Raghubir Singh: the photographer who saw India in colour

When serious photography meant black and white, a Jaipur-born photographer loaded slow colour slide film and argued that Indians had never seen in monochrome. The story of Raghubir Singh, and the case against him.

Ghats along the Ganges at Varanasi with bathers, boats and temple buildings
Photo: Vyacheslav Argenberg, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Raghubir Singh (22 October 1942 to 18 April 1999) was a Jaipur-born photographer who chose colour slide film for serious documentary and street work at a time when the art world treated black and white as the only serious medium. Across more than a dozen books, from Ganga (1974) to A Way into India (2002), he photographed India in dense, layered colour and argued that Indian art had never seen the world in monochrome. The Metropolitan Museum of Art's 2017 retrospective, Modernism on the Ganges, placed him beside Lee Friedlander and Henri Cartier-Bresson.

Key takeaways
  • 1942–1999: born in Jaipur, died in New York at 56, after more than a dozen photobooks.
  • Kodachrome slide film at ISO 25 or 64 set the limits he worked within.
  • 1966: a week with Cartier-Bresson in Jaipur, then a lifelong argument with him over colour.
  • "The Ganges side of modernism" was his own phrase for where his work belonged.
  • Critics such as Ratik Asokan argue his colour turned people into pattern.

He matters to anyone who photographs India today, because he answered a question every phone photographer here faces: what do you do with all this colour?

His answer was to treat colour as the structure of the picture, not a coat of paint on it. Critics have pushed back hard on what he left out, and that argument is part of the story.

1942–1999born in Jaipur, died in New York at 56
13+photobooks in his lifetime, one more after
ISO 25–64speed of the Kodachrome slide films of his era
2017Met Breuer retrospective, Modernism on the Ganges

Who was Raghubir Singh?

Raghubir Singh was born in Jaipur on 22 October 1942 into a Rajput family. As a schoolboy he found Henri Cartier-Bresson's book Beautiful Jaipur, made in 1948, in the family library, and his parents had given him a camera at about 14.

He worked briefly in the tea trade in Calcutta, then turned to photography full time; by the mid-1960s Life magazine ran eight pages of his pictures of student unrest.

The story

In 1966 the photographer Marilyn Silverstone hosted a dinner party at the Rambagh Palace hotel in Jaipur. Among the guests were the young Raghubir Singh and Henri Cartier-Bresson, the man whose book on Jaipur he had found in his family's library as a boy of about 14.

Singh then spent the week with Cartier-Bresson, following Prime Minister Indira Gandhi around Jaipur as she toured the city. He was, in the words of a later review, overjoyed to be spending the week with the Frenchman. From that week he took the habit of walking, waiting and composing in the moment, and the opponent he would argue with, in colour, for the rest of his career.

Julian Cosma, Los Angeles Review of Books: Modernism on the Ganges (2018)

A working life across continents

His working life moved between continents. He lived in Hong Kong, then Paris in the 1970s, and later New York, shooting features for National Geographic and The New York Times while keeping his best work for books.

  • Teaching: the School of Visual Arts, Columbia University and Cooper Union.
  • Honours: the Padma Shri in 1983.
  • Death: a heart attack in New York on 18 April 1999.
Raghubir Singh: life and books1942 born, Jaipur1966 Cartier-Bresson1974 Ganga1983 Padma Shri1988 Calcutta1992 The Ganges1998 River of Colour1999 dies, New York2002 A Way into India2017 Met showDrawn to scale, 1942 to 2017. Dates from the books table and sources below.
Singh's career on one line. The books came in a steady rhythm, each built around one place or route over several years.

Why did Raghubir Singh shoot in colour?

He shot in colour because he believed colour was how India, and Indian art, had always seen. In his essay for River of Colour (1998) he argued that before colonialism and photography, Indian artists did not see in black and white.

He told the story of Mughal court artists receiving an engraved Bible from Jesuit missionaries and filling its stark engravings with colour. If photography had been an Indian invention, he wrote in effect, seeing in colour would never have been treated as a theoretical problem.

