AI Overviews and ChatGPT search choose sources in four steps: they rewrite your question into several sub-queries (Google calls this query fan-out), retrieve pages for each from a search index, pick the passages that answer a sub-question most directly, and attach those pages as citations. So a page must first be indexed and rank for at least one sub-query, then contain a passage that states the answer plainly. In the main controlled study, adding statistics and quotations raised a source's visibility in generated answers by up to about 40%.
- Query fan-out: one question becomes many searches, and each sub-query is a separate chance to be cited.
- 18% of Google searches showed an AI summary in Pew's March 2025 sample; 60% of questions starting with who, what, when or why did.
- 88% of summaries cited three or more sources, so you compete for one of about three to five slots.
- 1% of visits clicked a link inside the summary: a citation is mostly a brand impression.
- Up to about 40% more visibility from adding statistics and quotations (GEO paper, KDD 2024); keyword stuffing scored below baseline.
- 51.5% of generated sentences were fully supported by their citations in a 2023 audit.
The Reddit threads on this topic split into two camps. One says generative engine optimisation (GEO) is a new discipline with its own tactics; the other says it is mostly SEO with a new name. The evidence supports a bit of both.
Retrieval still runs on a search index, so ranking matters. But the final step selects passages, not pages, and that step responds to how you write.
This post walks through the pipeline using Google's own descriptions, Pew Research Center's click data on 68,879 real searches, and three research papers that measured what generative engines cite.
How do answer engines build an answer?
Answer engines build an answer by turning one question into many searches, reading the top results for each, and writing a summary grounded in the passages they retrieved. Google described this publicly at I/O on 20 May 2025: AI Mode "uses query fan-out", splitting a question into subtopics and issuing many searches at once, and its Deep Search mode can run hundreds of searches before writing a cited report.
The four steps
- Fan-out. The question is rewritten into several sub-queries.
- Retrieve. Each sub-query pulls top pages from a search index.
- Select passages. The model picks the passages that answer each sub-question most directly.
- Write and cite. The answer is written from those passages, with the pages attached as citations.
Two consequences follow:
- Sub-query wins count. A page can earn a citation for a sub-query it ranks for even if it doesn't rank for the head term. A page on "LTV to CAC ratio for Indian D2C" can be cited inside an answer to "how to scale a D2C brand".
- Passages beat pages. The selection step judges passages, so a strong page with the key fact buried in paragraph nine competes poorly against a weaker page that states the fact in one sentence.
One commenter in the r/digital_marketing thread made the same point bluntly: Perplexity, ChatGPT search and Google AI Mode mostly retrieve from an existing search index and then pull answers out of it, so classic SEO is still the entry ticket. The research below agrees, and adds what happens after entry.
A week after Google rolled AI Overviews out to everyone in the US in May 2024, screenshots spread of the feature telling a user whose cheese kept sliding off a pizza to mix about an eighth of a cup of glue into the sauce. Reporters traced the advice to a joke comment on Reddit's r/Pizza forum, roughly a decade old. Another viral answer, to "How many rocks should I eat?", came from satire republished on a geology software firm's site. On 30 May 2024 Google's vice-president for Search, Liz Reid, explained the failure in a company post: on rarely searched questions with little good content, a data void, the system had lifted sarcastic forum posts and satire as if they were advice. Google said it made more than a dozen technical fixes, including limits on user-generated content and on satire.
Google: AI Overviews, about last week (Liz Reid, 30 May 2024)The lesson for a brand is the pipeline in miniature: the engine retrieved a page that matched the sub-query, then quoted the passage that answered it most directly, whether or not it was true. The passage that states the answer plainly is the one that gets lifted.
How often do AI Overviews appear, and for which queries?
AI Overviews appeared on about 18% of Google searches in Pew Research Center's March 2025 sample, and the rate rises sharply with query length. Pew tracked 900 US adults' browsing and logged 68,879 unique searches; 12,593 of them produced an AI summary.
See the data as a table
| Searches with an AI summary (%) | |
|---|---|
| 1–2 words | 8 |
| Noun + verb | 36 |
| Starts with a question word | 60 |
| 10+ words | 53 |
Source: Pew Research Center, browsing data from 900 US adults, March 2025 · Overall, 18% of the 68,879 searches produced a summary. Categories overlap.
Questions starting with who, what, when or why triggered a summary 60% of the time; one- and two-word searches only 8%. That tells you where to aim:
- Short commercial keywords ("CRM software") mostly still show classic results.
- Long, specific questions ("which CRM works for a 20-person Indian B2B sales team with WhatsApp") are where generative answers live, and where fan-out has the most sub-queries to cite.
How many slots there are
The median summary in Pew's data was 67 words, and 88% of summaries cited three or more sources. Only 1% cited a single source.
An AI Overview is a short paragraph with a shortlist, so you are competing for one of roughly three to five slots per answer.
Do people click AI Overviews citations?
