crude dyes, never lead at harmful levels or ethylene oxide.

The useful way to think about this is by adulterant, not by spice. Each adulterant has a motive (colour, weight or shelf life), a health risk, and a detection method, and the three rarely line up neatly.

This post works through the research, the 2024 export recalls, the regulator's own test methods and the numbers, so you can tell a genuine risk from a WhatsApp scare.

What is spice adulteration in India, and why do spices attract it?

Spice adulteration is the deliberate addition of a cheaper or cosmetic substance to a spice, and spices attract it because they are high-value, sold ground and judged largely by colour. Forsyth and colleagues at Stanford make this point directly in their 2024 paper: spices are a high-value commodity often sold in processed forms, which makes fraud both profitable and hard to see.

How much money is at stake

The money is large. India exported 17.34 lakh tonnes of spices and spice products worth ₹39,140 crore (US$4.43 billion) in 2025-26, according to the Spices Board, after a record ₹39,994 crore in 2024-25.

Domestic consumption is larger still. Chilli alone was 27% of export value in 2025-26 and turmeric 7% (Spices Board India). When a product sells on brightness, anything that makes it brighter for less money is a temptation.

India spice exports by volume, lakh tonnes
See the data as a table
Export volume (lakh t)
2020-2115.65
2021-2215.31
2022-2314.04
2023-2415.4
2024-2517.99
2025-2617.34

Source: Spices Board India, annual export reviews and press releases · Values: ₹27,193 cr (2020-21), ₹31,761 cr (2022-23), ₹36,959 cr (2023-24), ₹39,994 cr (2024-25), ₹39,140 cr (2025-26). The 2021-22 rupee value differs between Spices Board releases, so it is not shown.

Four kinds of adulterant

The adulterants fall into four groups, and they need different responses:

  • Bulking agents (starch, chalk, brick powder, sawdust, papaya seeds): economic fraud. Mostly harmless or mildly harmful, and the easiest to spot at home.
  • Colourants (lead chromate, metanil yellow, Sudan dyes, Rhodamine B): cosmetic fraud, and the toxic group. Lead chromate is the worst.
  • Process residues (ethylene oxide, pesticides): not added as fraud, but left behind by fumigation or farming. Lab-only detection.
  • Natural contaminants (aflatoxins from mould in chilli and nutmeg): storage failures. Also lab-only.
Risk vs what you can detect at home Kitchen test works Lab only Higher health risk Lower risk Crude colourantsheavy lead chromateon whole roots,dyes that streakin water Hidden hazardslow lead, Sudan dyes,ethylene oxide,pesticides,aflatoxins Bulking agentssawdust, brick dust,papaya seeds,exhausted cloves Hidden fillersstarch, chalk,soapstone inpowders The top-right box is why a clean kitchen test is not a clean bill of health
The adulterants that matter most for health sit where home tests cannot reach. Grouping from the FSSAI manual and the Forsyth papers.

How much lead is in Indian turmeric, and where?

Most Indian turmeric tested in the largest recent survey had no detectable lead, but a few cities had extreme levels, with every Patna sample contaminated and a Patna median of 1,232 µg/g. That is the core finding of the Forsyth et al. study published in Science of the Total Environment in July 2024.

The survey design

The team bought 356 samples (180 dried roots, 176 powders) from wholesale and retail bazaars in 23 cities across India, Pakistan, Sri Lanka and Nepal between December 2020 and March 2021. In India they picked 17 states in proportion to population and sampled the largest city in each.

What they found

Of all samples, 14% (51) had lead above 2 µg/g and 7% (24) were above India's standard of 10 µg/g (Forsyth et al. 2024). Seven cities crossed that standard: Patna, Guwahati and Chennai in India, plus Kathmandu, Karachi, Islamabad and Peshawar. Patna, Karachi and Peshawar went above 1,000 µg/g.