He wanted his work placed "on the Ganges side of modernism".Raghubir Singh, quoted in Interview Magazine (2017)

Against the taste of his time

That was a direct challenge to the taste of his time. In the 1960s and 1970s the gatekeepers of art photography, led by the Museum of Modern Art in New York, treated colour as the language of advertising and holiday snaps; MoMA's influential 1967 New Documents show of Winogrand, Arbus and Friedlander was in black and white.

Singh wanted his work placed, in his own words, "on the Ganges side of modernism", not the Seine side of Cartier-Bresson or the East River side of New York.

Munshi Ghat in Varanasi with steps, buildings and the river
Banaras was Singh's recurring subject. Its ghats pack people, ritual, water and painted walls into one frame, the kind of density he built pictures from.Photo: Marcin Białek, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

What film did Raghubir Singh use, and why did it matter?

Singh's colour work is associated with Kodachrome slide film; reviewers of the 2017 retrospective describe his colour work from the late 1960s to the 1990s as Kodachromes. Kodachrome was slow and unforgiving.

The table and chart show the speeds Kodak offered; in the 1970s the standard choices were ISO 25 and ISO 64. Slide film has little latitude, so exposure had to be close to exact, and there was no adjusting colour later in a darkroom the way black-and-white printers could dodge and burn.

Colour that lasts

The payoff was colour that held. Kodachrome had no dye couplers in the emulsion; the dyes were added during the complex K-14 process, which needed several developers and many tanks of chemicals.

Wilhelm Imaging Research's tests, cited widely, estimated that its least stable yellow dye would take about 185 years in dark storage to lose 20%. For a photographer building books meant to last, that durability was part of the argument for colour.

A box of Kodak Kodachrome II colour slide film
Kodachrome II, introduced in 1961 at ASA 25. Slow, fine-grained slide film of this kind set the limits Singh worked within.Photo: Dnalor 01, CC BY-SA 3.0 at, via Wikimedia Commons
Kodachrome film speeds by introduction year
See the data as a table
Film speed (ISO/ASA)
Kodachrome (1935)10
Kodachrome II (1961)25
Kodachrome-X (1962)64
Kodachrome 25 (1974)25
Kodachrome 64 (1974)64

Source: Wikipedia: Kodachrome (Kodak product history) · Kodak stopped making Kodachrome 64 in June 2009; the last lab, Dwayne's Photo in Kansas, ended processing on 30 December 2010.

KodachromeIntroducedSpeedDiscontinued
Kodachrome1935ASA 101962 (16 mm)
Kodachrome II1961ASA 251974
Kodachrome-X1962ASA 641974
Kodachrome 251974ISO 252002
Kodachrome 641974ISO 642009 (135 format)
ISO 64 slide film at f/8 (Sunny 16 arithmetic)Bright sun1/250 sOvercast1/60 sHeavy overcast1/30 sOpen shade, lane1/15 sSunny 16 steps: overcast f/8, heavy overcast f/5.6, open shade f/4 at 1/60 s.Moved to f/8, each step costs shutter speed: 2, 3 and 4 stops.
The stop-by-stop cost of slow colour film in Indian street light, using the Sunny 16 rule from the note above. Open shade in a narrow lane is roughly four stops darker than open sun.

Which books did Raghubir Singh publish?

Singh worked in books, building each around a place or a subject over years. The list below follows his published bibliography; a few dates differ by a year between sources.

YearBookNote
1974Ganga: Sacred River of IndiaFirst book, introduction by Eric Newby
1975CalcuttaThe city where he befriended Satyajit Ray
1980Kumbh MelaThe pilgrimage at Allahabad
1981RajasthanPreface by Satyajit Ray
1988Calcutta: The Home and the StreetReturn to the city with a street photographer's eye
1992The GangesThe river again, two decades on
1994Bombay: Gateway of IndiaWith a conversation with V.S. Naipaul
1995The Grand Trunk RoadThe old trunk highway across north India
1996–97Tamil NaduPreface by R.K. Narayan
1998River of Colour: The India of Raghubir SinghRetrospective book with his essay on colour
2002A Way into IndiaPosthumous; the Ambassador car as a frame

What was the Ambassador car series?