Rarely. Pew found users clicked a link inside the AI summary on just 1% of visits to pages that had one, and clicked any traditional result on 8% of those visits, against 15% when no summary appeared.
See the data as a table
| Page had an AI summary (% of visits) | No AI summary (% of visits) | |
|---|---|---|
| Clicked a traditional result | 8 | 15 |
| Clicked a link in the AI summary | 1 | |
| Ended the browsing session | 26 | 16 |
Users also ended their browsing session on 26% of visits to pages with a summary, against 16% without. So being cited is mostly a brand impression, not a traffic source.
Ahrefs' March 2025 study of about 35,000 websites makes the same point from the other end: AI assistants sent about 0.1% of total referral traffic, and Google search sent 345 times more traffic than ChatGPT, Perplexity and Gemini combined.
Google's counterpoint, from its May 2025 I/O post, is that in big markets including the US and India, AI Overviews drive more than a 10% increase in usage of Google for the queries that show them. More searches, fewer clicks per search.
Use this to check what you just read: plug in the monthly searches behind your sub-questions and see how many citation impressions and clicks that turns into at Pew's rates.
What AI Overview citations are worth to you
| Measure | Figure | Source and date |
|---|---|---|
| Searches with an AI summary | 18% | Pew, Mar 2025 |
| Summaries citing 3+ sources | 88% | Pew, Mar 2025 |
| Clicks on links inside the summary | 1% of visits | Pew, Mar 2025 |
| AI assistants' share of referral traffic | 0.1% | Ahrefs, 35K sites, Mar 2025 |
| Google vs top three AI assistants, referral traffic | 345 : 1 | Ahrefs, Mar 2025 |
| Usage lift on queries showing AI Overviews | 10%+ (US, India) | Google, May 2025 |

Which kinds of sources get cited most?
Government sites, encyclopaedias and large platforms are over-represented, and news is a small slice. In Pew's data, .gov sites made up 6% of sources in AI summaries against 2% in standard results, while Wikipedia, YouTube and Reddit together made up 15% of AI summary sources and 17% of standard results.
| Source type | Share of AI summary sources | Share of standard results |
|---|---|---|
| .gov sites | 6% | 2% |
| Wikipedia, YouTube and Reddit together | 15% | 17% |
A July 2025 paper by Kai-Cheng Yang analysed more than 366,000 citations from 65,000 responses in the AI Search Arena, covering models from OpenAI, Perplexity and Google. About 9% of citations pointed to news sources, and those were concentrated in a small number of outlets.
Models from the same provider cited similar sources; different providers had distinct preferences. For a brand, the practical reading is that each engine has its own habits, and you should test your visibility in each rather than assuming one result generalises. The most cited domains in AI search post ranks the domains themselves.
The study uses the AI Search Arena, a head-to-head evaluation site, covering over 24,000 conversations, 65,000 responses and more than 366,000 citations from OpenAI, Perplexity and Google models. About 9% of citations referenced news outlets, heavily concentrated among a few of them; low-credibility sources were rarely cited, and providers differed from each other while their own models behaved alike. Limit: Arena users are not typical searchers, and the analysis covers news citations in depth, not brand or commercial sites.
Read the paper (free)What actually raises a page's chance of being cited?
Adding concrete statistics, quotations from named sources and citations to evidence raised visibility the most in the only large controlled test, while keyword stuffing made things worse. That test is the GEO paper by Pranjal Aggarwal and five co-authors, published at KDD 2024.
They built GEO-bench, 10,000 queries across 25 domains, rewrote source pages using nine methods, and measured how much of each source made it into generated answers. The results below are the paper's headline comparisons on its benchmark, plus its live test on Perplexity.
| Method | What it changes | Measured effect |
|---|---|---|
| Quotation addition | Adds quotes from relevant named sources | Among the top methods, up to about 41% gain in position-adjusted word count; about 22% on Perplexity |
| Statistics addition | Replaces vague claims with numbers | Among the top methods; up to 37% gain in subjective impression on Perplexity |
| Cite sources | Adds citations to credible sources | +115% visibility for a site ranked 5th; -30% for the site ranked 1st |
| Fluency and easy-to-understand | Cleaner, simpler prose | Moderate gains |
| Keyword stuffing | Repeats query terms | Below baseline (17.8 vs 19.5); about 10% below baseline on Perplexity |
The authors define visibility metrics for sources inside generated answers and test nine rewriting methods on GEO-bench, 10,000 queries across nine datasets and 25 domains. Quotation and statistics addition gave the largest gains, up to about 40% in visibility; keyword stuffing underperformed the unoptimised page. Gains were largest for lower-ranked sources: citing sources lifted a fifth-ranked site's visibility by 115% while cutting the top-ranked site's by 30%. Limit: most tests use a simulated engine built on a GPT model, and the live Perplexity test was smaller, so effect sizes on today's AI Overviews may differ.