2,274 µg/ghighest lead in a Patna turmeric sample (2020-21)
10 µg/gFSSAI limit for lead in turmeric
14%of 356 South Asian samples above 2 µg/g
1:1lead to chromium molar ratio in samples at or above 18 µg/g

The chemical fingerprint is what makes this adulteration rather than pollution. Lead chromate (PbCrO4) carries one lead atom per chromium atom. In samples at or above 18 µg/g of lead, the molar ratio of lead to chromium sat near 1:1.

That is what you would expect if someone had dusted chrome yellow pigment onto the roots. Soil or traffic contamination would not produce that ratio.

Evidence of turmeric adulteration with lead chromate across South AsiaJenna E. Forsyth et al. · Science of the Total Environment, vol. 949 · 2024

356 turmeric samples from 23 cities in four countries were tested for lead and chromium, and child blood lead levels were modelled where lead was found. 14% of samples had lead above 2 µg/g, samples above 18 µg/g showed a near 1:1 lead to chromium molar ratio, and Patna, Karachi and Peshawar exceeded 1,000 µg/g, giving projected child blood lead up to 10 times the US CDC level of concern. The limit: one buying round in one season, few samples per city (Patna had 12), and bazaar purchases rather than branded retail packs.

Read the paper (free, CC BY)
The story

The trail to that survey began in rural Bangladesh in 2015, when Stanford PhD researcher Jenna Forsyth found unexpectedly high lead in the blood of pregnant women. Leaded petrol was already banned, and her pesticide theory failed. Of the first 17 turmeric samples her team tested, one carried very high lead and chromium, and her adviser, epidemiologist Stephen Luby, asked her to prove it.

Lead isotope ratios did: the lead in the women's blood matched the turmeric and the yellow pigment used to colour it. After a public campaign from September to December 2019, with 50,000 posters, food safety officers escorted by soldiers screened bags in a Dhaka market with a handheld X-ray analyser, destroyed tainted stock and fined traders the equivalent of about $9,288 on the spot (Stanford Medicine, 2023). Television carried it nationwide. Adulterated turmeric in markets fell from 47% in September 2019 to 5% by early 2020.

Stanford Medicine magazine (Kris Newby): The spice sellers' secret, June 2023
Fresh turmeric rhizomes beside a small heap of bright yellow turmeric powder
Turmeric gets its colour from curcumin. Lead chromate is added to the dried roots during polishing to fake a brighter, more even yellow.Photo: Simon A. Eugster, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Why would anyone add lead chromate to turmeric?

Processors add lead chromate because it turns dull or poor-quality turmeric roots a uniform bright yellow during polishing, and buyers pay more for brightness. The practice was traced in Bangladesh, where processors told researchers it began in the 1980s after a flood left the crop dull, and it then spread as a cheap fix for low-grade roots.

How Bangladesh stopped it

Bangladesh is also the proof that it can be stopped. After Stanford and icddr,b researchers published the problem in 2019, the country combined several measures:

  • news coverage and public notices;
  • face-to-face outreach to traders;
  • rapid lead testing in markets;
  • fast penalties by the Bangladesh Food Safety Authority.

The 2023 follow-up paper measured the result.

Food safety policy enforcement and associated actions reduce lead chromate adulteration in turmeric across BangladeshJenna E. Forsyth et al. · Environmental Research, vol. 232 · 2023

The team tracked market turmeric and polishing mills from 2017 to 2021 and interviewed 47 consumers, traders and officials. Market samples with detectable lead fell from 47% in 2019 to 0% in 2021 (n = 631), mills with pigment on site fell from 30% to 0% (n = 33), and the 90th percentile of worker blood lead fell 49%, from 18.2 to 9.2 µg/dL, 16 months later. The limit: a before-and-after design with no control country, and the blood lead result rests on only 15 workers.

