CTC vs orthodox tea: oxidation, theaflavins and your cup

The same Assam leaf becomes a dark, punchy chai base or a bright, aromatic pot depending on how hard it is broken. The difference is written in theaflavins and thearubigins.

Processed CTC tea granules being graded on a sieve machine in an Indian tea factory
Photo: shankar s. from Dubai, united arab emirates, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

CTC (crush, tear, curl) tea is made by shredding withered leaf between serrated steel rollers, which smashes every cell, lets polyphenol oxidase reach the catechins at once and drives fast, near-complete oxidation into theaflavins and thearubigins. Orthodox tea is rolled more gently, so leaf pieces stay larger, oxidation is slower and more of the aroma survives. Tocklai's analysis of Assam clones found CTC with about 1.30% theaflavins and 18% thearubigins against 0.59% and 6.5% for orthodox, which is why CTC brews dark, strong and fast for milk chai, while orthodox is brisker, lighter and more fragrant.

Key takeaways
  • 88% of the tea India made in 2025 was CTC (1,227.66 of 1,395.53 million kg).
  • 18% vs 6.5% thearubigins in CTC vs orthodox: the source of chai's dark colour and body.
  • 2× the aroma: orthodox kept more than twice the flavour volatiles in Tocklai's comparison.
  • 20 minutes: theaflavins peaked that fast during CTC oxidation in an Assam factory study.
  • 3–4% caffeine by dry weight in black tea either way; the method barely changes it.

India has picked its side. The Tea Board's final figures for calendar 2025 show 1,227.66 million kg of CTC out of 1,395.53 million kg in total: 88% of everything the country made. Orthodox was 149.04 million kg, under 11%, and green tea 18.83 million kg.

Yet the export growth of 2025 came mostly from orthodox. This post explains the chemistry that separates the two, from the enzyme to the colour in the cup, using Tocklai Tea Research Institute data, two Indian lab studies and the Tea Board's production tables.

88%CTC share of India's 2025 tea output (Tea Board, final)
18% vs 6.5%thearubigins in CTC vs orthodox (Tocklai, Assam clones)
280.40 mkgrecord tea exports in 2025, led by orthodox
3–4%caffeine in black tea, dry weight (Tocklai)

What is the difference between CTC and orthodox tea?

Both are black teas from the same plant, Camellia sinensis, and both go through withering, rolling, oxidation and drying. The difference is the rolling step: orthodox rollers twist the leaf; a CTC machine cuts it into tiny granules.

The story

For nearly a century, Assam's tea industry made black tea the orthodox way, in a style that imitated hand-rolling. In 1931 William McKercher, superintendent of the Amgoorie Tea Company on the south bank of the Brahmaputra, introduced a machine that did something else entirely: instead of twisting the withered leaf, it crushed, tore and curled it.

Accounts differ on the exact garden. Goodricke, whose Amgoorie estate page credits him as Sir W.G. McKercher, says it happened at Amgoorie; a 2023 World Tea News history places it at Borbam Tea Estate in Sivasagar district. They agree on the year and the man, and on the result: the CTC machine changed black tea manufacture for good. Ninety-four years later, it accounted for 1,227.66 million kg of the tea India made in 2025, 88% of the total.

World Tea News (Pullock Dutta): Assam celebrates 200-year tea history, Jan 2023; Goodricke: Amgoorie tea estate
StepOrthodoxCTC
WitheringWither tuned so the leaf twists rather than shattersTypically lighter; one Assam study withered 16–18 h, from 76–78% to 68–70% moisture
MacerationRolling tables twist and bruise; leaf stays largely whole or brokenIn one Assam trial, 15 min of rolling, then 3 passes through toothed CTC rollers
Cell damagePartialAlmost total
Oxidation ("fermentation")Slower, uneven through the leafFast and uniform; about 60 min at 30°C and 95% humidity in one trial
Dried productTwisted leaf, broken grades, fanningsUniform hard pellets
BrewLighter liquor, more aroma, briskDark, thick liquor in 2–3 minutes, holds up to milk

Not really fermentation

The word "fermentation" in tea factories is a misnomer. No microbes are involved; it is enzymatic oxidation inside the broken leaf.

