What if chai had never reached India? The maths of a tea-less nation

India drinks about a billion cups of tea a day, a habit barely a century old. Take it away and the stall survives, the milk survives, but swapping in coffee would need four to five and a half times the land India grows tea on.

Milky tea served in a small clay kulhad cup
Photo: Akshay Sanjay Agrawal, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

If chai had never reached India, most Indians would still be drinking what they drank before 1900: milk, buttermilk, sherbets and water, with coffee in the south and salted or spiced tea only in Kashmir, Ladakh and the northeast. The roadside stall would still exist, selling milk or coffee. A straight swap is the part that fails: replacing India's roughly 1.1 billion daily cups of tea with coffee would need about 2.1 million tonnes of roasted coffee a year (at 5 g a cup) and 2.5 to 3.5 million hectares of plantations, four to five and a half times the land India grows tea on today.

Calculated in this post from India's 2024 tea left after exports (1,028.6 million kg, ThePrint, citing Reuters), an assumed 5 g of roasted coffee a cup and a yield of 700 to 1,000 kg of green coffee a hectare, set against the Tea Board tea area of 6.35 lakh hectares. The workings are in the sections below.

Key takeaways
  • Over 90% of India's tea crop was still exported in 1930; Indians were not yet tea drinkers.
  • 1935: planters sat on more than 100 million pounds of unsold tea, so the Indian Tea Market Expansion Board set out to sell it to Indians.
  • About 1,029 million kg: tea left in India in 2024 after exports, about 1.1 billion cups a day at 2.5 g a cup (my calculation).
  • About 7% of India's milk, roughly 17 million tonnes a year, goes into chai on my central estimate.
  • 6.35 lakh hectares are under tea (Tea Board, March 2025); a coffee swap would need about 25 to 35 lakh.

Chai feels ancient. It is not. The plant grew wild in Assam, and Himalayan communities drank tea traded over the mountains, but the sweet, milky, boiled cup that defines the Indian day was manufactured by a marketing campaign in the 1930s and 1940s. The full history is in how India became a chai nation. This post runs the counterfactual with numbers.

When did Indians actually start drinking tea?

Mostly after 1935. Tea was planted in Assam from the 1830s for export to Britain, and for a century Indians drank very little of it.

The story

By 1935 the Great Depression had crushed world tea prices, and planters in India were sitting on more than 100 million pounds of tea nobody abroad would buy. The industry's Tea Cess Committee was reorganised that year as the Indian Tea Market Expansion Board, and its job was to make Indians into customers. It sent propagandists out in the hundreds. At Howrah station in Calcutta they handed out free cups of tea and sold paper packets for one pice. Vans fitted with kettles toured the towns of Bengal brewing tea in public, and millions of free cups were poured. An earlier push under Viceroy Curzon, begun in 1901, had been abandoned in 1904. This one worked.

ThePrint: excerpt from Mohona Kanjilal, Taste of Time: A Food History of Calcutta (2021)
Nationalizing the Consumption of Tea for the Hindi Reader: The Indian Tea Market Expansion Board's advertisement campaignShobna Nijhawan, York University · Modern Asian Studies 51(5), pp. 1229-1252 · 2017

Nijhawan studied the Board's tea advertisements in a Hindi literary magazine in the decade before Independence. Because tea drinking was not common among Indians in the first half of the twentieth century, the ads spent their space teaching how to prepare tea "properly" and when to drink it, and they cast the middle-class housewife, along with working women, aristocrats and film actresses, as the face of a modern, healthy, national drink. The point for this post: chai's place in Indian life was deliberately built, with a method. The limit: I could read only the abstract; the article is paywalled, and it covers one Hindi magazine, not the whole campaign.

Read the abstract (free)
1834Tea Committee:Assam trials1881Indian TeaAssociation1888: exports toBritain pass China1903tea cess1930: over 90%still exported1935: MarketExpansion Board1954: TeaBoard of IndiaA century of growing tea for Britain, then about twenty years of selling it to India.
How tea became chai. Dates from Jagjeet Lally (1834, 1888), Mohona Kanjilal via ThePrint (1881, 1903, 1930, 1935) and the Tea Board (1954).
Rows of tea bushes stretching across the Sensuwa Tea Estate in Jorhat, Assam
A tea estate in Jorhat, Assam. For its first hundred years the Assam crop was grown for London, not for Indian kitchens.Photo: JyotiPN, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Would there be no tea in India at all?

No: the mountains would still drink it. Tea reached the Himalayan fringe over trade routes long before the British planted Assam, so a no-chai India would still have tea, just not where most Indians live.