Read the abstract (Stanford GSB)
Bangladesh: before and after enforcement 47%5%0% 30%0% Sep 2019early 20202021 20172021 Market samples with pigment Mills with pigment
Heights to scale. Figures from Forsyth et al. (2023) and Stanford Medicine (2023).

The lesson for India is uncomfortable but useful. Bangladesh did not need new laws; it needed fast field testing and visible enforcement aimed at a few hundred polishing mills.

Pure Earth reported in 2026 that it is working with Bihar's food safety department on inspections in Patna, Gaya and Samastipur, and that at an April 2026 workshop only about half the officials could spot an adulterated sample by eye.

What happened with MDH and Everest and ethylene oxide in 2024?

In April 2024 Hong Kong's Centre for Food Safety found ethylene oxide in four Indian spice mixes, three from MDH and one from Everest, and Singapore later recalled Everest Fish Curry Masala over the same chemical.

The CFS named the products as MDH Madras Curry Powder, MDH Sambhar Masala, MDH Curry Powder and Everest Fish Curry Masala, all bought at retail outlets in Tsim Sha Tsui under its routine surveillance programme, and it did not publish concentrations.

What ethylene oxide is

Ethylene oxide is a gas used to sterilise spices against Salmonella and moulds. The International Agency for Research on Cancer classifies it as a Group 1 carcinogen.

It is not an adulterant in the fraud sense; it is a fumigation residue, and many importing countries effectively allow none in food. Both companies said their products were safe.

India's response

India's response came in two parts:

  • Testing at home. FSSAI collected 34 samples from MDH and Everest plants (25 and 9) and reported in May 2024 that 28 lab reports found no ethylene oxide.
  • Wider sampling. Reuters obtained data under the RTI Act showing 474 of 4,054 spice samples tested from May to early July 2024 failed quality and safety standards, about 12%. The regulator did not release a brand-wise breakdown.

A parallel row ran over pesticide limits. An FSSAI order dated 8 April 2024 set a default maximum residue limit of 0.1 mg/kg for spices and culinary herbs where no Codex limit exists, up from 0.01 mg/kg.

Activists called it a tenfold loosening; FSSAI called the reports false and said the default applies only to pesticides not registered in India.

A trader weighing and packing loose red chilli powder at a spice shop in Kolkata's New Market
Loose chilli powder at Kolkata's New Market. Colour is the selling point, which is exactly why dyes such as Sudan and Rhodamine B turn up in red spices.Photo: McKay Savage from London, UK, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Which adulterants matter most, and how are they detected?

The table below ranks common spice adulterants by health risk and pairs each with the detection method FSSAI itself lists. The lab methods come from FSSAI's 2019 Manual of Methods for Testing Adulterants; the kitchen tests come from its DART (Detect Adulteration with Rapid Test) series.

AdulterantFound inWhy it is addedHealth riskFSSAI detection
Lead chromateTurmeric (whole and powder)Bright yellow colourSevere: lead harms the developing brain; hexavalent chromium is carcinogenicLab: ash, dissolve in 1:7 sulphuric acid, add diphenylcarbazide; pink means chromate. Kitchen: whole roots that bleed colour into water
Metanil yellowTurmeric powder, pulsesYellow colourAzo dye with suspected toxic effects; not permitted in foodLab: add water and concentrated HCl; violet colour that persists on dilution indicates dye
Sudan III and oil-soluble dyesChilli powderRed colourIndustrial dyes, not permitted in foodLab: hexane extract plus acetonitrile; red lower layer
Rhodamine BChilli powderRed colourIndustrial dye, not permitted in foodLab: shake with acetone; immediate red colour
Ethylene oxideSpice mixes, sesameFumigation residueIARC Group 1 carcinogenAccredited lab only (GC-MS)
Brick powder, sandChilli powderWeightLow, but gritty and fraudulentKitchen: grit settles fast in water
Starch, sawdust, branMost powdersWeightLowLab: iodine turns starch blue. Kitchen: particles float on water
Papaya seedsBlack pepperWeightLowKitchen: papaya seeds float; lab: cut seeds, iodine test
Chalk, soapstoneTurmeric, asafoetidaWeightLowLab: fizzing with dilute HCl

Which home spice tests actually work?