That is also why the gap between the two methods is so large: CTC is not a different recipe so much as a far more efficient way of mixing an enzyme with its substrate.

Same leaf, two factories OrthodoxCTC Witherleaf stays pliable Witherlighter wither Roll and twistsome cells broken Crush, tear, curlalmost every cell broken Oxidiseslow, uneven Oxidisefast, uniform Drytwisted leaf Dryhard pellets TF 0.59%, TR 6.5%more aroma, lighter cup TF 1.30%, TR 18%dark, strong, fast brew TF = theaflavins, TR = thearubigins (Tocklai, Assam clones)
The only step that differs in kind is maceration. Everything downstream follows from how many cells it breaks.
Machinery in an Indian factory processing tea leaf by the crush, tear and curl method
CTC rollers turn withered leaf into a wet, uniform mash in seconds. Every cell is broken.Photo: shankar s. from Dubai, united arab emirates, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

How does oxidation turn green leaf into black tea?

Polyphenol oxidase (PPO) and peroxidase in the leaf oxidise catechins, mainly EGCG, ECG, EGC and EC, into quinones. Pairs of these quinones condense into theaflavins (orange-red, bright, astringent), and further polymerisation gives thearubigins (brown-red, body, colour).

The sequence inside the leaf

  1. Separation. In the intact leaf the enzyme and the catechins are kept apart in different compartments of the cell.
  2. Mixing. Rolling breaks the walls and the reaction starts the moment oxygen arrives. Withering helps by softening the leaf and concentrating its contents.
  3. Stopping. Drying at high heat stops the enzyme for good.

Measured on a real CTC line

Tocklai and Indian university labs have measured how fast this runs on real factory lines. During CTC processing of eight Assam cultivars, total catechins fell by more than 96%, EGCG by more than 97%, and total polyphenols by 26 to 37% from fresh leaf to finished tea.

Theaflavins peaked after only 20 minutes of oxidation and then dipped as they were drawn into thearubigins. Caffeine, untouched by PPO, rose slightly (1.09 to 1.27 times, mostly during withering).

CatechinsEGCG, ECG, EGC, EC Quinonesreactive, short-lived Theaflavinsorange-red, briskCTC 1.30% / orth 0.59% Thearubiginsbrown, body, colourCTC 18% / orth 6.5% PPO + O₂pairs condensepolymerise over time
Oxidation pathway in black tea. Figures are Tocklai's averages for Assam clones; thearubigin chemistry is still only partly resolved.
Changes in major catechins, caffeine, and antioxidant activity during CTC processing of black tea from North East IndiaDeka, Sarmah, Devi, Tamuly and Karak · RSC Advances · 2021

Leaf from eight Tocklai cultivars, plucked on one Assam estate in July and August 2017, was sampled at every CTC stage: fresh, withered, rolled, after the CTC cut, after 20 and 40 minutes of oxidation, and as finished tea. UPLC showed EGCG falling by over 97% and total catechins by over 96%; total polyphenols fell 26 to 37%. Theaflavins peaked at 20 minutes, fell 13 to 36% by 40 minutes, and the best cultivars ended near 17 to 18 mg/g. Caffeine rose up to 27%, mostly in withering. The limit: one estate, one season and one run per cultivar, and thearubigins were not measured.

Read the paper (free)

Why does CTC brew darker and stronger than orthodox?

Two reasons: more of the leaf has been converted to coloured, soluble thearubigins, and tiny granules expose far more surface to hot water. CTC delivers its colour and body in two or three minutes; orthodox leaf unfolds slowly.

Tocklai's comparison of orthodox and CTC teas from the same Assam clones gives the clearest picture. CTC had more than twice the theaflavins and almost three times the thearubigins, plus slightly more water-soluble solids. Orthodox kept more than twice the flavour volatiles, more carotenoids (which break down into aroma compounds) and much more chlorophyll.