Read the paper (free)The rank effect
The rank effect is the most useful finding for a smaller brand:
- If you already rank first, rewriting for GEO can cost you share because you were already being quoted.
- If you rank fifth for a sub-query, adding a sourced number and a named quote can more than double how much of your page the engine uses.
It also explains a pattern in the r/SEO thread on AEO results: the most common reply was that good GEO results are mostly good SEO results, and very few replies offered numbers at all.

Are AI citations accurate?
Often not fully. In an audit of four generative search engines, only about 51.5% of generated sentences were fully supported by their citations, and about 74.5% of citations actually supported the sentence they were attached to.
The researchers had humans audit answers from Bing Chat, NeevaAI, Perplexity and YouChat across a diverse set of queries. On average, 51.5% of generated sentences were fully supported by citations (citation recall) and 74.5% of citations supported their sentence (citation precision). Limit: the engines audited are 2023 versions that have since changed, so treat the numbers as a baseline, not a current rate.
Read the paper (free)How should an Indian brand write pages that get cited?
Write pages that rank for specific sub-questions and state each answer in a self-contained, sourced sentence near the top of its section. Then make sure the pages are indexable and fast, because nothing downstream works if retrieval can't fetch them.
- Map the fan-out. For each money query, list the 5 to 10 sub-questions an engine would search: cost, comparison, eligibility, risks, alternatives, Indian context. Each needs a page or a clearly headed section.
- Lead with the answer. Open each section with one or two sentences a model could quote alone, with the number and the year in them.
- Add your own data. Statistics and named quotes were the strongest levers in the GEO tests. Original numbers (your survey, your pricing data, your benchmarks) are the hardest for competitors to copy.
- Cite primary sources. Link the RBI circular, the ministry release, the paper. It helped lower-ranked sites most in the GEO paper.
- Cover Indian languages. AI Mode added Hindi in September 2025 and seven more Indian languages in October 2025. A Hindi or Tamil page that answers the sub-question is a separate retrieval candidate.
- Skip the tricks. Keyword stuffing scored below baseline. In my view, hidden prompt text and padded FAQ blocks are the 2026 version of the same mistake.
This is not a break from search history so much as its latest turn; the history of SEO and Google's updates shows the same pattern of tactics rising and being neutralised. If you would rather have someone build this for your brand, the hire page explains how I take on projects.
What's new
- Google brings ads to AI Mode in India as part of a 10-country first phase Beebom, Oct 2026
- Search Live launches in India; AI Mode adds Bengali, Kannada, Malayalam, Marathi, Tamil, Telugu and Urdu TechCrunch, Oct 2025
- Google AI Mode adds Hindi among five new languages TechCrunch, Sep 2025
- Pew: Google users click links half as often when an AI summary appears Pew Research Center, Jul 2025
Questions people ask
Do I need to rank on Google to appear in AI Overviews?
In practice, yes, for at least one sub-query. AI Overviews and AI Mode retrieve from Google's index via fan-out searches, so a page that never appears in results for any related query has little chance of being cited. You don't need to rank first for the head term, though; the GEO paper found lower-ranked pages gained the most from better writing.
Does ChatGPT search use Google or Bing results?
OpenAI has not published a full description of its retrieval stack, so treat confident claims either way with caution. What is consistent across engines is the pattern: a search step fetches candidate pages, and the model cites the passages it used. Being indexed by the major search engines and allowing their crawlers is the safe baseline.
Is GEO just SEO with a new name?
Partly. Retrieval is still search, so indexing, relevance and authority still decide who gets in. What is new is the passage-selection step, which rewards quotable sentences with statistics and named sources, and the fact that one answer cites three to five sources instead of showing ten blue links.
Is it worth chasing AI citations if they bring so few clicks?
For pure traffic, not yet: Ahrefs measured AI assistants at about 0.1% of referral traffic in early 2025. For brand, yes, because the summary shapes what a buyer believes before they click anything. Track citations as share of voice and judge them against branded search and direct traffic, not referral clicks.
Sources
- Pew Research Center: Google users are less likely to click on links when an AI summary appears (2025)
- Aggarwal et al.: GEO, Generative Engine Optimization, KDD (2024)
- Liu, Zhang, Liang: Evaluating Verifiability in Generative Search Engines, Findings of EMNLP (2023)
- Yang: News Source Citing Patterns in AI Search Systems, arXiv (2025)
- Google: AI in Search, going beyond information to intelligence (I/O 2025) (2025)
- Ahrefs: AI traffic research, 35,000 websites (2025)
- Google: AI Overviews, about last week, by Liz Reid (2024; source for the glue and rocks story)
- Popular Science: Google's AI Overview tells you to eat glue (2024; the Reddit r/Pizza origin)
- TechCrunch: Google's AI Mode adds five new languages including Hindi (2025)
- TechCrunch: Search Live comes to India, AI Mode gets more languages (2025)
- Beebom: Google AI Mode is getting ads in India (2026)

