How Meta Andromeda and Advantage+ decide which ad you see

Meta picks your ad in three steps, and the first one now reads your creative before it reads your targeting.

Entrance sign of the Facebook headquarters complex at 1 Hacker Way, Menlo Park
Photo: LPS.1, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons

Meta Andromeda is the retrieval engine that cuts tens of millions of eligible ads down to a few thousand for each person, before heavier ranking models (trained by Meta's GEM foundation model) score that shortlist and the auction picks a winner. Because retrieval now runs a deep neural network over the ad itself, your creative decides which people an ad can even compete for. Broad targeting plus many genuinely different creatives is how you feed it.

Key takeaways
  • Three stages: retrieval (Andromeda), ranking (GEM-trained models), then the auction.
  • Tens of millions → a few thousand: what Andromeda does to the eligible ads for each person.
  • 10,000× more retrieval model capacity since December 2024, so the creative itself now steers delivery.
  • Concepts, not variants: ten colour swaps of one idea count as one idea to a model that reads meaning.
  • 18.8 vs 2.8 new creatives a week: the largest accounts against the smallest in a 2026 benchmark.
  • 22% ROAS lift from Advantage+ is Meta's own figure; test it in your account before trusting it.

Most agency explainers of Meta Andromeda repeat one line from Meta and add a checklist. This post works from Meta's own engineering writing and the research papers underneath it, then turns that into account decisions for an Indian advertiser spending anywhere from ₹50,000 to a few crore a month.

The short version: the system has three stages, the first stage got 10,000 times more model capacity in December 2024, and that change explains most of the "my creatives die in four days" complaints you see on r/FacebookAds.

What is Meta Andromeda?

Meta Andromeda is the first stage of Meta's ad delivery, a personalised retrieval system that Meta announced in its engineering blog on 2 December 2024. Its job is narrow and brutal: from the tens of millions of ads that could legally be shown to a user at a given moment, return a few thousand that are worth scoring properly.

Meta says retrieval handles roughly three orders of magnitude more ads than the later stages, which is why it has to be cheap per ad.

The story

On 3 February 2022, Meta had the worst day in its history on Wall Street. The night before, it had told investors that Apple's iPhone privacy changes, which let users refuse app tracking, could cost it about $10 billion in lost sales that year. Facebook had also lost daily users for the first time ever.

The stock fell about 26% and more than $250 billion of market value disappeared, NPR reported. Mark Zuckerberg's answer on the call was that Meta was rebuilding much of its ads infrastructure to keep delivering personalised ads. With less tracking data about people, the rebuilt system would have to learn far more from the ads themselves. Andromeda, nearly three years later, is a large part of that rebuild.

NPR via WFAE: Facebook just had its worst day ever on Wall Street (3 Feb 2022)

What Meta changed in December 2024

What changed with Andromeda is how smart that cheap step became. Meta built it on NVIDIA's Grace Hopper Superchip and its own MTIA accelerator, stored precomputed ad embeddings in GPU memory, and moved feature extraction off CPUs. The company reported:

  • a 10,000-fold increase in retrieval model capacity;
  • a 6% recall improvement in the retrieval system;
  • an 8% ads-quality gain on selected segments;
  • more than 100 times faster feature extraction;
  • over 3 times more queries per second end to end.
10,000×increase in retrieval model capacity (Meta, Dec 2024)
+6%recall in the retrieval stage
+8%ads quality on selected segments
15 millionads made with Meta's GenAI tools in one month

That last number matters. Meta says more than a million advertisers used its generative AI tools to make over 15 million ads in a single month.

When the number of ad variants explodes, the old retrieval approach (a simple two-tower model matching a user vector to an ad vector) runs out of room to tell near-identical ads apart. Andromeda exists partly because generative AI multiplied the inventory it has to sort.

Close-up of an Nvidia graphics processor with passively cooled video memory chips on a circuit board
Andromeda moved ad retrieval from CPU-bound lookups onto GPUs, keeping ad embeddings in fast memory next to the processor.Photo: Brett Samuel, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

How does Meta pick an ad in three stages?

Meta picks an ad in three stages: retrieval (Andromeda) builds a shortlist, ranking models predict the value of each shortlisted ad, and the auction combines your bid with those predictions. Each stage sees fewer ads and spends more compute per ad.