Measure (Assam clones, average)OrthodoxCTC
Theaflavins (%)0.591.30
Thearubigins (%)6.518.00
Water-soluble solids (%)39.5241.12
Flavour volatiles (relative GC peak area)18.408.20
Carotenoids (µg/g)215176
Chlorophyll a (mg/g)1.380.48
Total lipid3.113.68
Total fibre (%)19.3518.93

Read the table as a trade-off

  • CTC wins on everything milk can't hide: colour, body, astringent bite, speed.
  • Orthodox wins on everything milk would bury: volatile aroma, the green and floral notes, the "brisk" brightness tasters prize.

Caffeine is about 3 to 4% of dry weight in black tea either way, so a cup's caffeine depends more on how much leaf you use and how long you boil it than on the method. More on that in caffeine in Indian drinks ranked. Use this to check what you just read:

Caffeine in the tea leaf you use

Loose orthodox Darjeeling tea leaves, twisted and multi-coloured
Orthodox Darjeeling: twisted leaf, slower oxidation, a lighter liquor that keeps its aroma.Photo: Vyacheslav Argenberg, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

How do time and temperature change theaflavins?

Theaflavins form fast and then get consumed, so there is an optimum oxidation time, and it gets longer as the room gets cooler. Cooler oxidation gives a better theaflavin-to-thearubigin ratio; warmer oxidation gives more colour.

What the lab found at four temperatures

An Indian lab study oxidised macerated leaf at 20, 25, 30 and 35°C and tracked the chemistry minute by minute:

  • theaflavins peaked at about 40 minutes at 30 and 35°C, at 60 minutes at 25°C and at 80 minutes at 20°C;
  • the highest theaflavin accumulation came at 20°C;
  • thearubigins and liquor colour rose with temperature and time;
  • polyphenol oxidase stayed at about 90% stability for 40 minutes at 25 to 35°C and above 90% for about 80 minutes at 20°C.

A factory that runs its oxidation room hot in an Assam summer is trading brightness for colour.

Assessing biochemical changes during standardization of fermentation time and temperature for manufacturing quality black teaSamanta, Cheeni, Das, Basu Roy, Ghosh and Mitra · Journal of Food Science and Technology · 2015 (online 2013)

Macerated tea leaf was oxidised at four temperatures (20 to 35°C) and sampled over time for catechins, theaflavins, thearubigins, PPO activity, brightness and colour. Total theaflavins peaked at about 40 minutes at 30 to 35°C but took 80 minutes at 20°C, where the peak was highest; the theaflavin-to-thearubigin ratio and brightness were also best at 20°C. Thearubigins and colour peaked at 35°C. The authors recommend cooler, longer oxidation for quality. The limit: lab-scale oxidation of one leaf source, and caffeine was not measured.

Read the paper (free)
CTC is not a different recipe so much as a far more efficient way of mixing an enzyme with its substrate. The core of the CTC vs orthodox difference
Fresh green tea leaves spread in a withering trough in a Darjeeling tea factory
Withering softens the leaf and concentrates it before rolling. Caffeine rises slightly at this stage.Photo: shankar s. from Dubai, united arab emirates, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

How much of India's tea is CTC and how much is orthodox?

CTC dominates. In calendar 2025 India produced 1,227.66 million kg of CTC, 149.04 million kg of orthodox and 18.83 million kg of green tea, out of 1,395.53 million kg, according to the Tea Board's final figures.

India tea production by type, calendar 2025
See the data as a table
2025 (million kg)
CTC1227.66
Orthodox149.04
Green18.83

Source: Tea Board of India: Region-wise category-wise tea production 2025 and 2025-26 (final)

North and south

The split differs sharply by region:

  • North India (Assam, West Bengal and others) made 1,161.30 million kg, 89% of it CTC.
  • South India (Tamil Nadu, Kerala, Karnataka) made 234.23 million kg, with orthodox at 17% of its output, a much larger share than the north.
  • Darjeeling, the famous orthodox district, produced only 5.60 million kg in 2025, about 0.4% of India's tea.
Tea production by region and type, 2025
See the data as a table
CTC (million kg)Orthodox (million kg)Green (million kg)
North India1038.92109.3213.06
South India188.7439.725.77

Source: Tea Board of India: final production 2025

Why did India go CTC? Domestic demand is overwhelmingly boiled milk chai, and CTC gives more cups per kilo of dark, strong liquor at a lower price. The history of how the industry got here, from the Assam wild plant to Darjeeling's Chinese bushes, is in the history of tea in India.