A Way into India, published in 2002 after his death, is built around the Hindustan Ambassador, the car that defined Indian roads for decades. Singh used the car as a camera-like frame, so that the country is seen from inside and around an Indian-made machine.

It is the clearest example of his formal method:

  1. break the scene into panels (windows, mirrors, door frames);
  2. let colour and reflection do the joining;
  3. make the viewer's eye travel from panel to panel.
A white Hindustan Ambassador car parked at the City Palace in Jaipur
A Hindustan Ambassador at the City Palace, Jaipur, Singh's home city. His last book used the car as a frame for the country around it.Photo: Jakub Hałun, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

How did Cartier-Bresson shape him, and where did he break away?

Cartier-Bresson was Singh's first model and the man he argued with for the rest of his life. After their 1966 meeting at the Rambagh Palace dinner, told above, Singh took from him the habit of walking, waiting and composing in the moment.

Two points of departure

He broke away on two points:

  • Colour, which Cartier-Bresson distrusted.
  • Structure. Cartier-Bresson's decisive moment isolates one peak of action; Singh's pictures spread attention across many centres at once, the way a Rajasthani miniature does.
ApproachCartier-BressonRaghubir Singh
MediumBlack and whiteColour slide film
Centre of the frameOne decisive peak of actionMany centres at once
Visual ancestry cited by criticsEuropean painting and geometryMughal and Rajasthani miniatures
Unit of workThe single pictureThe book, built over years

Critics have linked his style to Mughal and Rajasthani painting, and the Met show hung Indian court paintings and work by Friedlander and Anish Kapoor beside his prints to make the point.

The reviewer for The Brooklyn Rail objected to one pairing, his 1975 Holi picture beside Cartier-Bresson's 1947 picture of refugees in Punjab, arguing it diminished both.

The New York influence

Two Americans helped him find his own way. William Gedney, whom Singh met in Banaras in 1969, brought him into New York's street photography circle.

Friedlander's habit of letting reflections, poles and intruding limbs break up the frame shows up in Singh's later work, such as Crawford Market, Bombay (1993) and Pavement Mirror Shop, Howrah (1991), in which his own reflection appears.

Scindia Ghat in Varanasi in morning light with people on the steps
Morning at Scindia Ghat, Varanasi. Singh's Morning on Panchganga Ghat, Benares (1985) spread its figures across the frame like the hands of a clock.Photo: travelwayoflife, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

What is the criticism of Raghubir Singh's work?

The sharpest criticism is that his colour turned people into pattern. Writing in The Caravan in 2018 after the Met show, Ratik Asokan argued that pictures such as Employees, Morvi Palace, Gujarat (1982), where two servants scrubbing a floor become a study in tiles and colour, and a Dharavi portrait, look past the people in them.

He read Singh's celebration of rural vitality in Rajasthan (1981) as a way of avoiding poverty and class, and judged him more impersonal than the American modernists he admired. Asokan still named Pavement Mirror Shop the best picture in the show.

Warmer readings, and an allegation

Other critics were warmer. Julian Cosma in the Los Angeles Review of Books placed Singh between deep engagement with Indian history and international modernism, while questioning his claim that India has no tradition of black and white, citing Buddhist sculpture and Ray's films.

What can a photographer in India learn from Raghubir Singh?

Three practical lessons come straight from his pictures:

  1. Use colour as a structural element. Find the two or three colours that organise a scene and compose around them.
  2. Layer the frame. Foreground, middle and background each doing work, which is how a dense Indian street becomes legible rather than chaotic.
  3. Think in books, not single frames. His projects ran for years on one city or one road.