Eligible ads: tens of millionsfiltered by budget, policy, audience limits, placement1. Retrieval: Andromedahierarchical index + neural network on GPUs, reads the creative2. Ranking: a few thousand adsGEM-trained models predict clicks, conversions, quality3. Auction: one ad shown
The three stages of Meta ad delivery, drawn from Meta's engineering posts. Your bid only matters at the last step; your creative matters from the first.
StageInputOutputWhat it usesWhat you control
Retrieval (Andromeda)Tens of millions of eligible adsA few thousand candidatesUser history, ad embeddings learned from creative, hierarchical ad indexCreative variety, landing page, conversion signal
Ranking (GEM-trained models, Lattice)A few thousand candidatesPredicted value per adClick, conversion and quality predictions, longer user historiesOptimisation event, data quality via Pixel and Conversions API
AuctionRanked ads with predictionsOne impressionYour bid times predicted action rate, plus ad qualityBid strategy, budget, cost caps

GEM and the ranking layer

The ranking layer has its own names. Meta's November 2025 engineering post describes GEM, the Generative Ads Recommendation Model, as the largest recommendation foundation model in the industry; it does not serve ads itself but teaches the smaller ranking models on each surface.

Meta credited it with 5% more ad conversions on Instagram and 3% on Facebook Feed in Q2 2025. In October 2026, AdExchanger reported a further round of upgrades, including a generative retrieval model called GenRecs that adds candidates to Andromeda's shortlist in parallel with the original retriever.

Why does Andromeda read the creative instead of the audience?

Andromeda reads the creative because the ad's learned embedding, built from what the image, video and text are about and who has responded to similar ads, is now the strongest signal it has for deciding who should see it.

Your interest and lookalike settings still exist, but in Advantage+ campaigns they act as suggestions, not fences.

What the HSNN paper shows

The research behind Andromeda explains why. Meta engineers published the retrieval model as the Hierarchical Structured Neural Network (HSNN).

SetupResultCost vs two-tower
Three-layer HSNN, offline (about 10 million items)+10% recall4.5×
Flat model chasing a similar gain+12% recall64×
Best HSNN, production A/B on Meta Ads+2.57% online ads metric (significance bar 0.1%)Not reported

The point for an advertiser is that retrieval stopped being a coarse lookup and started modelling the interaction between a specific person and a specific ad.

Hierarchical Structured Neural Network: Efficient Retrieval Scaling for Large Scale RecommendationKaushik Rangadurai et al. · arXiv 2408.06653 · 2024 (revised 2025)

Meta's engineers describe the retrieval model family behind Andromeda: a mixture of modular neural networks trained jointly with a hierarchical index of items, so cost grows sublinearly with the number of ads. Offline, a three-layer HSNN gave a 10% recall gain and a 1.46% normalised-entropy gain over a two-tower baseline at 4.5 times the compute; a flat model needed 64 times the compute for a 12% recall gain. Online, on Meta Ads, the best variant lifted the main ads metric by 2.57%. Limit: it is an industry paper with no public dataset, so outsiders cannot replicate the numbers, and it does not report latency.

Read the paper (free)
Actions Speak Louder than Words: Trillion-Parameter Sequential Transducers for Generative RecommendationsJiaqi Zhai et al. · ICML 2024

This Meta paper reframes recommendation as a sequence problem, like next-word prediction, and introduces the HSTU architecture. Models reached 1.5 trillion parameters, ran 5.3 to 15.2 times faster than FlashAttention2 Transformers on 8,192-long sequences, and improved online A/B metrics by 12.4%. Quality scaled as a power law with training compute across three orders of magnitude. It is the clearest public evidence for why GEM reads longer user histories. Limit: tests ran on Meta surfaces and public datasets, and ads results are not broken out.

Read the paper (free)

What is Advantage+ and why is it now the default?

Advantage+ is Meta's name for automated campaign settings (audience, placements, budget and creative), and since 2025 it is the default setup for Sales, App and Leads campaigns rather than a separate campaign type.

How it became the default

  • February 2025: Meta began testing a streamlined flow where new campaigns start with Advantage+ switched on, and renamed Advantage+ Shopping campaigns to Advantage+ Sales.
  • In the same update it reported that Advantage+ leads campaigns in early tests got a 10% lower cost per qualified lead.
  • October 2025: it deprecated the legacy Advantage+ Shopping and App campaign APIs in favour of a single structure.