Kitchen tests reliably catch bulking agents and crude dyes, but they cannot detect lead at the levels that matter, and they cannot detect ethylene oxide or pesticides at all. A clean kitchen test does not mean a spice is free of lead or residues.

  1. Chilli powder in water. Sprinkle a spoonful on still water in a clear glass. FSSAI says synthetic colour streaks downward at once; sawdust floats and brick dust sinks quickly as grit.
  2. Turmeric powder in water. Stir a teaspoon into warm water. FSSAI's DART page says pure turmeric leaves a light yellow, while strong yellow suggests added colour.
  3. Whole turmeric in water. Drop a dried root in water. Roots coated in lead chromate shed bright colour immediately; genuine roots do not.
  4. Black pepper in water or spirit. Mature berries sink. Floating, lighter, rounder seeds are either light berries or papaya seeds; press one and it crushes easily.
  5. Cumin rubbed on palms. Grass seeds coloured with charcoal leave black on your hands.
  6. Cloves in water. FSSAI says exhausted cloves (oil already extracted) float, while genuine cloves sink.

How to read the result

Here is how I would use these:

  • Treat a positive result as a reason to change shops, not as a diagnosis.
  • Treat a negative result as meaning only that the crude fraud is absent.

The water test for whole turmeric is the one link between kitchen tests and the lead problem, because lead chromate sits as a surface coating on polished roots, but a light dusting may not show. The Bangladesh team used portable X-ray fluorescence analysers for exactly this reason.

Green peppercorn spikes hanging on a black pepper vine in Coorg, Karnataka
Black pepper on the vine in Coorg. Lighter, immature berries and papaya seeds are the classic pepper fillers, and both float.Photo: This Photo was taken by Timothy A. Gonsalves. Feel free to use my photos, but please mention me as the author. I would, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Is branded spice safer than loose spice?

For lead chromate and crude fillers, branded powder from a licensed manufacturer is the lower-risk choice; for residues such as ethylene oxide and pesticides, branding offers no guarantee, as the 2024 recalls showed.

The Forsyth survey bought from bazaars, which is where bright, cheap loose turmeric is sold. The ethylene oxide cases, by contrast, all involved packaged, branded export mixes.

FSSAI's 2025 drive on processing units

The regulator is now targeting the processing step. A FSSAI circular dated 17 September 2025 ran a 31-day drive from 1 October 2025 aimed only at manufacturing units: spice grinding mills, chilli cleaning plants, turmeric polishing units, cardamom sorting sheds and pepper cracking units.

Samples went to NABL-accredited labs for pesticide residues, aflatoxins, heavy metals, extraneous colour, ash and microbial load, with state returns due by 20 November 2025. That is the right target: turmeric polishing is where lead chromate goes in.

Practical rules

The practical rules that follow from the data:

  • Buy turmeric as a licensed, labelled product, or buy whole roots and judge their colour; matt, uneven, slightly dull roots are normal.
  • Be wary of turmeric or chilli that looks unusually vivid and is unusually cheap.
  • Check the 14-digit FSSAI licence number on the label; see the guide to reading an FSSAI food label.
  • Grind whole spices yourself where you can. Whole pepper, cumin and coriander are much harder to adulterate invisibly than powders.

How big is the health risk from lead in spices?

The risk is serious for heavy users of contaminated turmeric, especially young children and pregnant women, because lead accumulates and childhood exposure causes permanent IQ loss.

Forsyth's model projected that eating turmeric from the worst cities could push child blood lead to as much as 10 times the US CDC reference level of 3.5 µg/dL. The same paper cites an estimate that lead-linked IQ losses cost India, Pakistan, Nepal, Sri Lanka and Bangladesh more than $293 billion a year.

