Pantone is still worth it when a brand colour has to look the same on every carton, label and sign printed by different vendors, especially on offset or flexo presses, or when the colour sits outside what CMYK can print. It is often not worth it for short digital runs, where 7-colour CMYKOGV printing now reproduces most Pantone colours to within a just-noticeable difference. Since Adobe dropped most Pantone libraries in 2022, the honest answer is: specify a Pantone for the brand, then decide per job whether to mix the spot ink or simulate it.
- Spot colour is a premixed ink on its own plate; process colour is built from CMYK dots.
- 85% of in-gamut Pantone colours hit ΔE under 2.5 on a 7-colour flexo press (Pune, 2019).
- ΔE00 1.55 to 3.49 was the average spot-colour error in the Toronto study, depending on software.
- 3 books are all that stayed inside Adobe apps after the 2022 split; the rest need Pantone Connect.
- Metallics, fluorescents and opaque white still need a real spot ink.
"Should my logo have a Pantone?" is one of the first questions a small business asks a designer. The answer usually given is either "always" or "that's old school", and both skip the mechanics.
This post explains what a spot colour physically is, what changed between Pantone and Adobe, what the 2019 to 2022 print studies show about extended-gamut printing, and a practical rule for when to pay for a separate ink.
What is a spot colour, physically?
A spot colour is an ink mixed to a recipe before printing and laid down as one solid layer from its own plate, while a process colour is built on press from tiny halftone dots of cyan, magenta, yellow and black. Pantone's Matching System supplies the recipes: each colour is a formula of 13 base pigments plus black, so a printer anywhere can mix "PANTONE 185 C" from the same starting inks.
The recipe book began as a tidy-up job. In 1956 the brothers Mervin and Jesse Levine, who ran M & J Levine Advertising in New York, hired a recent Hofstra University graduate, Lawrence Herbert, as a "colour matching specialist" after he passed their colour sorting test. Herbert used his chemistry training to systematise the firm's sprawling pigment stock and the way it mixed coloured inks.
By 1962 the ink and printing division he ran was making money, while the commercial-display side was about $50,000 in debt. Herbert then bought the company's technological assets from the Levines for $50,000. Fewer base pigments, mixed to written formulas, is still the whole idea of a Pantone number.
Wikipedia: Pantone, company historyThat difference between a mixed ink and a dot pattern shows up in three ways:
- Smoothness. A spot ink is an unscreened layer, so large flat areas look even with no dot pattern.
- Saturation. It can be more saturated than any CMYK mix, because it is a single pigment rather than overlapping dots that absorb more light.
- Reach. It can be a colour CMYK cannot make at all: metallics, fluorescents, opaque whites and many bright oranges, greens, blues and violets.
| Property | Spot colour | Process colour (CMYK) |
|---|---|---|
| How it is made | Premixed ink, one plate | Halftone dots of four inks |
| Flat areas | Even, no dot pattern | Visible rosette under a loupe |
| Metallic or fluorescent | Possible | Not possible |
| Extra cost | One more press unit and wash-up per colour | None beyond the four inks |
| Photos in the same job | Need CMYK as well | Handled by the same four inks |
What do the C and U after a Pantone number mean?
C means the swatch was printed on coated paper and U on uncoated paper, using the same ink formula. The ink looks different because uncoated paper absorbs more ink into its fibres and scatters more light, so the same recipe appears duller and darker.
That is why a brand guide should list both, and why "185 C" on your business card stock will not match the swatch unless the card is coated.
Pantone also publishes CMYK simulations of its spot colours (the Pantone + CMYK Coated and Uncoated books, still bundled in Adobe apps). Those are not the spot ink; they are the closest four-colour build, and for saturated colours the gap is large. Our guide to RGB vs CMYK print colour explains why the CMYK gamut is smaller than both screens and spot inks.
What changed between Pantone and Adobe in 2022?
From August 2022, Adobe stopped updating the Pantone colour books in Photoshop, Illustrator and InDesign. By the end of that year only three remained:
- Pantone + CMYK Coated;
- Pantone + CMYK Uncoated;
- Pantone + Metallics Coated.