Why automation and Andromeda go together

The reason is mechanical. Andromeda and the GEM-trained rankers do their best work when they can match any ad to any person. Narrow audiences and split ad sets shrink the pool retrieval can search, so the model has less to work with.

In Meta's December 2024 post, advertisers who switched on Advantage+ creative and AI-driven targeting saw a 22% ROAS improvement.

Mark Zuckerberg speaking on stage at the Facebook F8 developer conference in 2018
Meta's leadership has said the end goal is automated ad creation: an advertiser supplies a product, a budget and a goal, and the system does the rest.Photo: Anthony Quintano from Honolulu, HI, United States, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Where this is heading was spelled out in June 2025, when the Wall Street Journal reported that Meta aims to let brands create and target ads fully with AI by the end of 2026. Whether or not that deadline holds, the direction for anyone running accounts is clear: fewer manual levers, more weight on inputs.

Why do creatives seem to burn out faster now?

Creatives seem to burn out faster because Andromeda groups ads it reads as similar, so ten minor variants of one idea often compete for the same small pocket of people and exhaust it together. What looks like fatigue is frequently audience exhaustion for a concept, not for a file.

Variants vs concepts 10 variants of 1 ideaone pocket of people,used up together 4 distinct concepts4 pockets of people
An illustration of the idea, not a map of Meta's real embedding space: near-identical ads land close together, so they compete for the same people. Distinct promises, personas, formats or languages spread out.

What advertisers report

The r/FacebookAds threads in the plan for this post show both sides:

  • In one January 2026 thread, an advertiser described new creatives converting for a few days then dying; replies split between "your audience pool is exhausted" and "you are cycling them wrong".
  • A May 2026 thread argued that advertisers label every drop as fatigue when the delivery environment changed, and reported ads that died in one campaign and worked again in a fresh setup with no creative change.

Both observations fit the three-stage model: if retrieval stops pulling your ad into the shortlist for new people, the ad looks dead even though nothing about it changed.

Fatigue or delivery? A two-way test

Meta's own Ads Manager has a narrower definition. Its "creative fatigue" label compares cost per result against your past ads and only works for ad sets with one creative. For everything else you need your own test:

  • If a new concept in the same ad set restores results, it was fatigue.
  • If the old ad recovers in a fresh campaign, it was delivery.
New creatives launched per week, by monthly Meta spend
See the data as a table
Creatives launched per week (per week)
Under $10K2.8
$10K–50K4.1
$50K–200K6.6
$200K–1M11.2
Over $1M18.8

Source: Creative Benchmarks 2026: scale and volume · Hit rate (share of creatives that became winners) rose from 4.0% in the smallest tier to 8.8% in the largest. The report does not state its sample size or how a winner is defined.

The benchmark data above points the same way. Accounts spending over $1 million a month launched 18.8 new creatives a week, about 6.7 times the 2.8 launched by accounts under $10,000, and their hit rate was about twice as high (8.8% against 4.0%).

Bigger accounts don't just test more; they find winners more often, which is what you'd expect if retrieval rewards a wide spread of distinct ads. The report doesn't publish its sample size, so read it as direction rather than a precise rate.

Monthly Meta spendCreatives per weekHit rate
Under $10K (about ₹8.5 lakh)2.84.0%
$10K–50K4.16.4%
$50K–200K6.68.1%
$200K–1M11.28.6%
Over $1M18.88.8%

How many winners will your cadence produce?

Use this to check what you just read. Put in your weekly launches, how many of them are genuinely new concepts, and a hit rate; the default 4.0% is the benchmark's smallest spend tier.

Concepts and expected winners per month

At the default four launches a week and a 4% hit rate, you wait about six weeks for one winner. That is why concept count, not file count, is the lever.

How should an Indian advertiser structure a Meta account for Andromeda?

Structure it so retrieval has a large pool and many distinct ideas: few campaigns, broad audiences, one strong conversion signal, and creative variety measured in concepts rather than file count. Many accounts do the opposite, with many small ad sets split by city, age band and interest.