Tea and Empire in the Asian Interior, c. 1750-1900Jagjeet Lally, University College London · in Gupta and Hossain (eds.), Across Colonial Lines: Commodities, Networks and Empire Building, Bloomsbury, pp. 55-80 · 2023

Using British archives in London, New Delhi and Yangon, Lally follows tea through the continental interior rather than the sea route to Britain. He notes that the East India Company set up its Tea Committee in 1834 to start trials in Assam, that Indian tea overtook Chinese tea in Britain by 1888, and that very few Indians drank tea until the start of the twentieth century. He also records that Kangra planters in the 1850s pinned their hopes on Kashmiris in Punjab because they were already tea drinkers, and that brick tea moved to Tibet by mule caravan. The limit: it is about trade and empire, so it says little about everyday consumption numbers.

Read the chapter (free, author's copy)

So the counterfactual has three regions:

  • Kashmir and Ladakh: salted pink noon chai and spiced kahwa survive, because they came over the mountains, not from Assam.
  • The northeast: where the plant grows wild, a small local tea culture is likely to survive.
  • The plains and the south: no mass tea habit. This is where most Indians live, and where the real change happens.
A cup of pink Kashmiri noon chai
Kashmiri noon chai, salted and pink. Tea arrived in Kashmir along Central Asian routes, so it would likely be there even without the Assam plantations.Photo: Naryiitmandi, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

How much chai does India drink today?

About 1.1 billion cups a day, by my calculation from Tea Board production and export figures. Here is the working.

Executive Summary of Study on Domestic Consumption of Tea in IndiaTea Board of India · official consumption study (pan-India household, institutional and trade survey) · 2018

The Board's survey of households across urban and rural India, socio-economic classes and regions, plus hotels, canteens and traders, found that about 88% of households drink tea, about 64% of the total population drinks it, and more than 80% of households prefer milk tea with sugar. Over 80% of people drink it before or with breakfast. Consumption is skewed north and west: the north takes about 32% of domestic tea, the west 31%, the east including the northeast 19%, and the south 18%. The limit: the summary does not publish its sample size or per-cup quantities.

Read the summary (free)

The worked derivation: from kilograms to cups

  1. Apparent domestic use = production minus exports (imports are small and ignored). With 2024 production of 1,284.78 million kg (Tea Board, via Reuters) and exports of 256.17 million kg (Asia News Network):
    \[ C = P - X = 1284.78 - 256.17 = 1028.6\ \text{million kg/yr} \]

    Calculated in this post from 2024 production of 1,284.78 million kg (ThePrint, citing Reuters) minus exports of 256.17 million kg (Asia News Network). Imports are ignored.

  2. Cups per day, with \( g \) grams of leaf per cup. ISO 3103 brews 2 g per 100 ml; Indian chai is boiled stronger, so I use \( g = 2.5 \) g as my central estimate:
    \[ N = \frac{C}{365\,g} = \frac{1.0286\times10^{12}\ \text{g}}{365 \times 2.5\ \text{g}} \approx 1.13\times10^{9}\ \text{cups/day} \]
  3. Milk in those cups. With 80% milk tea (Tea Board) and \( m = 50 \) ml of milk a cup (my estimate):
    \[ M = N \times 0.8 \times 0.05\ \text{L} \approx 4.5\times10^{7}\ \text{L/day} \approx 17\ \text{Mt/yr} \]
    India produced 239.3 million tonnes of milk in 2023-24, so chai takes about 7%.
  4. Sensitivity. At 2 g a cup, 1.41 billion cups; at 3 g, 0.94 billion. Milk at 30 to 80 ml a cup gives 4% to 11% of national milk. Sugar at 5 g in 80% of cups is about 1.6 million tonnes a year (my estimate).

    Calculated in this post from the 1,028.6 million kg above, at ISO 3103's 2 g a cup and an assumed 3 g: 1.0286 × 10¹² g ÷ (365 × 2) ≈ 1.41 billion, ÷ (365 × 3) ≈ 0.94 billion.

Input per day (central case)Per cupAll India, per dayAll India, per year
Tea leaf2.5 g2.8 million kg1,029 million kg
Milk (80% of cups)50 ml45 million litresabout 17 million tonnes
Sugar (80% of cups)5 g4,500 tonnesabout 1.6 million tonnes
Cups1about 1.13 billionabout 411 billion
Where India's tea is drunk, by region
See the data as a table
Share of domestic consumption (%)
North32
West31
East incl. Northeast19
South18

Source: Tea Board of India, Study on Domestic Consumption of Tea (2018)

What would Indians drink instead?