Full access to the solid spot libraries now comes through Pantone's own Pantone Connect plug-in, reported at $15 a month in November 2022.
That black-swatch problem caused the outcry. Adobe's guidance was that existing files would mostly keep working.
In practice, the change pushed many designers to store brand colours as Lab or sRGB values alongside the Pantone name, which is better practice anyway. A Pantone number is a name, while Lab values are a measurement any colour-managed workflow can use.
| Option | What you get | Cost and catch |
|---|---|---|
| Pantone Connect subscription | All current spot libraries inside Adobe apps, Lab values, conversions | About $15 a month (2022 price); a yearly plan is cheaper |
| Bundled Adobe books | Pantone + CMYK Coated and Uncoated, Metallics Coated | Free with Creative Cloud, but CMYK simulations, not solid spot colours |
| Physical Formula Guide | Printed ink swatches to check under daylight | One-time cost; fades with light and age, so it needs replacing |
| Lab values from the brand guide | Measured colour any printer's software can target | Free to use; needs a spectrophotometer to verify |
Can CMYK or extended gamut replace spot colours?
For most colours, extended gamut can; plain CMYK often cannot. Extended Colour Gamut (ECG) printing adds orange, green and violet to CMYK (CMYKOGV) and keeps all seven inks on press, so many spot colours are built from fixed process inks without washing up a unit for each job.
What the print studies measured
Two peer-reviewed studies on narrow-web label presses measured how close it gets.
A team from P. V. G.'s College of Engineering and Technology in Pune ran a Nilpeter FB-430 flexo press with UV inks on polypropylene, characterised it for CMYK to ISO 12647-2 (GRACoL 2013) and for orange, green and violet to ISO 20654, then printed a verification chart of 799 Pantone Solid Coated patches. Of the Pantone colours that fell inside the CMYKOGV gamut but outside plain CMYK, 85% were reproduced with a colour difference below ΔE 2.5, roughly the threshold where a trained eye starts to notice side by side. Limit: one press, one substrate and one ink set; colours outside the seven-colour gamut were not counted as matched.
Read the paper (free)At Toronto Metropolitan University, the authors printed CMYKOGV on a narrow-web flexo label press and compared two commercial separation systems, Esko Equinox and GMG OpenColor, each characterised with its own proprietary chart and with the generic Idealliance ECG chart. Across 27 in-gamut Pantone spot colours, average CIEDE2000 error was 1.55 (GMG, own chart) and 2.45 (Esko, own chart), rising to 2.94 and 3.49 with the generic chart; worst cases reached 3.87 and 9.93. Mid-tone neutrals such as Pantone 443 C were hardest, because the eye is very sensitive to small shifts in grey-blues. Limit: 27 colours and one press; results depend heavily on the software and characterisation.
Read the paper (free)See the data as a table
| Average (ΔE00) | 95th percentile (ΔE00) | |
|---|---|---|
| GMG, own chart | 1.55 | 3.22 |
| Esko, own chart | 2.45 | 4.77 |
| GMG, generic chart | 2.94 | 4.58 |
| Esko, generic chart | 3.49 | 6.15 |
Source: El Asaleh, Habekost and Sharma, JPMTR 2022 · CIEDE2000 between the Pantone Plus Solid Coated Lab values and the printed result. Lower is better; around 2 is a common acceptance limit for brand colours.
Of the Pantone colours inside the seven-ink gamut, 85% came within ΔE 2.5 of the target.Joshi, Shetye and Kolte, Acta Graphica, 2019
What the industry claims, and where ECG stops
The industry framing is similar. The JPMTR paper cites claims that CMYKOGV can cover up to 90% of the Pantone Plus book.
Fogra, the German print research institute, published FOGRA55 (version 4.0, September 2021) as a standard seven-colour exchange space with defined orange, green and violet primaries, so files can be prepared once and printed on any calibrated ECG press. What ECG cannot do:
- metallics and fluorescents;
- opaque whites;
- very light pastels that need a thin solid ink;
- brand colours that fall outside even the seven-ink gamut.