Bangladesh did not need new laws; it needed fast field testing and visible enforcement. From the Forsyth et al. (2023) results above

Work out your own exposure

Use this to check what you just read. Enter how much turmeric you eat a day and its lead level; the presets in the note come from the 2024 survey.

Lead you would eat from turmeric

The perspective cuts both ways. In most of the 23 cities, no sample exceeded the limit. The problem is clustered by supply chain, which is why a national scare is less useful than a targeted crackdown on a few processing hubs.

If you want the bigger picture of where Indian spices are grown and traded, read the top Indian spices by export value and the history of the Malabar pepper trade. For how heat chemistry works once the chilli is clean, see how capsaicin works, and for the rest of the food science on this site, start at Rasa, the Taste Lab.

Questions people ask

How can I check turmeric for lead at home?

You cannot measure lead at home. The closest check is dropping whole dried turmeric roots in water: roots coated with lead chromate release bright yellow colour straight away. A clean result does not rule out low-level contamination, which needs X-ray fluorescence or a lab.

Were MDH and Everest spices banned in India?

No. Hong Kong and Singapore acted on specific export products in April 2024. FSSAI tested samples from both companies' Indian plants and reported no ethylene oxide in the 28 lab reports it had received by May 2024.

Does the water test for chilli powder work?

It works for crude cases. Synthetic colour tends to streak down through water, and brick dust sinks quickly as grit. It will not detect pesticides, aflatoxins or low levels of oil-soluble dyes, which need solvent extraction in a lab.

What is the legal limit for lead in turmeric in India?

FSSAI's Contaminants, Toxins and Residues Regulations, 2011 set 10 µg/g (10 ppm) for lead in whole and powdered turmeric, as cited in the 2024 Forsyth paper.

Sources

  1. Forsyth J.E. et al., Evidence of turmeric adulteration with lead chromate across South Asia, Science of the Total Environment 949 (2024)
  2. Forsyth J.E. et al., Food safety policy enforcement and associated actions reduce lead chromate adulteration in turmeric across Bangladesh, Environmental Research 232 (2023)
  3. Stanford Medicine magazine (Kris Newby): The spice sellers' secret, a hunt for the sources of lead poisoning in Bangladesh (2023; source for the story, the market raid and the 47% to 5% fall)
  4. FSSAI: Manual of Methods for Testing Adulterants in Food (spices chapter) (2019)
  5. FSSAI Eat Right India: DART, Detect Adulteration with Rapid Test (accessed 2026)
  6. Centre for Food Safety, Hong Kong: CFS finds ethylene oxide in samples of prepackaged spice mix products (2024)
  7. The Week: FSSAI clears MDH, Everest spice samples, finds no ethylene oxide (2024)
  8. Outlook Business, citing Reuters RTI data: 474 of 4,054 spice samples fail quality tests (2024)
  9. Down To Earth: Activists call out FSSAI over pesticide limits in herbs and spices (2024)
  10. Down To Earth: Lead in turmeric more than 200 times the limit in parts of India (2024)
  11. Spices Board India: export performance 2025-26 and 2024-25 (2026)
  12. Spices Board India: major item-wise export shares (2026)
  13. Eastern Mirror, citing Spices Board: spice exports hit record US$4.46 billion in FY24 (2024)
  14. IndiaLaw: FSSAI's October 2025 spice manufacturing sweep explained (2025)
  15. Pure Earth: Bihar officials report improved ability to detect adulterated turmeric (2026)
spice adulterationlead chromateturmericethylene oxideFSSAImetanil yellowSudan dyefood safety
Sapta

Sapta (Saptarshi Sarkar) is a mechanical engineer turned marketer in Bengaluru and a solo touring rider. He writes the seven Saptaverse blogs. Work with him or read more of Foodblog.

Keep reading in Foodblog

From the other blogs