The Photo Stack Exchange thread on approaching strangers for a natural look in street photography reaches a similar answer to his method: spend time in one place until people stop reacting to the camera.

The thread on making travel photography captivating keeps returning to planning and returning to a subject, which is exactly what Singh did with Banaras over three decades.

For more on the practice, see the street photography guide for India, Indian photographers to know, and for a black-and-white contemporary of the previous generation, Homai Vyarawalla. On how a modern sensor handles the same light, white balance and colour temperature picks up the thread.

What Raghubir Singh Did Not SeeRatik Asokan · The Caravan (Out of Focus essay series) · 2018

A critical essay written after the Met Breuer retrospective closed in January 2018. It reviews about a dozen named photographs from 1976 to 1996 and the curatorial explanations of Singh's colour offered by Mia Fineman, John Baldessari, Partha Mitter and Amit Chaudhuri, which tie it variously to India's vividness, to visual overload or to joy. Its finding is that these readings avoid the question of class, and that Singh's colour often flattens his subjects into decoration. Limit: it is criticism, not empirical research, and it judges the pictures against a social-documentary standard Singh did not claim.

Read the paper (free)
Modernism on the Ganges: Raghubir Singh at the Met BreuerJulian Cosma · Los Angeles Review of Books · 2018

A review of the Met retrospective curated by Mia Fineman that reconstructs Singh's formation: the camera at 14, Cartier-Bresson's Beautiful Jaipur (1948), the 1966 meeting at the Rambagh Palace, friendship with Satyajit Ray in 1960s Calcutta, and William Gedney as his closest American antecedent. It sets out the River of Colour argument, including the story of Mughal artists colouring Jesuit engravings, and tests it against Buddhist sculpture and Ray's black-and-white films. Limit: a review, so it gives no counts of works or print processes.

Read the paper (free)

Questions people ask

Why is Raghubir Singh famous?

He was one of the first photographers anywhere to make colour the core of serious documentary and street photography, beginning in the late 1960s, and he did it with India as his subject across more than a dozen books.

What camera and film did Raghubir Singh use?

He is associated with Kodachrome colour slide film, which in the 1970s came in ISO 25 and ISO 64. Slow film and little exposure latitude shaped how he worked in India's harsh light.

What is River of Colour?

River of Colour: The India of Raghubir Singh is the 1998 retrospective book published with the Art Institute of Chicago's exhibition. It opens with his essay arguing that India has always seen in colour.

Was Raghubir Singh influenced by Cartier-Bresson?

Yes. He discovered Cartier-Bresson's 1948 book on Jaipur as a boy and spent a week with him in Jaipur in 1966, but he broke with him by working in colour and by spreading attention across the whole frame instead of one decisive moment.

Sources

  1. Wikipedia: Raghubir Singh (photographer) (life dates, books, teaching, 2017 allegation)
  2. Julian Cosma, Los Angeles Review of Books: Modernism on the Ganges (2018; source for the 1966 story)
  3. Ratik Asokan, The Caravan: What Raghubir Singh did not see (2018)
  4. Louis Block, The Brooklyn Rail: Deep in the Static (2017)
  5. Interview Magazine: Raghubir Singh's images of India's streets (2017; 85 photographs, dates, the "Ganges side" quote)
  6. The Metropolitan Museum of Art: Modernism on the Ganges (2017)
  7. Wikipedia: Kodachrome (film speeds, K-14, Wilhelm dye-stability figure)
  8. Photo Stack Exchange: How do I approach people for a natural look in street photography?
  9. Photo Stack Exchange: How to make travel photography captivating?
Raghubir Singhcolour photographyKodachromestreet photographyCartier-BressonModernism on the GangesRiver of ColourIndian photographers
Sapta

Sapta (Saptarshi Sarkar) is a mechanical engineer turned marketer in Bengaluru and a solo touring rider. He writes the seven Saptaverse blogs. Work with him or read more of Artblog.

Keep reading in Artblog

From the other blogs