When should you actually use a spot colour?
Use a spot ink when the colour is out of gamut, when the area is large and flat, or when the same colour must match across many vendors and years; simulate it in CMYK or ECG when runs are short, digital or full of photographs. This decision path covers most jobs:
- Define the colour three ways. Pantone C and U references, Lab values, and screen values (sRGB hex or OKLCH). Our OKLCH guide covers the screen side.
- Check it against the CMYK book. If the Pantone + CMYK simulation is visibly off, the colour is a spot or ECG candidate.
- Ask the printer what is on the press. A digital press or a four-unit offset job usually means simulation; a six-plus-unit flexo or offset packaging line can run spot inks or ECG.
- Set a tolerance. Ask for ΔE2000 of 2 or less on the brand colour and a measured press proof, not a visual "looks fine".
- Keep the files clean. Logos and flat brand elements should be vector with the spot swatch named correctly; see vector vs raster for logos and print.
How far apart are your two colours?
Use this to check what you just read. Enter the Lab values of your target swatch (from Pantone Connect or the brand guide) and of the printed sample (from a spectrophotometer). The tool gives the simple CIE76 ΔE, a quick screen before a full ΔE2000 check.
Colour difference between target and print (CIE76 ΔE)
With the defaults, a print only 1.5 units darker and slightly less blue already gives ΔE 2.9, above the usual brand tolerance, which is exactly the kind of grey-blue the Toronto study found hardest to hold.
Is Pantone's Colour of the Year useful to designers?
As trend marketing, yes; as a design tool, barely. Pantone has named a Colour of the Year since 2000, beginning with Cerulean, and for 2026 it chose PANTONE 11-4201 Cloud Dancer, a soft white, announced in early December 2025.
Its six-digit, hyphenated code belongs to Pantone's textile and interiors numbering rather than the "C" and "U" graphic Matching System printers mix from, so it is a trend reference, not a print-ready ink.
For brand work, the more useful 2026 lesson is that the brand colours Indian consumers know best are owned by being consistent, not by being trendy; our planned piece on India's top brand colours and the brand guidelines template cover how to document them. For the marketing side of that argument, see the work page.

What's new
Questions people ask
Is Pantone becoming obsolete?
Not for packaging and brand colour communication, where it remains the common naming system between designers, brand owners and printers. What is fading is the need to print every Pantone as a separate ink, because calibrated CMYKOGV presses match most of them.
Why does my Pantone colour look different on screen?
Screens make colour with light in RGB and many spot inks sit outside the screen's gamut, or the screen is not calibrated. Use the Lab values and a colour-managed workflow, and judge spot colours only against a physical swatch under daylight-balanced light.
Do I need a Pantone colour for my small business logo?
You need a defined colour, and a Pantone reference is the cheapest way to tell a printer what you mean. Whether you pay for spot ink on each job depends on the run: business cards and flyers on digital presses are fine in CMYK; printed cartons or signage across vendors benefit from a spot ink.
Why do some Pantone colours have names?
The textile and fashion system (codes like 11-4201) uses names alongside numbers for marketing and trend work, while most graphic Matching System colours are known by number. Names such as Cloud Dancer are for the Colour of the Year programme and retail products.
Sources
- Joshi, A. V., Shetye, P. and Kolte, P.: Evaluation of Spot Color Reproduction by Extended Gamut Printing on a Narrow Web Flexography Press, Acta Graphica (2019)
- El Asaleh, R., Habekost, M. and Sharma, A.: Accuracy of spot color reproduction in a 7-color expanded gamut flexographic printing system, JPMTR (2022)
- Fogra: Multiprimary printing project 13.003 and FOGRA55 (2021)
- Print21: Adobe and Pantone in decree nisi (2022)
- Wikipedia: Pantone (company history, base inks, colour counts)
- ipcm: Pantone Colour of the Year 2026, 11-4201 Cloud Dancer (2025)
- Graphic Design Stack Exchange: Is Pantone becoming antiquated?