Whatever was already in the house. Without the 1930s campaign, the morning drink of the plains would most plausibly be milk, buttermilk or hot water, with coffee spreading in the south, where it was already established. The named idea here is path dependence, which the economist W. Brian Arthur formalised in 1989: small historical events, like a surplus that needed a buyer, can lock a society into one option that then reinforces itself.

Option 1: swap every cup for filter coffee

This is the obvious replacement, and the numbers say it cannot happen cup for cup.

  1. Coffee needed. With \( c = 5 \) g of roasted coffee per cup (my estimate for a South Indian tumbler) and 1.13 billion cups:
    \[ R = N \times c \times 365 = 1.13\times10^{9} \times 5\ \text{g} \times 365 \approx 2.06\ \text{Mt roasted/yr} \]
  2. Green beans, allowing about 16% weight lost in roasting (my estimate):
    \[ G = 1.19\,R \approx 2.45\ \text{Mt/yr} \]
  3. Land, at an assumed yield \( y \) of 700 to 1,000 kg of green coffee per hectare:
    \[ A = \frac{G}{y} = \frac{2.45\times10^{9}\ \text{kg}}{700\ \text{to}\ 1000\ \text{kg/ha}} \approx 2.5\ \text{to}\ 3.5\ \text{million ha} \]
  4. Compare. India's whole coffee crop was about 3.7 lakh tonnes in 2024-25 and domestic use about 91,000 tonnes in 2023. The swap needs about 27 times today's coffee drinking, and land four to five and a half times the 6.35 lakh hectares under tea. At 7 to 10 g a cup, it needs 3.4 to 7 million hectares.

Coffee also grows only in a narrow band of Indian hills, mostly in Karnataka, Kerala and Tamil Nadu, under shade. Finding 25 to 35 lakh hectares there would mean converting a vast area of hill forest and farmland. Tea won partly because it yields about 2,000 kg per hectare, more than twice what coffee gives on my assumed yields.

Land to supply India's daily cupTea today0.64 million haCoffee swap, 1,000 kg/ha2.5 million haCoffee swap, 700 kg/ha3.5 million haSquare areas drawn to scale. 1.13 billion cups a day, 5 g of coffee a cup.
Tea is a land-efficient caffeine crop. Replacing it with coffee cup for cup would need four to five and a half times the area.
South Indian filter coffee poured between a steel tumbler and davara
South Indian filter coffee. In a chai-less India it would likely spread further north, but not cup for cup. The full story is in the history of filter coffee.Photo: Nizil Shah, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Option 2: a glass of milk instead

If each chai became a 200 ml glass of milk, India would need \( 1.13\times10^{9} \times 0.2 \approx 2.3\times10^{8} \) litres a day, about 82 million tonnes a year, or 34% of national milk output. That is far beyond what the dairy system could spare, even after Operation Flood. A cup of chai is in fact a milk-saving device: it stretches about 50 ml of milk into a full, hot, sweet drink.

Option 3: buttermilk and the old drinks

Buttermilk is the surprising match. Thin chaas is curd diluted several times with water, so a glass uses roughly as much milk as a cup of chai, by my estimate. It is cold, though, and India's morning drink is hot.

Replacement for 1.13 billion daily cupsKey input needed per yearCompared with todayFeasible?
Filter coffee, 5 g a cup2.45 Mt green coffeeabout 27 times India's coffee useNo, land-limited
Glass of milk, 200 mlabout 82 Mt milk34% of all milk producedNo, milk-limited
Chaas, about 50 ml milk a glassabout 17 Mt milksame as chai uses nowYes, but cold
Mix: coffee south, milk and chaas northabout 0.3 Mt coffee plus milkcoffee use triplesYes, most likely

The last row is my estimate of the realistic outcome: the south's coffee share grows maybe three-fold, and the north drinks less of anything hot.

A tall glass of plain white lassi
Lassi and its thinner cousin chaas were the everyday dairy drinks of the north before tea. Chaas uses about as much milk per glass as a cup of chai.Photo: Kyu3a, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Would the chai stall still exist?

Yes, as a different shop. The stall's economics never depended on tea. It depends on a cheap, hot, quickly served drink that justifies standing on a corner for five minutes. That is what cafés, paan shops and milk booths already sell.

  • In the south: it would be a coffee stall, as many already are.
  • In the north: most likely a milk and lassi shop, with boiled sweet milk in winter.
  • At stations: the Expansion Board worked railway stations, where crowds wait. Waiting crowds would still buy something hot.
The stall was never about the leaf. It was about a hot, cheap reason to stop.The working of this post

What does this say about how traditions are made?

That a tradition can be under a hundred years old and still feel eternal. The historian Eric Hobsbawm called this the invention of tradition: practices that look ancient but were created, often recently and on purpose, and then repeated until they seem natural. Chai fits almost perfectly, with a twist. It was invented by a sales campaign, and then Indians changed it into something the campaign never designed: boiled, milky, spiced, served in a kulhad. For why tea and not coffee won the north, see why tea is more popular than coffee in India.