  1. Consolidate. One prospecting campaign per objective and margin profile, not one per city or interest. Every split divides the data the ranking models learn from.
  2. Go broad on audience. Keep exclusions that are real business rules (existing customers, unserviceable PIN codes via location) and drop interest stacks. In Advantage+ they are suggestions anyway.
  3. Fix the signal first. Retrieval and ranking optimise toward the events you send. Pixel plus a deduplicated Conversions API setup is the floor, not an extra.
  4. Count concepts, not variants. A concept is a different promise, persona, format or setting. Ten colour swaps of one static count as one concept to a model that reads meaning. Aim for a weekly cadence in line with your spend tier.
  5. Write for Indian languages deliberately. A Hindi, Tamil or Bengali version with its own hook is a new concept. A subtitle swap is a variant.
  6. Test with a method. Use a structured creative testing framework and decide refresh timing from data, as in how often to refresh Meta creatives.
Your bid only matters at the last step; your creative matters from the first.From the three-stage model above, drawn from Meta's engineering posts

This is the shift from performance marketing as bid management to performance marketing as a creative and data operation, which I trace in the history of performance marketing.

It also fits how I think marketing teams should work: small, highly competent teams with strong systems, and AI cutting the repetitive production. The work page shows what that has looked like in practice.

What does Andromeda not change?

Andromeda does not change the auction maths or the need for a product people want. Your bid, your conversion rate and your landing page still decide what you pay once an ad reaches the auction.

  • Bad offers still lose. Ranking predicts conversion. A weak offer predicts poorly at every stage.
  • Meta's numbers are Meta's. The 22% ROAS, 10% cost-per-lead and 5% conversion figures are self-reported. Run your own holdout or geo tests before believing any platform's lift.
  • Small budgets still learn slowly. An account with 20 conversions a week gives ranking models little to calibrate on, whatever the retrieval capacity.

Questions people ask

Is Meta Andromeda a new campaign type I need to switch on?

No. Andromeda is back-end infrastructure that serves every campaign. You don't opt in. What you control is how much room you give it: broad audiences, consolidated campaigns and varied creative.

Do interest targeting and lookalikes still work after Andromeda?

They still run, but in Advantage+ audience they work as starting suggestions the system can expand beyond. Hard limits remain for things like age minimums and locations. For most prospecting, broad plus strong creative now matches or beats stacked interests, though you should confirm that in your own account with a split test.

How many creatives should a small Indian brand run?

Benchmark data shows accounts under $10,000 a month launching about 3 creatives a week. A practical floor is 3 to 5 genuinely different concepts live per campaign, refreshed when cost per result climbs on the winners. Volume without variety does little, because near-duplicates get treated as the same ad.

Why did my winning ad stop delivering when I added new ads?

New ads change what retrieval and ranking compare. If a new ad is predicted to do better for the same people, spend shifts to it. If the new ads are near-copies, they can split delivery without adding reach. Launch new concepts in a separate test before adding them to a proven ad set.

Sources

  1. Engineering at Meta: Meta Andromeda, Advantage+ automation's next-gen personalised ads retrieval engine (2024)
  2. Rangadurai et al.: Hierarchical Structured Neural Network for retrieval, arXiv 2408.06653 (2024)
  3. Zhai et al.: Actions Speak Louder than Words, trillion-parameter sequential transducers, ICML (2024)
  4. Engineering at Meta: Meta's Generative Ads Model (GEM) (2025)
  5. AdExchanger: Meta has a new ad ranking system built on LLMs, plus upgrades to Andromeda and GEM (2026)
  6. Creative Benchmarks 2026: scale and volume (2026)
  7. Jon Loomer: Advantage+ Sales, App and Leads campaigns (2025)
  8. Social Media Today: Meta Advantage+ ad updates (2025)
  9. PPC Land: Meta deprecates legacy campaign APIs for Advantage+ structure (2025)
  10. Verdict: Meta to fully automate ad creation with AI by end of 2026, citing the Wall Street Journal (2025)
  11. NPR via WFAE: Facebook just had its worst day ever on Wall Street (Feb 2022)
meta andromedaadvantage+meta adsad retrievalcreative strategyGEM
Sapta

Sapta (Saptarshi Sarkar) is a mechanical engineer turned marketer in Bengaluru and a solo touring rider. He writes the seven Saptaverse blogs. Work with him or read more of Marketblog.

Keep reading in Marketblog

From the other blogs