Is orthodox tea becoming more important?

For exports, yes. India shipped a record 280.40 million kg of tea in 2025, up from 256.17 million kg in 2024, worth ₹8,488.43 crore, and traders credited the growth mainly to orthodox tea while CTC exports stayed flat.

Price pressure on CTC

The Tea Board's deputy chairperson urged small growers to move from CTC to orthodox, pointing to buyers such as China. The pressure on CTC is price: the Indian Tea Association said the all-India average auction price fell 7.13% in 2025 to ₹186.92/kg.

Production in January to March 2026 dropped about 12% from a year earlier after a dry start in Assam. The Tea Board's own tables put January to March 2026 at 97.61 million kg against 110.40 million kg a year earlier.

Which is better for masala chai?

CTC, for most people. Boiled with milk and sugar, CTC's thearubigins give the colour and body that stand up to dilution, while orthodox's aroma mostly boils away and its lighter liquor looks thin.

Orthodox teas earn their price brewed in water at the right temperature, without boiling, where their volatiles and theaflavin brightness come through. For ratios and timing, see how to brew masala chai, and if your milk splits with ginger, the enzyme story is in why milk curdles with ginger.

A glass of milky masala chai
Milky chai needs colour and body that survive dilution, which is what CTC's high thearubigin content supplies.Photo: Ganesh Mohan T, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Questions people ask

Is CTC tea lower quality than orthodox?

Not lower quality, a different target. CTC is engineered for strong, dark liquor and fast brewing with milk. Orthodox keeps more aroma volatiles and sells for more, but a good CTC is the right tea for chai.

Does CTC tea have more caffeine?

Not by much per gram. Black tea runs about 3 to 4% caffeine by dry weight whichever way it's made. CTC releases it faster, and chai is often boiled with more leaf, so the cup can carry more.

Why is it called fermentation if no microbes are involved?

It is an old factory term. The change is enzymatic oxidation: polyphenol oxidase in the broken leaf turns catechins into theaflavins and thearubigins.

Is Darjeeling tea CTC or orthodox?

Darjeeling is overwhelmingly orthodox, made in small volumes: about 5.60 million kg in 2025, under half a percent of India's output.

Which has more antioxidants, CTC or orthodox?

Both lose most of their catechins in oxidation; in one Assam CTC study, catechins fell over 96% and antioxidant assays fell 17 to 71%. The theaflavins that form are antioxidants too, so the difference in a cup is smaller than marketing claims.

More from the Taste Lab on Rasa.

Sources

  1. Tea Board of India: Final tea production 2025 (Jan-Dec) and 2025-26, region-wise and category-wise (2026)
  2. Tocklai Tea Research Institute: Composition of orthodox and CTC teas (theaflavins, thearubigins, volatiles, caffeine) (accessed 2026; caffeine range used in the calculator)
  3. Deka et al.: Changes in major catechins, caffeine, and antioxidant activity during CTC processing of black tea from North East India, RSC Advances 11:11457 (2021)
  4. Samanta et al.: Assessing biochemical changes during standardization of fermentation time and temperature for manufacturing quality black tea, J Food Sci Technol (2015)
  5. Food Business MEA: India records highest-ever tea exports in 2025 (2026)
  6. Outlook Business: ITA flags financial stress in tea sector despite record exports (2026)
  7. World Tea News (Pullock Dutta), via History of Ceylon Tea: Assam celebrates 200-year tea history (McKercher, 1931) (2023; source for the story)
  8. Goodricke Group: Amgoorie tea estate (Sir W.G. McKercher and the CTC machine, 1931) (accessed 2026)
CTC teaorthodox teatheaflavinsthearubiginspolyphenol oxidaseTea Board of IndiaAssamDarjeelingTocklai
Sapta

Sapta (Saptarshi Sarkar) is a mechanical engineer turned marketer in Bengaluru and a solo touring rider. He writes the seven Saptaverse blogs. Work with him or read more of Foodblog.

Keep reading in Foodblog

From the other blogs