So: what if chai had never reached India?

  1. History: mass tea drinking dates from the 1930s campaign; before it, over 90% of the crop left the country.
  2. Scale: today's habit is about 1.1 billion cups and 17 million tonnes of milk a year.
  3. Coffee swap: needs 2.5 to 3.5 million hectares, four to five and a half times the tea area. Not possible on India's coffee land.
  4. Milk swap: needs a third of national milk. Not possible.
  5. Realistic outcome: a coffee-drinking south, a milk-and-chaas north, and tea in the Himalaya.
Verdict: possible

A chai-less India is entirely possible; India got by without a mass tea habit until the 1930s. What is impossible is a like-for-like replacement: swapping 1.13 billion daily cups for coffee needs about 2.45 million tonnes of green coffee and 2.5 to 3.5 million hectares, against 6.35 lakh hectares of tea today. So the country would drink less hot caffeine, more milk and buttermilk, and more coffee in the south, and the stall on the corner would sell whatever was hot and cheap.

What if next?

Over on the food blog: the history of tea in Assam. More everyday questions live on the Kyun page.

Questions people ask

Did Indians drink tea before the British?

In the Himalayan fringe, yes: Kashmiris were already tea drinkers when British planters in Kangra looked for buyers in the 1850s, and tea moved to Tibet by caravan. On the plains, mass tea drinking dates from the twentieth century, especially the 1930s campaigns.

Why did the British want Indians to drink tea?

Because export markets collapsed in the Depression. By 1935 planters had over 100 million pounds of unsold tea, and the Indian Tea Market Expansion Board was set up to create a home market.

How much tea does India drink?

About 1,029 million kg in 2024 by production minus exports, which is roughly 1.1 billion cups a day at 2.5 g per cup. About 64% of Indians drink tea, according to the Tea Board.

Could coffee have become India's national drink?

Not cup for cup. Replacing chai would need about 2.45 million tonnes of green coffee a year, around 27 times what India drinks now, grown on 2.5 to 3.5 million hectares of hill land.

What did Indians drink before chai?

Water, milk, buttermilk, lassi, sherbets and regional drinks such as kanji, with coffee in parts of the south. Which one dominated depended on region and season.

Sources

  1. ThePrint: excerpt from Mohona Kanjilal, Taste of Time (2021) (source for the story, 1881, 1903, 1930 and 1935)
  2. Nijhawan, Modern Asian Studies: Nationalizing the Consumption of Tea for the Hindi Reader (2017) (source for the ad campaign's method)
  3. Lally: Tea and Empire in the Asian Interior, c. 1750-1900 (2023) (source for 1834, 1888 and Kashmiri tea drinkers)
  4. Tea Board of India: Executive Summary of Study on Domestic Consumption of Tea (2018) (source for 88%, 64%, 80% milk tea and regional shares)
  5. Tea Board of India: State-wise tea growers and tea area (as on 31 March 2025) (source for 6,35,365 ha)
  6. ThePrint (Reuters): India's 2024 tea output drops 7.8% (2025) (source for 1,284.78 million kg)
  7. Asia News Network: India records highest-ever tea exports in 2025 (2026) (source for 256.17 million kg exported in 2024)
  8. Drishti IAS summary of Basic Animal Husbandry Statistics 2024 (2024) (source for 239.3 million tonnes of milk)
  9. Drishti IAS (The Hindu): India's 10-year coffee growth plan (2024) (source for 3.7 lakh tonnes of coffee)
  10. The Tribune (ANI): India becomes 7th largest coffee producer (2025) (source for 91,000 tonnes domestic coffee use)
  11. Wikipedia: ISO 3103 (source for the 2 g per 100 ml standard brew)
  12. Arthur, Economic Journal: Competing Technologies, Increasing Returns, and Lock-In by Historical Events (1989) (source for path dependence)
  13. Wikipedia: The Invention of Tradition (Hobsbawm and Ranger, 1983) (source for invented tradition)
  14. Wikipedia: Tea Board of India (source for 1954)
  15. Business Today: FSSAI cracks down on fake teas (2025)
chaiIndian Tea Market Expansion Boardinvented traditionpath dependenceTea Board of Indiafilter coffeemilkCamellia sinensis
Sapta

Sapta (Saptarshi Sarkar) is a mechanical engineer turned marketer in Bengaluru and a solo touring rider. He writes the seven Saptaverse blogs. Work with him or read more of Whyblog.

Keep reading in Whyblog

From the other blogs